How to Compare Car Insurance Rates 2025
How Does LendingTree Get Paid?
LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

How Does LendingTree Get Paid?

LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

Cheap Car Insurance in West Virginia (2025)

Updated on:
Content was accurate at the time of publication.

Best cheap car insurance in West Virginia

$1,361/year
Cheapest full coverage: Erie
Erie logo
$1,481/year
Cheap after a ticket: Westfield
Westfield logo
$1,535/year
Best after an accident: State Farm
State Farm logo
+
More Options

Find the Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in West Virginia

Drivers in West Virginia get the cheapest full-coverage car insurance quotes with Erie at an average of $1,361 a year, or $113 a month. Westfield has the second-best rates of $123 a month.

Erie offers more discounts than Westfield does, but if you’re considering usage-based car insurance, Westfield may still save you more money. Westfield’s MissionSafe program tracks your driving behaviors using an app. You could save an average of 20% on your car insurance with MissionSafe, depending on how you drive.

USAA has the overall lowest full-coverage insurance Full-coverage car insurance usually includes liability, collision and comprehensive coverages. Liability covers injuries and damage you cause to others. Collision and comprehensive protect your own vehicle from damage and theft. rate in West Virginia, but it only sells insurance to military members and their families.

Cheapest car insurance companies in West Virginia

Cheapest companies for full coverage

CompanyAnnual rateLendingTree score
erie insurance logoErie$1,3614 stars
westfield logoWestfield$1,4813.5 stars
state farm logoState Farm$1,5354.5 stars
Progressive logoProgressive$1,8444 stars
geico logoGeico$2,0743.5 stars
nationwide logoNationwide$2,2333 stars
allstate logoAllstate$2,5803 stars
usaa logoUSAA*$1,1974 stars

With an average rate of $436 a year, or $36 a month, Erie also has the cheapest liability car insurance rate in West Virginia. Westfield is right behind at $37 a month, on average.

These average rates are close enough in cost that discounts could play a big role in which company has the cheapest liability insurance Liability car insurance covers injuries and damage you cause to others. Most states require drivers to buy at least a minimum amount of liability coverage. for you. Make sure to take advantage of all the discounts you can when you compare car insurance quotes.

Cheapest companies for minimum coverage

CompanyAnnual rate
Erie$436
Westfield$439
State Farm$501
Geico$890
Nationwide$987
Progressive$1,042
Allstate$1,081
USAA*$354

Find the Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in West Virginia

If you’re looking for cheap car insurance for a young driver, Erie has the cheapest rates for both minimum and full-coverage car insurance at $996 a year and $3,026 a year, respectively.

Cheapest companies for teen drivers

CompanyLiabilityFull coverage
Erie$966$3,026
Westfield$1,366$4,619
State Farm$1,658$4,379
Geico$1,983$4,613
Progressive$2,581$5,213
Nationwide$3,258$8,632
Allstate$3,802$9,465
USAA*$963$3,131

Westfield has the lowest rates for West Virginia drivers looking for cheap car insurance with a speeding ticket at an average of $1,481 a year, or $123 a year. Erie is right behind at $125 a month.

Broken down over the course of a year, the difference between Westfield’s and Erie’s rates after a ticket is just a few dollars. Comparing the two companies beyond cost could help you choose between them. For example, Erie policies come with some great perks that Westfield’s don’t, like first-accident forgiveness With accident forgiveness, your first accident won’t make your car insurance rates go up. and a diminishing deductible With Erie’s diminishing deductible, your deductible is lowered by $100 for each consecutive policy year you don’t file a claim, up to a maximum of $500. .

The average West Virginia driver sees their car insurance rates go up 15% after a speeding ticket.

Cheapest companies after a ticket

CompanyAnnual rate
Westfield$1,481
Erie$1,496
State Farm$1,627
Progressive$2,291
Geico$2,385
Allstate$2,869
Nationwide$2,895
USAA*$1,383

West Virginia drivers looking for cheap car insurance after an accident should get a quote from State Farm. State Farm has the cheapest rate of $1,535 a year, or $128 a month, after an accident. Erie has the next-cheapest rate at $137 a month.

Although it’s not something you can plan for, Erie’s new car protection coverage is excellent if you’re in an accident. If your new vehicle is up to 24 months old and is totaled in an accident, this coverage will replace it with a new vehicle of the latest model year.

West Virginia drivers can expect their auto insurance to rise 42% after an at-fault collision.

