REVISION : How to Compare Car Insurance Rates 2025
How Does LendingTree Get Paid?
LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

How Does LendingTree Get Paid?

LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

Cheapest Car Insurance in New Mexico (2025)

Updated on:
Content was accurate at the time of publication.

Best cheap car insurance in New Mexico

$1,464/year
Cheapest full coverage: State Farm
State Farm logo
$1,858/year
Second-cheapest full coverage: Geico
Geico logo
$2,937/year
Cheapest with bad credit: Progressive
Progressive logo
+
More Options

Find the Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in New Mexico

Drivers in New Mexico get the cheapest full-coverage car insurance from State Farm, which offers an average rate of $1,464 a year, or $122 a month.

Geico is the state’s second-cheapest company for full-coverage insurance Full-coverage car insurance usually includes both collision and comprehensive coverages, which protect your vehicle from damage and theft. at $155 a month.

USAA has a lower average rate than State Farm or Geico, but only military members and their families can buy from USAA. If that describes you, get a quote from USAA. Along with cheap full-coverage rates, USAA offers great customer service.

Cheapest car insurance companies in New Mexico

Cheapest companies for full coverage

CompanyAnnual rateLendingTree score
state farm logoState Farm$1,4644.5 stars
geico logoGeico$1,8583.5 stars
progressive logoProgressive$1,8614 stars
farm bureau logoFarm Bureau$2,4354 stars
allstate logoAllstate$2,5813 stars
farmers logoFarmers$3,1053 stars
usaa logoUSAA*$9554 stars

State Farm has the cheapest liability-only car insurance in New Mexico of $434 a year, or $36 a month. Farm Bureau has the next-cheapest liability rates in the state at $41 a month.

State Farm has more discounts than Farm Bureau, giving you more chances to save on liability car insurance Liability car insurance covers injuries and damage you cause to others. Most states require drivers to buy at least a minimum amount of liability coverage. . Still, comparing quotes from both is the only way to know for sure which is the cheapest for you.

New Mexico drivers are required by law to have at least a minimum amount of liability car insurance, which covers the medical and repair bills of others after you cause an accident.

Cheapest companies for minimum coverage

CompanyAnnual rate
State Farm$434
Farm Bureau$486
Progressive$622
Geico$915
Farmers$927
Allstate$1,194
USAA*$238

Find the Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in New Mexico

At $1,492 a year, State Farm has the cheapest car insurance for New Mexico teens who only buy liability coverage. Geico and Farm Bureau are close behind at $1,508 and $1,548 a year, respectively.

All three companies offer several discounts that could make them your cheapest option for liability insurance. Teens pay the highest car insurance rates of any group due to their lack of driving experience, and discounts could help you save a lot of money.

New Mexico teens looking for the cheapest full-coverage car insurance will also find it at State Farm, where rates average $4,097 a year.

If you’re a parent in New Mexico looking for cheap car insurance for teens, add them to your current policy. Your rate will go up, but it should still be cheaper than if you each bought your own auto insurance policies.

Cheapest companies for teens

CompanyLiabilityFull coverage
State Farm$1,492$4,097
Geico$1,508$3,032
Farm Bureau$1,548$3,895
Progressive$2,000$7,163
Allstate$3,664$8,189
Farmers$4,243$12,383
USAA*$611$2,040

State Farm has the best rates for New Mexico drivers looking for cheap car insurance with a speeding ticket at $1,563 a year, or $130 a month.

Geico is the state’s next-cheapest company after a ticket, with an average rate of $201 a month.

After a speeding ticket in New Mexico, you can expect your car insurance premium to increase by around 25%.

Cheapest companies after a ticket

CompanyAnnual rate
State Farm$1,563
Geico$2,407
Farm Bureau$2,734
Progressive$2,754
Allstate$2,880
Farmers$4,227
USAA*$1,186

With rates that average $1,672 a year, or $139 a month, State Farm has the cheapest car insurance rates after an accident for most New Mexico drivers. Geico is next, with an average rate of $214 a month.

New Mexico drivers see their auto insurance go up by an average of 42% after an accident.

Cheapest companies after an accident

CompanyAnnual rate
State Farm$1,672
Geico$2,567
Progressive$2,746
Farm Bureau$3,319
Allstate$4,262
Farmers$4,275
USAA*$1,378

Best insurance for New Mexico teens with a bad driving record: State Farm

Teen drivers in New Mexico with a ticket or accident on their record get the cheapest liability car insurance from State Farm. State Farm’s average rate for teens after a ticket is $1,641 a year. For teens with an accident, the average rate is $1,805 a year.

