How to Compare Home Insurance Quotes (2024)
How Does LendingTree Get Paid?
LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

How Does LendingTree Get Paid?

LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

Best Homeowners Insurance in Arkansas (2024)

Updated on:
Content was accurate at the time of publication.

Allstate has the best average rate for Arkansas homeowners insurance, at $289 a month. It also has the best selection of discounts.

Shelter has the best complaint rating of the state’s home insurance companies and offers many coverage options.

Find the Cheapest Home Insurance Quotes in Arkansas

Best cheap home insurance companies in Arkansas

$3,473/year
Cheapest rates: Allstate
Allstate logo
$3,629/year
Runner up: Farmers
Farmers logo
$3,810/year
Next cheapest rates: USAA
USAA logo
+
More Options

Arkansas residents get the cheapest home insurance from Allstate, at an average rate of $3,473 a year. This is 7% cheaper than the statewide average rate for home insurance.

Farmers is the second-cheapest choice, at $3,629 a year.

Cheapest companies in Arkansas

CompanyAverage annual rateLendingTree score
allstate logoAllstate$3,473
4 stars
Farmers logoFarmers$3,629
3.5 stars
usaa logoUSAA*$3,810
4 stars
shelter logoShelter$4,040 Not rated
nationwide logoNationwide$4,249
3.5 stars
state farm logoState Farm$4,336
4 stars

*USAA is only available to active-duty and veteran military members and their families.

Allstate, Shelter and USAA are the best home insurance companies in Arkansas.

Allstate has the cheapest home insurance rates and best discount options.

Meanwhile, Shelter has the best NAIC Complaint Index rating and USAA has the best benefits for military personnel.

Best Arkansas home insurance companies

CompanyAverage annual rate Customer satisfaction Customer satisfaction scores are from J.D. Power’s 2023 U.S. Home Insurance Study. Complaint index Complaint index ratings come from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). Lower scores are better; 1.0 is average.
Allstate$3,473 8681.79
Shelter$4,040 Not rated0.31
USAA$3,810 899Not rated
Average$3,722 in Arkansas8691.0

Cheapest rates and best discounts: Allstate

Allstate has Arkansas’ cheapest home insurance rate of $3,473 a year, on average. It also offers many discounts to lower your premium even more.

If you bundle your home and auto insurance with Allstate, you could save up to 25% on your premiums. It also gives discounts for:

  • Buying a newly constructed home
  • Early policy signing
  • Automatic payment sign-up
  • Installing fire alarms or other safety systems
  • Loyalty

ProsCons

 Wide range of discounts

 Low annual rate in Arkansas

 No banned breed dog list

 More complaints than average

 Doesn’t offer extended replacement cost coverage

Homeowners insurance companies offer discounts to policyholders to stay competitive. When you compare home insurance quotes, be sure to ask about discounts.

Best complaint index rating: Shelter

Shelter has a National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) Complaint Index rating of 0.31. This is the best complaint rating of the homeowners insurance companies we surveyed in Arkansas.

ProsCons

 Excellent complaint rating

 Good discounts

 No 24/7 customer service

 Premium higher than Arkansas average rate

The NAIC Complaint Index rates insurance companies based on claim-based complaints they receive, compared to similar-sized companies.

Best for military members: USAA

USAA has homeowners insurance policy offerings tailored to active-duty and veteran military members. Both USAA’s claims satisfaction and complaint index ratings are excellent.

ProsCons

 Top-tier claims satisfaction

 Active-duty service members get coverage for military equipment and uniforms with no deductible

 Personal property coverage at replacement cost

 No dedicated agents

 Only available to active-duty and veteran military and their families

 Few discounts compared to competitors

Find the Cheapest Home Insurance Quotes in Arkansas

The average cost of home insurance in Arkansas is $3,722 a year, which is 33% higher than the national average home insurance rate of $2,801 a year.

Insurers calculate your home insurance quote by weighing different risk factors, including your:

  • ZIP code
  • Home’s age and construction materials
  • Coverage limits and deductible
  • Insurance claim history

Standard home insurance policies tend to be similar from company to company. However, as you can see, premiums vary. This is due to homeowners insurance companies weighing risk factors differently.

The dwelling coverage limit you choose impacts the price of your homeowners insurance policy. The higher the limit, the higher your premium.

For example, you’ll pay $769 a year more for a home insurance policy with $450,000 of dwelling coverage than you would for a $350,000 policy in Arkansas. That’s an extra $64 a month.