Cheapest companies after an accident

CompanyAnnual rate
State Farm$1,535
Erie$1,646
Westfield$2,126
Progressive$2,864
Geico$3,180
Nationwide$3,590
Allstate$3,658
USAA*$1,678

Erie has the cheapest car insurance rates for West Virginia teens with a ticket or accident on their record.

  • Teens in West Virginia pay an average of $1,121 a year after a ticket with Erie.
  • The cheapest average rate for West Virginia teens after an accident is $1,144 a year, also from Erie.

Teen car insurance rates without a ticket or accident are steep enough, so if you’re looking to cut down on costs, look into Erie’s Youthful Driver discount for unmarried drivers under 21 who live with their parents.

Cheapest companies for teens with driving infractions

CompanyTicketAccident
Erie$1,121$1,144
Westfield$1,366$1,556
State Farm$1,800$1,658
Geico$2,191$2,811
Progressive$2,786$3,041
Nationwide$3,468$3,562
Allstate$4,382$4,643
USAA*$1,247$1,425

Find the Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in West Virginia

Erie has the best rates for drivers in West Virginia looking for cheap car insurance with a DUI at $2,128 a year, or $177 a month. Progressive has the second-cheapest rates at $213 a month.

Progressive offers more discounts than Erie, which could make it the cheaper of the two companies for you.

After a DUI in West Virginia, expect your car insurance rates to go up 75%.

Cheapest companies after a DUI

CompanyAnnual rate
Erie$2,128
Progressive$2,551
State Farm$3,127
Westfield$3,418
Allstate$3,465
Geico$3,662
Nationwide$4,475
USAA*$2,153

At $2,097 a year, or $175 a month, Westfield offers the cheapest car insurance with bad credit for West Virginia. Progressive is the next-cheapest company at $252 a month.

Car insurance companies see a connection between poor credit and higher chances of filing a claim. West Virginia drivers see their rates increase an average of 91% if they have poor credit.

Go to LendingTree Spring to learn your credit score for free before looking for auto insurance quotes.

Cheapest companies for drivers with poor credit

CompanyAnnual rate
Westfield$2,097
Progressive$3,020
Nationwide$3,049
Geico$3,063
Erie$3,149
Allstate$4,316
State Farm$6,398
USAA*$2,261

Erie and State Farm are the best car insurance companies in West Virginia, based on their coverage options and customer satisfaction ratings.

Erie includes some valuable coverages in its standard car insurance policy. For example, Erie’s rate lock feature keeps your rate fixed unless you make certain changes, such as changing your residence or adding or removing a car from your coverage.

State Farm comes out ahead of Erie in terms of financial strength, showing a higher ability to pay out on claims.

West Virginia car insurance company ratings

CompanyJ.D. Power**AM BestLendingTree
Allstate635A+3 stars
Erie700A+4 stars
Geico637A++3.5 stars
Nationwide641A3 stars
Progressive622A+4 stars
State Farm657A++4.5 stars
USAA*739A++4 stars
Westfield676A3.5 stars

*USAA only sells insurance to members of the military and their families.
**Source: J.D. Power 2024 U.S. Auto Insurance Study. Higher is better; 644 is average.

Martinsburg residents pay the cheapest rates for car insurance in West Virginia at $1,559 a year. Kermit is the state’s most expensive city for car insurance at $2,227 a year.

The average cost of full-coverage car insurance in West Virginia’s biggest cities is:

  • Charleston: $1,765 a year
  • Huntington: $1,792 a year
  • Morgantown: $1,660 a year

