How to Compare Car Insurance Rates 2024
How Does LendingTree Get Paid?
LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

How Does LendingTree Get Paid?

LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

Cheapest Car Insurance in Nebraska (2025)

Published on:
Content was accurate at the time of publication.

Best cheap car insurance in Nebraska

($1,391/year)
Cheapest full coverage: State Farm
State Farm logo
($382/year)
Cheapest liability: Progressive
Progressive logo
($2,532/year)
Cheapest for bad credit: Geico
Geico logo
+
More Options

Find the Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in Nebraska

At $1,391 a year, State Farm has the cheapest full-coverage car insurance in Nebraska. State Farm’s rate is 28% less than the state average rate for full-coverage policies, $1,933 a year.

Progressive has the second-cheapest full-coverage insurance quotes for most Nebraskans at $1,712 a year, on average.

Both companies offer several car insurance discounts that can save you money, but Progressive has some that can be easy to get. Progressive has discounts for getting an online quote, signing online, receiving documents through email and setting up automatic payments.

Cheapest car insurance companies in Nebraska

Full-coverage car insurance rates by company

CompanyAnnual rateLendingTree score
state farm logoState Farm$1,3914.5 stars
progressive logoProgressive$1,7124 stars
geico logoGeico$1,8613.5 stars
American Family logoAmerican Family$2,0414 stars
farm bureau logoFarm Bureau$2,0534 stars
nationwide logoNationwide$2,1493 stars
allstate logoAllstate$2,7723 stars
usaa logoUSAA*$1,4884 stars

Progressive has the cheapest liability car insurance for Nebraska drivers at an average rate of $382 a year. This is 33% lower than the state average of $570 a year.

USAA is even cheaper, with an average liability insurance rate of $378 a year — however, only members of the military and their families can buy from USAA.

State Farm comes in second for most drivers in Nebraska at $408 a year. Geico is close behind at $412 a year.

Liability-only car insurance rates by company

CompanyAnnual rate
Progressive$382
State Farm$408
Geico$412
Farm Bureau$422
American Family$588
Nationwide$917
Allstate$1,056
USAA*$378

Find the Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in Nebraska

With an average rate of $1,179 a year, Geico has the cheapest car insurance for young drivers in Nebraska who buy only liability coverage. Geico’s rate is 36% cheaper than the state average of $1,835 a year.

State Farm has the most affordable full-coverage insurance for Nebraska’s young drivers at about $3,786 a year. This is 28% less than the state average rate ($5,240 a year).

Cheapest car insurance companies for young drivers

CompanyLiability onlyFull coverage
Geico$1,179$4,570
State Farm$1,340$3,786
Farm Bureau$1,463$4,651
American Family$1,857$4,877
Progressive$2,032$7,506
Allstate$2,638$5,364
Nationwide$3,120$7,476
USAA*$1,053$3,692

To get cheap teen car insurance or lower your rate in Nebraska:

  • See if you qualify for discounts aimed at young drivers
  • Sign up for usage-based car insurance and drive safely
  • If you’re a parent, add your teen driver to your policy
  • If you’re a teen driver, get added to your parent’s policy
Nebraska drivers can get the cheapest car insurance from State Farm after a speeding ticket or similar traffic violation. State Farm’s average quote after a ticket is $1,484 a year.

The state average quote after a ticket is $2,277 a year. State Farm is 35% less.

Best car insurance companies with a speeding ticket

CompanyAnnual rate
State Farm$1,484
American Family$2,041
Geico$2,286
Farm Bureau$2,331
Progressive$2,382
Nationwide$2,830
Allstate$3,045
USAA*$1,817

American Family is the second-cheapest company for most drivers in Nebraska with a ticket on their records at $2,041 a year.

American Family offers a lot of discounts that could make it cheaper for you than State Farm. You can get discounts from American Family for:

  • Getting a quote seven days before your policy starts
  • Enrolling in automatic payments and online billing
  • Paying in full when you buy your policy

The average driver in Nebraska sees their car insurance premium go up 18% after a speeding ticket.

State Farm has the cheapest car insurance after an accident in Nebraska at $1,577 a year. State Farm’s rate is nearly half the state average rate after an accident ($2,903 a year).