Geico has the second-cheapest rates for teens with poor driving records in New Mexico, but it also offers more discounts than State Farm. Compare quotes from both car insurance companies to find out which one will give you the best deal.

Cheapest companies for teen drivers with bad records

CompanyTicketAccident
State Farm$1,641$1,805
Geico$1,804$1,972
Farm Bureau$1,889$2,555
Progressive$2,286$2,075
Allstate$4,196$6,488
Farmers$5,249$5,249
USAA*$829$975

Find the Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in New Mexico

Progressive offers the best cheap car insurance with a DWI in New Mexico at around $2,246 a year, or $187 a month. Geico is the next-cheapest company at $226 a month.

A driving while intoxicated (DWI) conviction usually leads to fines, jail time and license suspension. You can also expect your car insurance rates to jump about 54% after a DUI in New Mexico.

Cheapest companies after a DWI

CompanyAnnual rate
Progressive$2,246
Geico$2,708
State Farm$3,149
Allstate$3,554
Farmers$4,116
Farm Bureau$4,315
USAA*$1,883

At $2,937 a year, or $245 a month, Progressive has New Mexico’s cheapest auto insurance for poor credit. Geico is right behind at $246 a month.

Progressive and Geico are close enough in cost that discounts could be a key factor in which company gives you the cheapest car insurance quote.

Car insurance companies charge higher rates to drivers with poor credit because they see a link between credit score and the risk of filing a claim. With poor credit, you can expect to pay about 79% more for car insurance than a driver with good credit.

Cheapest companies for drivers with poor credit

CompanyAnnual rate
Progressive$2,937
Geico$2,951
Farm Bureau$3,555
Allstate$3,702
Farmers$5,131
State Farm$5,652
USAA*$1,663

If you want to learn your credit score, you can find out for free at LendingTree Spring before you shop for car insurance.

State Farm and Farm Bureau are the best car insurance companies in New Mexico, based on their customer satisfaction ratings, coverage options and online resources.

Farm Bureau has a higher J.D. Power customer satisfaction rating than State Farm, though both are better than average. Farm Bureau also offers gap insurance, while State Farm does not. Gap insurance pays the rest of what you owe on a financed car if it is totalled.

State Farm offers more discounts than Farm Bureau, and also makes it easy to get online car insurance quotes.

New Mexico car insurance company ratings

CompanyJ.D. Power**AM BestLendingTree
Allstate635A+3 stars
Farm Bureau673A4.5 stars
Farmers619A3 stars
Geico637A++3.5 stars
Progressive622A+4 stars
State Farm657A++4.5 stars
USAA*739A++4 stars

*USAA only sells insurance to members of the military and their families.
**Source: J.D. Power 2024 U.S. Auto Insurance Study. Higher is better; 644 is average.

Deming has the cheapest average car insurance rate in New Mexico at $1,697 a year, or $141 a month. South Valley has the state’s most expensive car insurance rate of $210 a month.

In Albuquerque, New Mexico’s largest city, drivers pay an average of $204 a month. Las Cruces, the state’s second-biggest city, has an average rate of $162 a month. Rio Rancho drivers pay around $185 a month.