Car insurance rates near you

CityAnnual rate% from average
Accoville$2,02411%
Adrian$1,8612%
Advent$1,8170%
Albright$1,8351%
Alderson$1,688-7%
Alkol$2,01111%
Allen Junction$1,9417%
Alloy$1,727-5%
Alma$1,763-3%
Alum Bridge$1,8120%
Alum Creek$1,8964%
Amherstdale$2,02111%
Amigo$1,9588%
Amma$1,8743%
Anawalt$1,9548%
Anmoore$1,703-6%
Annamoriah$1,8693%
Ansted$1,724-5%
Apple Grove$1,774-2%
Arbovale$1,8250%
Arnett$1,8190%
Arnoldsburg$1,9105%
Arthurdale$1,8381%
Artie$1,770-3%
Asbury$1,670-8%
Ashford$1,9005%
Ashton$1,787-2%
Athens$1,690-7%
Auburn$1,8814%
Augusta$1,661-9%
Aurora$1,8371%
Avondale$1,9467%
Baisden$2,12117%
Baker$1,656-9%
Bakerton$1,592-12%
Ballard$1,725-5%
Ballengee$1,741-4%
Bancroft$1,741-4%
Bandytown$1,9367%
Barboursville$1,8100%
Barrackville$1,698-7%
Bartley$1,9507%
Bartow$1,796-1%
Baxter$1,692-7%
Bayard$1,734-5%
Beaver$1,766-3%
Beckley$1,778-2%
Beech Bottom$1,674-8%
Beeson$1,749-4%
Belington$1,8250%
Belle$1,773-2%
Belleville$1,757-3%
Belmont$1,8230%
Belva$1,758-3%
Benwood$1,681-7%
Berea$1,8824%
Bergoo$1,8251%
Berkeley Springs$1,600-12%
Berwind$1,9698%
Bethany$1,687-7%
Bethlehem$1,633-10%
Bickmore$1,8904%
Big Bend$1,8773%
Big Chimney$1,765-3%
Big Creek$2,04513%
Big Otter$1,8824%
Big Run$1,775-2%
Big Sandy$1,9759%
Big Springs$1,8844%
Bim$1,9346%
Birch River$1,722-5%
Blacksville$1,735-4%
Blair$2,02111%
Blennerhassett$1,693-7%
Bloomingrose$1,8974%
Blount$1,770-3%
Blue Creek$1,768-3%
Bluefield$1,700-6%
Bluewell$1,722-5%
Boaz$1,754-3%
Bob White$1,9135%
Bolt$1,795-1%
Bomont$1,8612%
Boomer$1,732-5%
Borderland$2,16219%
Bowden$1,775-2%
Bradley$1,753-3%
Bradshaw$1,9477%
Bramwell$1,726-5%
Branchland$2,03912%
Brandywine$1,789-1%
Breeden$2,19021%
Brenton$1,9749%
Bretz$1,8482%
Bridgeport$1,682-7%
Brohard$1,8723%
Brookhaven$1,690-7%
Brownsville$1,728-5%
Bruceton Mills$1,8633%
Bruno$2,02411%
Buckeye$1,776-2%
Buckhannon$1,8381%
Bud$1,9407%
Buffalo$1,769-3%
Bunker Hill$1,570-14%
Burlington$1,650-9%
Burnsville$1,8542%
Burnt House$1,8723%
Burnwell$1,754-3%
Burton$1,773-2%
Cabin Creek$1,764-3%
Cabins$1,695-7%
Cairo$1,8653%
Caldwell$1,663-8%
Calvin$1,759-3%
Camden$1,8070%
Camden-on-Gauley$1,8230%
Cameron$1,705-6%
Camp Creek$1,709-6%
Canebrake$1,9698%
Cannelton$1,742-4%
Canvas$1,756-3%
Capon Bridge$1,636-10%
Capon Springs$1,651-9%
Carolina$1,708-6%
Carpendale$1,640-10%
Cass$1,8150%
Cassville$1,661-9%
Cedar Grove$1,782-2%
Cedarville$1,8633%
Center Point$1,8230%
Ceredo$1,786-2%
Chapmanville$2,01611%
Charles Town$1,586-13%
Charleston$1,765-3%
Charlton Heights$1,727-5%
Charmco$1,694-7%
Chattaroy$2,16419%
Chauncey$2,03712%
Cheat Lake$1,692-7%
Chesapeake$1,784-2%
Chester$1,684-7%
Chloe$1,9045%
Circleville$1,8291%
Clarksburg$1,715-6%
Clay$1,8602%
Clear Creek$1,778-2%
Clear Fork$1,9739%
Clendenin$1,803-1%
Cleveland$1,8753%
Clothier$2,01611%
Coal City$1,774-2%
Coal Mountain$2,00610%
Coaldale$1,716-6%
Coalton$1,797-1%
Coburn$1,773-2%
Colcord$1,807-1%
Colfax$1,696-7%
Colliers$1,658-9%
Comfort$1,8492%
Cool Ridge$1,759-3%
Copen$1,8411%