American Family and Progressive also offer rates that are cheaper than the state average, though both are a lot more expensive than State Farm.

An at-fault accident causes your car insurance to go up 50% in Nebraska, on average.

Cheapest car insurance rates after an accident

CompanyAnnual rate
State Farm$1,577
American Family$2,443
Progressive$2,838
Farm Bureau$3,251
Nationwide$3,487
Geico$3,704
Allstate$3,958
USAA*$1,962

Cheap auto insurance for Nebraska teens with a bad driving record: State Farm

Most teens in Nebraska with a bad driving record can get the cheapest car insurance from State Farm.
  • State Farm’s average quote for teen drivers with a ticket on their records is $1,486 a year.
  • The company’s average quote after an accident is $1,632 a year.

Cheapest insurance for teens with a ticket or accident

CompanyTicketAccident
State Farm$1,486$1,632
Geico$1,605$1,974
Farm Bureau$1,661$2,317
American Family$1,857$2,260
Progressive$2,247$2,428
Allstate$3,024$4,388
Nationwide$3,373$3,412
USAA*$1,379$1,519

Geico comes in second in both cases, with average rates that aren’t much higher than State Farm’s. Geico offers more discounts than State Farm does, so get and compare car insurance quotes from both companies to see which will give you the best deal.

Find the Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in Nebraska

American Family has the cheapest DUI insurance in Nebraska, with quotes that average $2,041 a year. This is 40% cheaper than the state average quote after a DUI of $3,375 a year.

Progressive’s average quote with a DUI (driving under the influence) conviction is nearly as cheap as American Family’s at $2,111 a year. Farm Bureau and State Farm also have rates that are well below the state average.

In Nebraska, a DUI causes your car insurance to go up an average of 75%.

Cheapest car insurance quotes after a DUI

CompanyAnnual rate
American Family$2,041
Progressive$2,111
Farm Bureau$2,331
State Farm$2,653
Allstate$3,607
Nationwide$4,718
Geico$6,185
USAA*$3,351

At $2,532 a year, Geico is the best company for cheap car insurance with poor credit in Nebraska. Geico’s average rate for poor credit is 32% lower than the state average rate of $3,712 a year.

Progressive is close behind at $2,803 a year. Nationwide is third at $3,094 a year.

It’s a good idea to compare quotes from several companies if you have bad credit, as not all companies will charge you a higher rate because of it.

Cheapest car insurance companies for poor credit

CompanyAnnual rate
Geico$2,532
Progressive$2,803
Nationwide$3,094
American Family$3,496
Farm Bureau$3,844
Allstate$4,280
State Farm$7,089
USAA*$2,555

State Farm is Nebraska’s best car insurance company because of its:

  • Low rates for most drivers and coverage types
  • Good customer service ratings
  • Strong financial strength rating

American Family, Farm Bureau and USAA have better customer satisfaction ratings from J.D. Power, but State Farm beats them in most other areas.

Nebraska car insurance company ratings

CompanyJ.D. Power**AM BestLendingTree
Allstate635A+3 stars
American Family660A4 stars
Farm Bureau673A4 stars
Geico637A++3.5 stars
Nationwide641A3 stars
Progressive622A+4 stars
State Farm657A++4.5 stars
USAA*739A++4 stars

*USAA only sells insurance to members of the military and their families.
**Source: J.D. Power 2024 U.S. Auto Insurance Study. Higher is better; 644 is average.

Drivers in York pay Nebraska’s cheapest car insurance rates at $1,730 a year, on average. With an average rate of $2,144 a year, Palisade drivers pay the state’s highest car insurance rates.