Car insurance rates near you

CityAnnual rate% from average
Abiquiu$2,1045%
Adelino$2,24412%
Agua Fria$2,0683%
Alamo$1,882-6%
Alamogordo$1,734-14%
Albuquerque$2,45122%
Alcalde$2,1015%
Algodones$2,1568%
Alto$1,986-1%
Amalia$2,0965%
Amistad$2,0291%
Angel Fire$2,0975%
Animas$1,722-14%
Anthony$1,972-2%
Anton Chico$2,0120%
Aragon$1,793-11%
Arenas Valley$1,733-14%
Arrey$1,794-11%
Arroyo Seco$2,1196%
Artesia$2,0040%
Atoka$2,0120%
Aztec$1,833-9%
Bard$1,958-2%
Bayard$1,715-14%
Belen$2,28614%
Bent$1,818-9%
Berino$1,952-3%
Bernalillo$2,1668%
Black Rock$1,807-10%
Blanco$1,796-10%
Bloomfield$1,828-9%
Bluewater Village$1,837-8%
Bosque$2,1125%
Bosque Farms$2,25012%
Brimhall$1,841-8%
Broadview$2,0492%
Buckhorn$1,707-15%
Buena Vista$2,0593%
Caballo$1,756-12%
Canjilon$2,1517%
Cannon AFB$2,0191%
Canones$2,1457%
Capitan$2,0171%
Caprock$2,0412%
Capulin$2,0120%
Carlsbad$2,1135%
Carnuel$2,40320%
Carrizozo$1,903-5%
Carson$2,1196%
Casa Blanca$2,0171%
Causey$1,960-2%
Cebolla$2,1517%
Cedar Crest$2,27513%
Cedar Grove$2,1145%
Cedarvale$2,0824%
Cedro$2,27413%
Cerrillos$2,0291%
Cerro$2,0814%
Chacon$2,0653%
Chama$2,1638%
Chamberino$1,925-4%
Chamisal$2,0593%
Chamita$2,0884%
Chaparral$1,9950%
Chimayo$2,1015%
Church Rock$1,892-6%
Cimarron$2,0894%
Claunch$1,917-4%
Clayton$2,0321%
Cleveland$2,0462%
Cliff$1,789-11%
Clines Corners$2,0452%
Cloudcroft$1,900-5%
Clovis$2,0231%
Cochiti Lake$2,0844%
Cochiti Pueblo$2,1437%
Columbus$1,773-12%
Conchas Dam$2,0221%
Continental Divide$1,846-8%
Cordova$2,1105%
Corona$2,0683%
Corrales$2,30215%
Costilla$2,0804%
Counselor$1,979-1%
Coyote$2,1125%
Crossroads$2,0070%
Crownpoint$1,875-6%
Cuartelez$2,0161%
Cuba$1,968-2%
Cubero$1,910-5%
Cuervo$1,973-2%
Datil$1,844-8%
Deming$1,697-15%
Derry$1,829-9%
Des Moines$2,0623%
Dexter$2,0372%
Dixon$2,0764%
Dona Ana$1,928-4%
Dulce$2,1035%
Eagle Nest$2,0120%
Edgewood$2,1105%
El Cerro$2,23612%
El Cerro Mission$2,24812%
El Prado$2,1095%
El Rancho$2,0633%
El Rito$2,0814%
Eldorado at Santa Fe$2,0954%
Elephant Butte$1,735-13%
Elida$1,938-3%
Embudo$2,1085%
Encino$1,976-1%
Espanola$2,0824%
Estancia$2,1658%
Eunice$2,0894%
Fairacres$1,959-2%
Farmington$1,796-10%
Faywood$1,766-12%
Fence Lake$1,818-9%
Flora Vista$1,811-10%
Floyd$1,988-1%
Folsom$2,0412%
Fort Bayard$1,771-12%
Fort Stanton$1,952-3%
Fort Sumner$2,0452%
Fort Wingate$1,889-6%
Fruitland$1,825-9%
Gallina$2,1759%
Gallup$1,832-9%
Gamerco$1,884-6%
Garfield$1,823-9%
Garita$2,0452%
Gila$1,791-11%
Gladstone$2,0301%
Glencoe$2,0010%
Glenwood$1,769-12%
Glorieta$2,0774%
Grady$2,0532%
Grants$1,799-10%
Grenville$2,0301%
Guadalupita$2,0060%
Hachita$1,723-14%
Hagerman$2,0110%
Hanover$1,725-14%
Hatch$1,863-7%
Hernandez$2,0753%
High Rolls Mountain Park$1,925-4%
Hillsboro$1,752-13%
Hobbs$2,0995%
Holloman AFB$1,748-13%
Holman$2,0824%
Hondo$2,0030%
Hope$2,0613%
House$1,951-3%
Hurley$1,710-15%
Ilfeld$2,0934%
Isleta$2,29715%
Jal$2,0492%
Jamestown$1,901-5%
Jarales$2,26413%
Jemez Pueblo$2,0372%
Jemez Springs$2,0241%
Kenna$1,991-1%
Kirtland$1,816-9%
Kirtland Air Force Base$2,39820%
La Cienega$2,0583%
La Huerta$2,1055%
La Jara$2,0412%
La Joya$1,959-2%
La Loma$2,0070%
La Luz$1,822-9%
La Madera$2,0693%
La Mesa$1,913-5%
La Mesilla$2,1055%
La Plata$1,809-10%
La Puebla$2,0723%
La Union$1,970-2%
La Villita$2,1035%
Laguna$2,1055%
Lake Arthur$2,0251%
Lakewood$2,0522%
Lamy$2,0110%
Las Cruces$1,938-3%
Las Maravillas$2,24612%
Las Vegas$2,0703%
Lee Acres$1,801-10%
Lemitar$1,951-3%
Lincoln$2,0040%
Lindrith$2,0462%
Lingo$1,9960%
Livingston Wheeler$2,1166%
Llano$2,1075%
Loco Hills$2,0442%
Logan$2,0090%
Lordsburg$1,734-13%
Los Alamos$1,876-6%
Los Chaves$2,25913%
Los Lunas$2,23411%
Los Ojos$2,21110%
Los Ranchos de Albuquerque$2,39019%