Cora$2,01211%
Corinne$1,9397%
Costa$1,8663%
Cottageville$1,797-1%
Cove Gap$2,08015%
Covel$1,9447%
Cowen$1,797-1%
Coxs Mills$1,8804%
Crab Orchard$1,769-3%
Craigsville$1,730-5%
Crawford$1,8874%
Crawley$1,661-9%
Creston$1,8693%
Crichton$1,696-7%
Cross Lanes$1,755-3%
Crum$2,15319%
Cucumber$1,9367%
Culloden$1,768-3%
Cyclone$2,01311%
Dailey$1,8220%
Dallas$1,697-7%
Danese$1,720-5%
Daniels$1,747-4%
Danville$1,9457%
Davin$2,00210%
Davis$1,8421%
Davisville$1,723-5%
Davy$1,9487%
Dawes$1,794-1%
Deep Water$1,727-5%
Dehue$2,02011%
Delbarton$2,14018%
Dellslow$1,689-7%
Delray$1,642-10%
Despard$1,703-6%
Diana$1,8200%
Dille$1,8572%
Dingess$2,18320%
Dixie$1,742-4%
Dorothy$1,8110%
Dothan$1,723-5%
Drennen$1,790-1%
Dry Creek$1,8482%
Dry Fork$1,8251%
Drybranch$1,750-4%
Duck$1,8371%
Dunbar$1,736-4%
Duncan$1,804-1%
Dunlow$2,16019%
Dunmore$1,786-2%
Durbin$1,8160%
Earling$2,01911%
East Bank$1,761-3%
East Lynn$2,08315%
Eccles$1,773-2%
Eckman$1,9336%
Edgarton$2,15219%
Edmond$1,721-5%
Eglon$1,8532%
Elbert$1,9357%
Eleanor$1,738-4%
Elizabeth$1,8934%
Elk Garden$1,666-8%
Elkhorn$1,9417%
Elkins$1,785-2%
Elkview$1,788-2%
Ellamore$1,8250%
Ellenboro$1,8411%
Emmett$2,15118%
Enterprise$1,710-6%
Erbacon$1,8200%
Eskdale$1,802-1%
Ethel$2,00911%
Eureka$1,8230%
Evans$1,793-1%
Exchange$1,8210%
Fairdale$1,8190%
Fairlea$1,662-8%
Fairmont$1,684-7%
Fairview$1,696-7%
Falling Rock$1,796-1%
Falling Waters$1,563-14%
Falls Mill$1,8633%
Fanrock$1,9668%
Farmington$1,721-5%
Fayetteville$1,715-6%
Fenwick$1,739-4%
Filbert$1,9357%
Fisher$1,673-8%
Flat Top$1,730-5%
Flatwoods$1,8190%
Flemington$1,8160%
Floe$1,9045%
Follansbee$1,647-9%
Folsom$1,777-2%
Forest Hill$1,753-3%
Fort Ashby$1,639-10%
Fort Gay$2,10916%
Foster$1,9186%
Four States$1,715-6%
Frametown$1,8180%
Frankford$1,647-9%
Franklin$1,8070%
Fraziers Bottom$1,794-1%
Freeman$1,716-6%
French Creek$1,8532%
Frenchton$1,8783%
Friendly$1,766-3%
Gallagher$1,754-3%
Gallipolis Ferry$1,778-2%
Galloway$1,8452%
Gandeeville$1,8773%
Gap Mills$1,741-4%
Gary$1,9296%
Gassaway$1,796-1%
Gauley Bridge$1,728-5%
Gauley Mills$1,8230%
Gay$1,805-1%
Genoa$2,10916%
Gerrardstown$1,573-13%
Ghent$1,770-3%
Gilbert$2,14818%
Gilboa$1,746-4%
Given$1,801-1%
Glady$1,779-2%
Glasgow$1,760-3%
Glen$1,9005%
Glen Dale$1,681-7%
Glen Daniel$1,8240%
Glen Easton$1,691-7%
Glen Ferris$1,733-5%
Glen Fork$1,9889%
Glen Jean$1,748-4%
Glen Rogers$1,9829%
Glen White$1,776-2%
Glengary$1,608-11%
Glenville$1,8723%
Glenwood$1,764-3%
Gordon$1,9286%
Gormania$1,693-7%
Grafton$1,8240%
Grant Town$1,711-6%
Grantsville$1,8864%
Granville$1,658-9%
Grassy Meadows$1,690-7%
Great Cacapon$1,613-11%
Green Bank$1,787-2%
Green Spring$1,663-8%
Green Sulphur Springs$1,771-2%
Greenville$1,736-4%
Griffithsville$2,03212%
Gypsy$1,730-5%
Hacker Valley$1,8592%
Halltown$1,592-12%
Hambleton$1,8602%
Hamlin$2,03112%
Handley$1,750-4%
Hanover$2,00110%
Hansford$1,766-3%
Harman$1,8130%
Harper$1,773-2%
Harrisville$1,8552%
Hartford$1,751-4%
Hartford City$1,751-4%
Harts$2,05813%
Haywood$1,706-6%