The average cost of car insurance in Nebraska’s biggest cities and suburbs:

  • Omaha, $2,046 a year
  • Lincoln, $1,784 a year
  • Bellevue, $1,879 a year
  • Grand Island, $1,810 a year

Car insurance rates near you

CityAnnual rate% from average
Abie$1,826-4%
Albion$1,881-1%
Alda$1,802-5%
Alexandria$1,815-4%
Allen$1,799-5%
Alliance$1,9754%
Alvo$1,876-1%
Amelia$1,9402%
Ames$1,854-2%
Amherst$1,822-4%
Angora$2,0176%
Anselmo$2,0106%
Ansley$2,0307%
Arapahoe$1,9231%
Arcadia$1,9945%
Archer$1,807-5%
Arlington$1,8930%
Ashby$2,0508%
Ashland$1,9261%
Ashton$1,9684%
Atkinson$1,9573%
Atlanta$1,820-4%
Auburn$1,813-5%
Aurora$1,766-7%
Axtell$1,775-7%
Ayr$1,794-6%
Barneston$1,878-1%
Bartlett$1,9794%
Bartley$2,09810%
Bassett$1,9804%
Battle Creek$1,840-3%
Bayard$2,0428%
Beatrice$1,869-2%
Beaver Crossing$1,804-5%
Bee$1,841-3%
Beemer$1,836-3%
Belden$1,838-3%
Belgrade$1,890-1%
Bellevue$1,879-1%
Bellwood$1,797-5%
Belvidere$1,801-5%
Benedict$1,778-6%
Benkelman$2,13112%
Bennet$1,9040%
Bennington$1,9151%
Bertrand$1,855-2%
Bingham$2,0126%
Bladen$1,838-3%
Blair$1,9593%
Bloomfield$1,837-3%
Bloomington$1,839-3%
Blue Hill$1,806-5%
Blue Springs$1,9000%
Boelus$1,841-3%
Boys Town$1,883-1%
Bradshaw$1,738-8%
Brady$2,0327%
Brainard$1,801-5%
Brewster$2,0307%
Bridgeport$2,0337%
Bristow$1,9442%
Broadwater$2,0267%
Brock$1,826-4%
Broken Bow$1,9653%
Brule$2,0598%
Bruno$1,809-5%
Brunswick$1,875-1%
Burchard$1,9040%
Burr$1,852-2%
Burwell$2,0458%
Bushnell$2,0558%
Butte$1,9573%
Byron$1,798-5%
Cairo$1,820-4%
Callaway$2,0206%
Cambridge$1,9211%
Campbell$1,818-4%
Carleton$1,822-4%
Carroll$1,834-3%
Cedar Bluffs$1,841-3%
Cedar Creek$1,9211%
Cedar Rapids$1,9352%
Center$1,884-1%
Central City$1,797-5%
Ceresco$1,874-1%
Chadron$2,0327%
Chambers$1,8910%
Champion$2,0759%
Chappell$2,0729%
Chester$1,822-4%
Clarks$1,792-6%
Clarkson$1,824-4%
Clatonia$1,884-1%
Clay Center$1,782-6%
Coleridge$1,785-6%
Colon$1,855-2%
Columbus$1,798-5%
Comstock$2,0096%
Cook$1,868-2%
Cordova$1,825-4%
Cortland$1,9181%
Cozad$1,886-1%
Crab Orchard$1,860-2%
Crawford$2,0729%
Creston$1,804-5%
Crete$1,863-2%
Crofton$1,872-1%
Crookston$2,0538%
Culbertson$2,09911%
Curtis$2,11311%
Dakota City$1,9080%
Dalton$2,0206%
Danbury$2,0448%
Davenport$1,795-5%
Davey$1,9010%
David City$1,800-5%
Dawson$1,855-2%
Daykin$1,819-4%
De Witt$1,9030%
Deweese$1,817-4%
Dickens$2,09410%
Diller$1,825-4%
Dix$2,0237%
Dixon$1,802-5%
Dodge$1,855-2%
Douglas$1,9282%
Du Bois$1,855-2%
Dunbar$1,860-2%
Duncan$1,818-4%
Dunning$2,0226%
Dwight$1,804-5%
Eagle$1,886-1%
Eddyville$1,9392%
Edison$1,879-1%
Elgin$1,882-1%
Elk Creek$1,867-2%
Ellsworth$2,0005%
Elm Creek$1,821-4%
Elmwood$1,9000%
Elsie$2,0759%
Elsmere$2,0438%
Elwood$1,9050%
Elyria$2,0086%
Emerson$1,823-4%
Emmet$1,8950%
Enders$2,09710%
Ericson$2,0025%
Eustis$1,9875%
Ewing$1,9010%
Exeter$1,800-5%
Fairbury$1,877-1%
Fairfield$1,794-6%