Loving$2,1005%
Lovington$2,0844%
Luna$1,804-10%
Magdalena$1,868-7%
Malaga$2,0693%
Maljamar$2,0753%
Maxwell$2,0241%
Mayhill$1,971-2%
McIntosh$2,1598%
Mcalister$1,984-1%
Mcdonald$2,0743%
Meadow Lake$2,24712%
Medanales$2,1166%
Melrose$2,0693%
Mentmore$1,895-5%
Mescalero$1,872-7%
Mesilla$1,930-4%
Mesilla Park$1,937-3%
Mesquite$1,930-4%
Mexican Springs$1,838-8%
Miami$2,0613%
Milan$1,814-10%
Mills$2,0181%
Milnesand$1,969-2%
Mimbres$1,732-14%
Monterey Park$2,24512%
Montezuma$2,0412%
Monticello$1,776-11%
Monument$2,1236%
Mora$2,0743%
Moriarty$2,1246%
Mosquero$2,0754%
Mountainair$2,1286%
Mule Creek$1,783-11%
Nageezi$1,894-6%
Nambe$2,0673%
Napi Headquarters$1,796-10%
Nara Visa$2,0130%
Navajo$1,889-6%
Navajo Dam$1,824-9%
New Laguna$2,0623%
Newcomb$1,934-4%
Newkirk$2,0181%
Nogal$1,966-2%
North Hobbs$2,0874%
North Valley$2,38519%
Ocate$2,0261%
Ohkay Owingeh$2,0824%
Ojo Caliente$2,0794%
Ojo Feliz$2,0412%
Organ$1,951-3%
Orogrande$1,919-4%
Paguate$1,9990%
Paradise Hills$2,34617%
Pecos$2,0904%
Pena Blanca$2,0281%
Penasco$2,0462%
Pep$1,980-1%
Peralta$2,27513%
Petaca$2,1296%
Picacho$2,0522%
Pie Town$1,836-8%
Pinehill$1,848-8%
Pinon$1,896-5%
Placitas$2,1849%
Playas$1,826-9%
Pojoaque$2,0623%
Polvadera$1,940-3%
Ponderosa$2,0713%
Ponderosa Pine$2,29414%
Portales$1,976-1%
Prewitt$1,855-7%
Pueblo Of Acoma$1,929-4%
Quay$2,0000%
Quemado$1,832-9%
Questa$2,0934%
Radium Springs$1,934-4%
Rainsville$2,0713%
Ramah$1,858-7%
Ranchos De Taos$2,0985%
Raton$2,0030%
Red River$2,0553%
Redrock$1,777-11%
Regina$2,0362%
Rehoboth$1,905-5%
Reserve$1,779-11%
Ribera$2,0452%
Rincon$1,907-5%
Rio Communities$2,28714%
Rio Rancho$2,22111%
Rociada$2,0643%
Rodeo$1,792-11%
Rogers$1,961-2%
Roswell$2,0382%
Rowe$2,0884%
Roy$1,9960%
Ruidoso$1,969-2%
Ruidoso Downs$2,0372%
Sacramento$1,869-7%
Salem$1,803-10%
San Acacia$1,942-3%
San Antonio$1,871-7%
San Cristobal$2,0603%
San Felipe Pueblo$2,1417%
San Fidel$1,856-7%
San Ildefonso Pueblo$2,0643%
San Jon$1,979-1%
San Jose$2,0693%
San Miguel$1,912-5%
San Patricio$1,965-2%
San Rafael$1,863-7%
San Ysidro$2,0120%
Sandia Heights$2,33516%
Sandia Knolls$2,22211%
Sandia Park$2,28914%
Sanostee$1,928-4%
Santa Clara$1,712-15%
Santa Clara Pueblo$2,1085%
Santa Cruz$2,0683%
Santa Fe$2,0583%
Santa Rosa$1,989-1%
Santa Teresa$2,0000%
Santo Domingo Pueblo$2,0532%
Sapello$2,0341%
Sausal$2,28614%
Sedan$2,0402%
Sedillo$2,28614%
Serafina$2,0804%
Sheep Springs$1,907-5%
Shiprock$1,836-8%
Silver City$1,710-15%
Skyline-Ganipa$1,928-4%
Smith Lake$1,908-5%
Socorro$1,921-4%
Solano$2,0080%
South Valley$2,51726%
Spencerville$1,828-9%
Springer$2,0201%
St. Vrain$2,0352%
Stanley$2,1055%
Sunland Park$2,0402%
Sunspot$1,928-4%
Taiban$2,0281%
Taos$2,0975%
Taos Pueblo$2,1095%
Taos Ski Valley$2,1306%
Tatum$2,0171%
Tererro$2,0894%
Tesuque$2,0794%
Texico$2,0311%
Thoreau$1,864-7%
Tierra Amarilla$2,0954%
Tijeras$2,29414%
Timberon$1,954-3%
Tinnie$2,0472%
Tohatchi$1,890-6%
Tome$2,23311%
Torreon$2,0864%
Trampas$2,1176%
Trementina$2,0794%
Tres Piedras$2,1135%
Truchas$2,1145%
Truth or Consequences$1,724-14%
Tucumcari$1,952-3%
Tularosa$1,800-10%
Twin Lakes$1,898-5%
University Park$1,988-1%
Upper Fruitland$1,820-9%
Ute Park$2,0794%
Vadito$2,0784%
Vado$1,915-4%
Valdez$2,0512%
Valencia$2,24412%
Vallecitos$2,1055%
Valmora$2,0573%
Vanderwagen$1,896-5%
Veguita$2,0130%
Velarde$2,1005%
Wagon Mound$1,987-1%
Waterflow$1,818-9%
Watrous$2,0382%
Weed$1,868-7%
West Hammond$1,832-9%
White Rock$1,949-3%
White Sands$1,907-5%
White Sands Missile Range$1,938-3%
Whites City$2,0653%
Willard$2,0271%
Williamsburg$1,744-13%
Winston$1,791-11%
Yah-ta-hey$1,902-5%
Yeso$2,0593%
Youngsville$2,1467%
Zia Pueblo$2,0693%
Zuni Pueblo$1,803-10%