Heaters$1,8452%
Hedgesville$1,578-13%
Helen$1,779-2%
Helvetia$1,8110%
Henderson$1,774-2%
Hendricks$1,8361%
Henlawson$2,00811%
Hensley$1,9819%
Hepzibah$1,706-6%
Herndon$1,9548%
Hernshaw$1,781-2%
Hewett$1,9316%
Hiawatha$1,762-3%
Hico$1,728-5%
High View$1,641-10%
Hillsboro$1,771-2%
Hilltop$1,716-6%
Hinton$1,758-3%
Holden$2,01911%
Hometown$1,737-4%
Hooverson Heights$1,651-9%
Horner$1,805-1%
Hugheston$1,764-3%
Hundred$1,8261%
Huntington$1,792-1%
Hurricane$1,748-4%
Iaeger$1,9618%
Idamay$1,707-6%
Ikes Fork$2,00911%
Independence$1,8401%
Indian Mills$1,753-3%
Indore$1,8763%
Institute$1,750-4%
Inwood$1,573-13%
Ireland$1,8220%
Isaban$2,04413%
Itmann$1,9477%
Ivydale$1,8824%
Jacksonburg$1,767-3%
Jane Lew$1,8180%
Jeffrey$1,9326%
Jenkinjones$1,9357%
Jesse$1,9839%
Job$1,794-1%
Jolo$1,9688%
Josephine$1,795-1%
Julian$1,9196%
Jumping Branch$1,769-3%
Junior$1,8311%
Justice$2,17120%
Kanawha Falls$1,725-5%
Kanawha Head$1,8623%
Kearneysville$1,585-13%
Kegley$1,698-7%
Kellysville$1,715-6%
Kenna$1,8361%
Kenova$1,791-1%
Kerens$1,790-1%
Kermit$2,22723%
Keslers Cross Lanes$1,750-4%
Keyser$1,646-9%
Kiahsville$2,08015%
Kimball$1,9357%
Kimberly$1,729-5%
Kincaid$1,729-5%
Kingmont$1,696-7%
Kingwood$1,8261%
Kirby$1,643-10%
Kistler$2,00911%
Kopperston$1,99310%
Kyle$1,9477%
Lahmansville$1,710-6%
Lake$2,00510%
Lanark$1,775-2%
Lansing$1,719-5%
Lashmeet$1,711-6%
Lavalette$1,9698%
Layland$1,739-4%
Le Roy$1,804-1%
Left Hand$1,8864%
Lehew$1,653-9%
Leivasy$1,756-3%
Lenore$2,15219%
Leon$1,772-2%
Lerona$1,688-7%
Lesage$1,790-1%
Leslie$1,687-7%
Lester$1,791-1%
Letart$1,766-3%
Levels$1,660-9%
Lewisburg$1,667-8%
Liberty$1,738-4%
Lindside$1,738-4%
Linn$1,8783%
Little Birch$1,8261%
Littleton$1,781-2%
Liverpool$1,804-1%
Livingston$1,754-3%
Lizemores$1,8854%
Lochgelly$1,719-5%
Logan$2,01211%
London$1,749-4%
Lookout$1,741-4%
Looneyville$1,8763%
Lorado$2,02111%
Lorentz$1,8361%
Lost City$1,663-8%
Lost Creek$1,766-3%
Lost River$1,663-8%
Lubeck$1,696-7%
Lumberport$1,750-4%
Lundale$2,02111%
Lyburn$2,01911%
Lynco$1,9849%
Maben$1,9729%
Mabie$1,794-1%
Mabscott$1,770-3%
MacArthur$1,780-2%
Macfarlan$1,8783%
Madison$1,9437%
Mahan$1,754-3%
Maidsville$1,671-8%
Mallory$2,00210%
Mammoth$1,763-3%
Man$2,01011%
Mannington$1,754-3%
Marfrance$1,696-7%
Marianna$1,98910%
Marlinton$1,798-1%
Marmet$1,777-2%
Martinsburg$1,559-14%
Mason$1,754-3%
Masontown$1,8612%
Matewan$2,14118%
Matheny$1,9829%
Mathias$1,640-10%
Matoaka$1,750-4%
Maxwelton$1,656-9%
Maybeury$1,9568%
Maysel$1,8964%
Maysville$1,714-6%
Mc Graws$1,9749%
McMechen$1,690-7%
Meadow Bluff$1,688-7%
Meadow Bridge$1,742-4%
Meadow Creek$1,748-4%
Meadowbrook$1,700-6%
Metz$1,758-3%
Miami$1,785-2%
Middlebourne$1,750-4%
Midkiff$2,02812%
Midway$1,767-3%
Milam$1,691-7%
Mill Creek$1,8301%
Millstone$1,8834%
Millville$1,592-12%
Millwood$1,801-1%
Milton$1,782-2%
Minden$1,711-6%
Mineral Wells$1,719-5%
Moatsville$1,8633%
Mohawk$2,02311%
Monongah$1,679-8%
Montana Mines$1,705-6%
Montcalm$1,702-6%
Monterville$1,8090%
Montgomery$1,742-4%