Fairmont$1,781-6%
Falls City$1,821-4%
Farnam$1,8910%
Farwell$1,827-4%
Firth$1,9663%
Fontanelle$1,877-1%
Fordyce$1,850-3%
Fort Calhoun$2,0116%
Franklin$1,847-3%
Fremont$1,800-5%
Friend$1,792-6%
Fullerton$1,856-2%
Funk$1,824-4%
Garland$1,862-2%
Geneva$1,795-5%
Genoa$1,854-2%
Gering$2,0267%
Gibbon$1,787-6%
Gilead$1,812-5%
Giltner$1,780-6%
Glenvil$1,793-6%
Goehner$1,849-3%
Gordon$2,0749%
Gothenburg$1,890-1%
Grafton$1,792-6%
Grand Island$1,810-5%
Grant$2,0146%
Greeley$1,865-2%
Greenwood$1,8990%
Gresham$1,813-5%
Gretna$1,869-2%
Gross$1,9442%
Guide Rock$1,824-4%
Hadar$1,857-2%
Haigler$2,0558%
Hallam$1,9613%
Halsey$2,0397%
Hampton$1,767-7%
Hardy$1,804-5%
Harrisburg$2,0558%
Harrison$2,0438%
Hartington$1,814-4%
Hastings$1,769-7%
Hay Springs$2,0277%
Hazard$1,9774%
Heartwell$1,797-5%
Hebron$1,831-4%
Hemingford$2,0176%
Henderson$1,755-8%
Hendley$1,883-1%
Herman$1,9241%
Hershey$2,0397%
Hickman$1,9231%
Hildreth$1,816-4%
Holbrook$1,872-1%
Holdrege$1,792-6%
Holstein$1,799-5%
Homer$1,9312%
Hooper$1,840-3%
Hordville$1,768-7%
Howells$1,833-3%
Hubbard$1,9111%
Hubbell$1,800-5%
Humboldt$1,844-3%
Humphrey$1,796-5%
Huntley$1,838-3%
Imperial$2,0317%
Inavale$1,838-3%
Indianola$2,0709%
Inland$1,812-5%
Inman$1,9050%
Ithaca$1,8960%
Jackson$1,8920%
Jansen$1,825-4%
Johnson$1,857-2%
Johnstown$2,0066%
Julian$1,869-2%
Juniata$1,775-7%
Kearney$1,775-7%
Kennard$1,9432%
Keystone$2,0749%
Kilgore$2,0468%
Kimball$2,0287%
La Vista$1,833-4%
Lakeside$2,0438%
Lamar$2,0759%
Laurel$1,772-7%
Lawrence$1,836-3%
Lebanon$2,0588%
Leigh$1,820-4%
Lemoyne$2,0488%
Lewellen$2,0528%
Lewiston$1,860-2%
Lexington$1,8950%
Liberty$1,872-1%
Lincoln$1,784-6%
Lindsay$1,830-4%
Linwood$1,829-4%
Lisco$2,0347%
Litchfield$2,0257%
Long Pine$1,9905%
Loomis$1,810-5%
Lorton$1,860-2%
Louisville$1,9573%
Loup City$2,0287%
Lyman$2,0417%
Lynch$1,9171%
Lyons$1,888-1%
Macy$1,9804%
Madison$1,827-4%
Madrid$2,0588%
Magnet$1,869-2%
Malcolm$1,8960%
Malmo$1,888-1%
Manley$1,8960%
Marquette$1,791-6%
Marsland$2,0176%
Martell$1,9462%
Maskell$1,820-4%
Mason City$2,0176%
Max$2,11011%
Maywood$2,0387%
McCook$2,0438%
McCool Junction$1,756-8%
McGrew$2,0458%
McLean$1,829-4%
Mead$1,876-1%
Meadow Grove$1,848-3%
Melbeta$2,0538%
Memphis$1,886-1%
Merna$1,9935%
Merriman$2,0538%
Milburn$2,0106%
Milford$1,855-2%
Miller$1,840-3%
Milligan$1,806-5%
Mills$2,0337%
Minatare$2,0417%
Minden$1,786-6%
Mitchell$2,0005%
Monowi$1,9171%
Monroe$1,805-5%
Moorefield$2,0508%
Morrill$2,0277%
Morse Bluff$1,863-2%
Murdock$1,9241%
Murray$1,9211%
Naper$1,9573%
Naponee$1,858-2%
Nebraska City$1,808-5%
Nehawka$1,887-1%
Neligh$1,8990%
Nemaha$1,844-3%
Nenzel$2,11011%
Newman Grove$1,841-3%
Newport$2,0387%
Nickerson$1,8920%
Niobrara$1,9111%
Norfolk$1,814-4%
North Bend$1,826-4%
North Platte$1,9814%
O'Neill$1,9000%
Oak$1,794-6%
Oakdale$1,855-2%
Oakland$1,851-3%
Oconto$2,0146%
Odell$1,9141%
Odessa$1,807-5%