New Mexico drivers are required to buy at least a minimum amount of liability car insurance. This minimum amount is usually written as 25/50/10.

  • $25,000 bodily injury coverage per person
  • $50,000 bodily injury coverage per accident
  • $10,000 property damage coverage

SR-22 insurance in New Mexico

If your driver’s license is suspended in New Mexico, you must file an SR-22 to get it reinstated.

An SR-22 proves you have at least the minimum amount of car insurance New Mexico law requires. Your insurance company should file the SR-22 with the Motor Vehicle Division (MVD) on your behalf.

If you do not maintain the SR-22 for its full duration, your insurance company will notify the MVD and your license will be suspended again.

The average cost of full-coverage car insurance in New Mexico is $2,037 a year, or $170 a month. Liability-only car insurance costs $688 a year, or $57 a month, on average.

New Mexico is an at-fault state for auto insurance, meaning the driver responsible for the accident pays for resulting injuries and damage.

Methodology

LendingTree uses insurance rate data from Quadrant Information Services using publicly sourced insurance company filings. Rates are based on an analysis of hundreds of thousands of car insurance quotes for a typical driver. Prices are shown for comparative purposes only. Your own rates may be different.

Unless noted otherwise, quotes are for a full-coverage policy for a 30-year-old man with good credit and a clean driving record who drives a 2015 Honda Civic EX.

Minimum-liability policies provide liability coverage with the state’s required minimum limits.

Full-coverage policies include collision, comprehensive and liability coverage:

  • Bodily injury liability: $50,000 per person, $100,000 per accident
  • Property damage liability: $25,000
  • Uninsured/underinsured motorist bodily injury: $50,000 per person and $100,000 per accident
  • Personal injury protection: minimum limits, where required by law
  • Collision: $500 deductible
  • Comprehensive: $500 deductible


Our team of insurance experts rated insurance companies based on several categories. These categories include average rates, discounts, coverage options, third-party customer service ratings and app/website experience. We weighted these categories based on what customers value in an insurance company.

For third-party customer service ratings, we included NAIC’s Complaint Index scores and financial strength ratings from A.M. Best. NAIC Complaint Index scores are used to determine how satisfied customers are with their claims, while financial strength ratings from A.M. Best reflect the ability to pay out claims. Overall satisfaction ratings are from the J.D. Power 2024 U.S. Auto Insurance Study.

*USAA is only available to current and former members of the military as well as certain family members.