Montrose$1,798-1%
Moorefield$1,657-9%
Morgantown$1,660-9%
Moundsville$1,681-7%
Mount Alto$1,799-1%
Mount Carbon$1,724-5%
Mount Clare$1,712-6%
Mount Gay$2,01211%
Mount Gay-Shamrock$2,01511%
Mount Hope$1,733-5%
Mount Lookout$1,744-4%
Mount Nebo$1,727-5%
Mount Storm$1,719-5%
Mount Zion$1,8743%
Mullens$1,9588%
Munday$1,8814%
Myra$2,00811%
Nallen$1,735-4%
Naoma$1,8733%
Napier$1,8633%
Naugatuck$2,15719%
Nebo$1,8673%
Nellis$1,8834%
Nemours$1,698-7%
Nettie$1,725-5%
New Creek$1,664-8%
New Cumberland$1,682-7%
New Haven$1,748-4%
New Manchester$1,688-7%
New Martinsville$1,744-4%
New Milton$1,8281%
New Richmond$1,9729%
Newburg$1,8321%
Newell$1,685-7%
Newhall$1,9578%
Newton$1,9236%
Newtown$2,14218%
Nicut$1,8502%
Nimitz$1,735-4%
Nitro$1,757-3%
Nobe$1,8844%
Normantown$1,8753%
North Hills$1,716-6%
North Matewan$2,15219%
North Spring$2,01211%
Northfork$1,9437%
Norton$1,793-1%
Nutter Fort$1,714-6%
Oak Hill$1,707-6%
Oakvale$1,713-6%
Oceana$1,9799%
Odd$1,779-2%
Old Fields$1,658-9%
Omar$2,01811%
Ona$1,776-2%
Onego$1,800-1%
Orgas$1,8894%
Orlando$1,804-1%
Orma$1,9075%
Osage$1,670-8%
Ottawa$1,9316%
Paden City$1,742-4%
Page$1,728-5%
Pageton$1,9357%
Palestine$1,9035%
Panther$1,9447%
Parkersburg$1,693-7%
Parsons$1,8602%
Paw Paw$1,605-12%
Pax$1,723-5%
Paynesville$1,9668%
Pea Ridge$1,791-1%
Peach Creek$2,01211%
Pecks Mill$2,01611%
Pence Springs$1,729-5%
Pennsboro$1,8472%
Pentress$1,678-8%
Perkins$1,8502%
Petersburg$1,696-7%
Peterstown$1,735-4%
Petroleum$1,8783%
Peytona$1,8743%
Philippi$1,8602%
Pickens$1,8080%
Piedmont$1,646-9%
Pinch$1,785-2%
Pine Grove$1,761-3%
Pineville$1,9708%
Piney View$1,773-2%
Pipestem$1,740-4%
Pleasant Valley$1,679-8%
Poca$1,754-3%
Point Pleasant$1,759-3%
Points$1,660-9%
Pond Gap$1,767-3%
Pool$1,745-4%
Porters Falls$1,750-4%
Powellton$1,726-5%
Pratt$1,750-4%
Premier$1,9216%
Prichard$2,00811%
Prince$1,731-5%
Princeton$1,710-6%
Princewick$1,774-2%
Procious$1,8653%
Proctor$1,700-6%
Prosperity$1,766-3%
Pullman$1,8924%
Purgitsville$1,652-9%
Pursglove$1,700-6%
Quinwood$1,696-7%
Rachel$1,714-6%
Racine$1,8602%
Ragland$2,15619%
Rainelle$1,710-6%
Raleigh$1,773-2%
Ranger$2,06814%
Ranson$1,584-13%
Ravencliff$2,00510%
Ravenswood$1,805-1%
Rawl$2,16219%
Raysal$1,9729%
Reader$1,745-4%
Red Creek$1,8281%
Red House$1,751-4%
Red Jacket$2,12917%
Reedsville$1,8291%
Reedy$1,8995%
Renick$1,646-9%
Reynoldsville$1,726-5%
Rhodell$1,777-2%
Richwood$1,722-5%
Ridgeley$1,640-10%
Ridgeview$1,8884%
Ridgeway$1,573-13%
Rio$1,643-10%
Ripley$1,787-2%
Rippon$1,590-12%
Riverton$1,8100%
Rivesville$1,697-7%
Robinette$2,02011%
Robson$1,720-5%
Rock$1,696-7%
Rock Castle$1,801-1%
Rock Cave$1,8874%
Rock Creek$1,8130%
Rock View$1,9638%
Rockport$1,774-2%
Roderfield$1,9588%
Romney$1,652-9%
Ronceverte$1,660-9%
Rosedale$1,8502%
Rosemont$1,8391%
Rossmore$2,00911%
Rowlesburg$1,8401%
Rupert$1,696-7%
Russelville$1,737-4%
Sabine$1,9729%
Salem$1,772-2%
Salt Rock$1,8311%
Sand Fork$1,8452%
Sand Ridge$1,9105%
Sandstone$1,754-3%
Sandyville$1,805-1%
Sarah Ann$2,01511%
Saulsville$1,9749%