Offutt AFB$1,883-1%
Ogallala$2,0558%
Ohiowa$1,823-4%
Omaha$2,0468%
Ong$1,795-6%
Orchard$1,8980%
Ord$2,0136%
Orleans$1,877-1%
Osceola$1,804-5%
Oshkosh$2,08510%
Osmond$1,851-3%
Otoe$1,846-3%
Oxford$1,9221%
Page$1,877-1%
Palisade$2,14413%
Palmer$1,806-5%
Palmyra$1,887-1%
Panama$1,8960%
Papillion$1,833-3%
Parks$2,0779%
Pawnee City$1,865-2%
Pender$1,826-4%
Peru$1,823-4%
Petersburg$1,875-1%
Phillips$1,828-4%
Pickrell$1,862-2%
Pierce$1,818-4%
Pilger$1,833-4%
Plainview$1,877-1%
Platte Center$1,807-5%
Plattsmouth$1,845-3%
Pleasant Dale$1,849-3%
Pleasanton$1,824-4%
Plymouth$1,872-1%
Polk$1,774-7%
Ponca$1,827-4%
Prague$1,886-1%
Primrose$1,859-2%
Purdum$2,0357%
Ragan$1,841-3%
Ralston$1,9201%
Randolph$1,840-3%
Ravenna$1,818-4%
Raymond$1,9131%
Red Cloud$1,860-2%
Republican City$1,838-3%
Reynolds$1,827-4%
Richfield$1,871-2%
Rising City$1,811-5%
Riverdale$1,809-5%
Riverton$1,848-3%
Roca$1,865-2%
Rockville$1,9734%
Rogers$1,852-3%
Rosalie$1,873-1%
Royal$1,859-2%
Rulo$1,833-4%
Rushville$2,0156%
Ruskin$1,828-4%
Salem$1,844-3%
Sargent$2,0639%
Saronville$1,808-5%
Schuyler$1,824-4%
Scotia$1,9181%
Scottsbluff$2,0307%
Scribner$1,839-3%
Seneca$2,0176%
Seward$1,836-3%
Shelby$1,807-5%
Shelton$1,788-6%
Shickley$1,792-6%
Shubert$1,838-3%
Sidney$1,9915%
Smithfield$1,9030%
Snyder$1,890-1%
South Sioux City$1,9181%
Sparks$2,0438%
Spencer$1,9543%
Sprague$1,8910%
Springfield$1,855-2%
Springview$2,0397%
St Columbans$2,0146%
St. Edward$1,868-2%
St. Helena$1,840-3%
St. Paul$1,820-4%
Stamford$1,859-2%
Stanton$1,838-3%
Staplehurst$1,842-3%
Stapleton$2,0257%
Steele City$1,846-3%
Steinauer$1,862-2%
Stella$1,842-3%
Stockville$2,0488%
Strang$1,808-5%
Stratton$2,13312%
Stromsburg$1,758-7%
Sumner$1,9020%
Superior$1,827-4%
Surprise$1,809-5%
Sutton$1,782-6%
Swanton$1,826-4%
Syracuse$1,855-2%
Table Rock$1,8920%
Talmage$1,856-2%
Taylor$2,0618%
Tecumseh$1,8940%
Tekamah$1,9151%
Terrytown$2,0247%
Thedford$2,0206%
Thurston$1,837-3%
Tilden$1,848-3%
Tobias$1,829-4%
Trenton$2,12612%
Trumbull$1,784-6%
Tryon$2,0598%
Uehling$1,9060%
Ulysses$1,809-5%
Unadilla$1,863-2%
Union$1,887-1%
Upland$1,835-3%
Utica$1,803-5%
Valentine$2,0649%
Valley$1,9020%
Valparaiso$1,886-1%
Venango$2,0568%
Verdigre$1,9241%
Verdon$1,847-3%
Virginia$1,8970%
Wahoo$1,880-1%
Wakefield$1,790-6%
Wallace$2,0639%
Walthill$1,9261%
Walton$1,889-1%
Washington$1,9543%
Waterbury$1,825-4%
Wauneta$2,09710%
Wausa$1,837-3%
Waverly$1,886-1%
Wayne$1,830-4%
Weeping Water$1,9332%
Wellfleet$2,0719%
West Point$1,818-4%
Western$1,859-2%
Westerville$2,0297%
Weston$1,862-2%
Whiteclay$2,0317%
Whitman$2,0608%
Whitney$2,0196%
Wilcox$1,798-5%
Willow Island$1,8970%
Wilsonville$1,883-1%
Winnetoon$1,877-1%
Winside$1,834-3%
Winslow$1,9201%
Wisner$1,815-4%
Wolbach$1,849-3%
Wood Lake$2,0166%
Wood River$1,797-5%
Woodland Park$1,819-4%
Wymore$1,8950%
Wynot$1,842-3%
York$1,730-9%
Yutan$1,9191%