Saxon$1,8250%
Scarbro$1,722-5%
Scott Depot$1,747-4%
Second Creek$1,715-6%
Selbyville$1,8442%
Seneca Rocks$1,800-1%
Seth$1,8643%
Shady Spring$1,763-3%
Shanks$1,658-9%
Shannondale$1,595-12%
Sharples$2,00811%
Shenandoah Junction$1,567-14%
Shepherdstown$1,568-14%
Shinnston$1,687-7%
Shirley$1,804-1%
Shoals$1,8985%
Shock$1,8703%
Short Creek$1,674-8%
Simon$1,99610%
Simpson$1,8391%
Sinks Grove$1,716-5%
Sissonville$1,800-1%
Sistersville$1,754-3%
Skelton$1,776-2%
Slab Fork$1,780-2%
Slanesville$1,662-8%
Slatyfork$1,792-1%
Smithburg$1,8080%
Smithers$1,750-4%
Smithfield$1,8271%
Smithville$1,8723%
Smoot$1,688-7%
Snowshoe$1,785-2%
Sod$2,00310%
Sophia$1,780-2%
South Charleston$1,739-4%
Southside$1,788-2%
Spanishburg$1,712-6%
Spelter$1,715-6%
Spencer$1,8783%
Spring Dale$1,736-4%
Spurlockville$1,99210%
Squire$1,9708%
St. Albans$1,758-3%
St. Marys$1,8261%
Stanaford$1,777-2%
Standard$1,754-3%
Star City$1,652-9%
Stephenson$1,9628%
Stollings$2,02111%
Stonewood$1,710-6%
Stouts Mills$1,8452%
Sugar Grove$1,798-1%
Sumerco$2,00410%
Summersville$1,741-4%
Summit Point$1,593-12%
Surveyor$1,763-3%
Sutton$1,800-1%
Swiss$1,757-3%
Switchback$1,9538%
Switzer$2,01411%
Sylvester$1,8884%
Tad$1,786-2%
Talcott$1,741-4%
Tallmansville$1,8351%
Tanner$1,8844%
Taplin$2,01911%
Teays Valley$1,753-3%
Terra Alta$1,8331%
Tesla$1,8261%
Thacker$2,15219%
Thomas$1,8552%
Thornton$1,8431%
Thorpe$1,9326%
Thurmond$1,723-5%
Tioga$1,747-4%
Tornado$1,762-3%
Triadelphia$1,625-11%
Trout$1,676-8%
Troy$1,8693%
Tunnelton$1,8301%
Turtle Creek$1,9226%
Twilight$1,9367%
Uneeda$1,9206%
Union$1,733-5%
Upper Falls$1,770-3%
Upper Tract$1,790-1%
Upperglade$1,8170%
Valley Bend$1,8190%
Valley Fork$1,8944%
Valley Grove$1,628-10%
Valley Head$1,798-1%
Vallscreek$1,9698%
Van$1,9125%
Varney$2,15219%
Verdunville$2,01911%
Verner$2,15118%
Victor$1,721-5%
Vienna$1,730-5%
Vivian$1,9357%
Volga$1,8170%
Vulcan$2,15219%
Waiteville$1,717-5%
Walkersville$1,8512%
Wallace$1,760-3%
Wallback$1,8944%
Walton$1,9025%
Wana$1,729-5%
War$1,9367%
Wardensville$1,661-9%
Warriormine$1,9578%
Washington$1,701-6%
Waverly$1,735-4%
Wayne$2,02411%
Wayside$1,726-5%
Webster Springs$1,806-1%
Weirton$1,659-9%
Welch$1,9336%
Wellsburg$1,674-8%
West Columbia$1,759-3%
West Hamlin$2,03412%
West Liberty$1,645-9%
West Milford$1,752-4%
West Union$1,803-1%
Weston$1,8150%
Westover$1,655-9%
Wharncliffe$2,13418%
Wharton$1,9326%
Wheeling$1,636-10%
White Oak$1,764-3%
White Sulphur Springs$1,660-9%
Whitesville$1,8200%
Whitman$2,01011%
Whitmer$1,794-1%
Whittaker$1,754-3%
Widen$1,8763%
Wilcoe$1,9357%
Wildcat$1,8220%
Wiley Ford$1,644-9%
Wilkinson$2,01211%
Williamsburg$1,676-8%
Williamson$2,15919%
Williamstown$1,750-4%
Willow Island$1,8230%
Wilsondale$2,09415%
Winding Gulf$1,774-2%
Windsor Heights$1,656-9%
Winfield$1,752-4%
Winifrede$1,770-3%
Winona$1,725-5%
Wolf Creek$1,721-5%
Wolfe$1,696-7%
Woodville$1,9467%
Worthington$1,701-6%
Wyatt$1,730-5%
Wyco$1,9397%
Wyoming$1,9729%
Yawkey$1,99610%
Yellow Spring$1,653-9%
Yolyn$2,02011%

West Virginia law requires its drivers to have at least 25/50/25 car insurance limits:

  • $25,000 of bodily injury liability coverage per person
  • $50,000 of bodily injury liability coverage per accident
  • $25,000 of property damage coverage

West Virginia full-coverage car insurance costs an average of $1,788 a year, or $149 a month. Minimum car insurance costs an average of $716 a year, or $60 a month.

West Virginia is an at-fault state for car insurance. This means the driver responsible for causing an accident is required to pay for the injuries and repairs of others involved in the accident.

Methodology

LendingTree uses insurance rate data from Quadrant Information Services using publicly sourced insurance company filings. Rates are based on an analysis of hundreds of thousands of car insurance quotes for a typical driver. Prices are shown for comparative purposes only. Your own rates may be different.

Unless noted otherwise, quotes are for a full-coverage policy for a 30-year-old man with good credit and a clean driving record who drives a 2015 Honda Civic EX.

Minimum-liability policies provide liability coverage with the state’s required minimum limits.

Full-coverage policies include collision, comprehensive and liability coverage:

  • Bodily injury liability: $50,000 per person, $100,000 per accident
  • Property damage liability: $25,000
  • Uninsured/underinsured motorist bodily injury: $50,000 per person and $100,000 per accident
  • Personal injury protection: minimum limits, where required by law
  • Collision: $500 deductible
  • Comprehensive: $500 deductible


Our team of insurance experts rated insurance companies based on several categories. These categories include average rates, discounts, coverage options, third-party customer service ratings and app/website experience. We weighed these categories based on what customers value in an insurance company.

For third-party customer service ratings, we included Complaint Index scores from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) and financial strength ratings from A.M. Best. NAIC Complaint Index scores are used to determine how satisfied customers are with their claims, while financial strength ratings from A.M. Best reflect the ability to pay out claims.

*USAA is only available to current and former members of the military as well as certain family members.