Nebraska requires drivers to prove financial responsibility for all vehicles registered with the state. Most drivers do this by buying car insurance.

If you buy car insurance in Nebraska, you’re required to get at least a minimum amount of liability car insurance.

Nebraska auto insurance requirements

Coverage typeMinimum amount needed
Liability (bodily injury)$25,000 per person

$50,000 per accident
Liability (property damage)$25,000 per accident
Uninsured motorist (bodily injury)$25,000 per person

$50,000 per accident
Underinsured motorist (bodily injury)$25,000 per person

$50,000 per accident

Drivers who don’t want to buy car insurance can prove financial responsibility with a $75,000 bond, property bond or certificate of deposit.

The average cost of full-coverage car insurance in Nebraska is $1,933 a year. The average cost of liability car insurance is $570 a year in Nebraska.

In Nebraska, full-coverage car insurance costs $161 a month, on average. The state average rate for liability car insurance is $48 a month.

State Farm has the cheapest car insurance in Nebraska for drivers who want full-coverage policies, with an average rate of $1,391 a year.

Progressive has Nebraska’s cheapest liability-only car insurance at $382 a year.

Methodology

LendingTree uses insurance rate data from Quadrant Information Services using publicly sourced insurance company filings. Rates are based on an analysis of hundreds of thousands of car insurance quotes for a typical driver. Prices are shown for comparative purposes only. Your own rates may be different.

Unless noted otherwise, quotes are for a full-coverage policy for a 30-year-old man with good credit and a clean driving record who drives a 2015 Honda Civic EX.

Minimum-liability policies provide liability coverage with the state’s required minimum limits.
Full-coverage policies include collision, comprehensive and liability coverage:

  • Bodily injury liability: $50,000 per person, $100,000 per accident
  • Property damage liability: $25,000
  • Uninsured / underinsured motorist bodily injury: $50,000 per person and $100,000 per accident
  • Personal injury protection: minimum limits, where required by law
  • Collision: $500 deductible
  • Comprehensive: $500 deductible


Our team of insurance experts rated insurance companies based on several categories. These categories include average rates, discounts, coverage options, third-party customer service ratings and app/website experience. We weighted these categories based on what customers value in an insurance company.

For third-party customer service ratings, we included NAIC’s Complaint Index scores and financial strength ratings from A.M. Best. NAIC Complaint Index scores are used to determine how satisfied customers are with their claims, while financial strength ratings from A.M. Best reflect the ability to pay out claims.

*USAA is only available to current and former members of the military as well as certain family members.