Average annual rate by dwelling coverage

Dwelling coverage limitAverage annual rate
$350,000 $3,357
$400,000 $3,722
$450,000 $4,126

If you want to save money on your home insurance costs, consider raising your deductible. The higher your deductible, the lower your annual premium.

Find the Cheapest Home Insurance Quotes in Arkansas

Of Arkansas cities, Tumbling Shoals has the cheapest homeowners insurance rates, at an average of $3,327 a year. Guion has the most expensive average premiums, at $4,376 a year.

Average home insurance rate by city

CityAverage annual rate
Adona$3,685
Alexander$3,695
Alicia$3,440
Alix$3,777
Alleene$4,022
Alma$3,996
Almyra$3,658
Alpena$3,607
Alpine$3,846
Altheimer$3,791
Altus$3,854
Amagon$3,999
Amity$3,870
Antoine$3,845
Arkadelphia$3,894
Arkansas City$3,767
Armorel$3,577
Ash Flat$3,638
Ashdown$4,066
Atkins$3,544
Aubrey$3,748
Augusta$3,774
Austin$3,716
Avoca$3,473
Bald Knob$3,941
Banks$3,949
Barling$3,871
Barton$3,737
Bass$3,556
Bassett$3,576
Batesville$3,526
Bauxite$3,756
Bay$3,600
Bearden$3,851
Bee Branch$3,416
Beebe$3,726
Beech Grove$3,577
Beedeville$3,901
Beirne$3,844
Bella Vista$3,470
Belleville$3,654
Ben Lomond$4,069
Benton$3,780
Bentonville$3,603
Bergman$3,632
Berryville$3,605
Bethel Heights$3,442
Bexar$3,554
Big Flat$3,502
Bigelow$3,479
Biggers$3,404
Bismarck$3,827
Black Oak$3,627
Black Rock$3,562
Blevins$4,164
Bluff City$4,060
Bluffton$3,650
Blytheville$3,823
Board Camp$3,776
Boles$3,711
Bonnerdale$3,790
Bono$3,594
Booneville$3,785
Bradford$3,873
Bradley$4,028
Branch$3,724
Brickeys$3,925
Briggsville$3,636
Brinkley$4,003
Brockwell$4,177
Brookland$3,609
Bruno$3,552
Bryant$3,736
Buckner$3,949
Bull Shoals$3,381
Burdette$3,628
Cabot$3,655
Caddo Gap$3,935
Caldwell$4,037
Cale$4,006
Calico Rock$3,939
Calion$3,935
Camden$3,883
Cammack Village$3,339
Camp$3,568
Canehill$3,546
Caraway$3,594
Carlisle$3,687
Carthage$3,964
Casa$3,736
Cash$3,619
Casscoe$3,702
Caulksville$3,753
Cave City$3,613
Cave Springs$3,527
Cecil$3,675
Cedarville$3,977
Center Ridge$3,576
Centerton$3,590
Charleston$3,684
Charlotte$3,511
Cherokee Village$3,606
Cherry Valley$3,985
Chester$3,655
Chidester$4,050
Clarendon$4,017
Clarkedale$3,672
Clarkridge$3,459
Clarksville$3,772
Cleveland$3,475
Clinton$3,481
Coal Hill$3,773
College Station$3,586
Colt$4,016
Columbus$4,203
Combs$3,384
Compton$3,740
Concord$3,386
Conway$3,470
Cord$3,473
Corning$3,588
Cotter$3,406
Cotton Plant$3,903
Cove$4,019
Coy$3,636
Crawfordsville$3,624
Crocketts Bluff$3,640
Crossett$4,078
Crumrod$3,758
Curtis$4,017
Cushman$3,550
Damascus$3,524
Danville$3,797
Dardanelle$3,644
Datto$3,539
De Queen$4,069
De Valls Bluff$3,831
De Witt$3,693
Decatur$3,669
Deer$3,813
Delaplaine$3,551
Delaware$3,692
Delight$3,902
Dell$3,657
Dennard$3,575
Dermott$4,004
Des Arc$3,792
Desha$3,517
DeWitt$3,678
Diamond City$3,614
Diaz$4,027
Dierks$4,229
Doddridge$3,996
Dolph$3,804
Donaldson$3,845
Dover$3,598
Drasco$3,361
Driver$3,618
Dumas$3,798
Dyess$3,712
Earle$3,588
East Camden$3,908
East End$3,642
Edgemont$3,398
Edmondson$3,549
El Dorado$3,848
El Paso$3,704
Elaine$3,813
Elizabeth$3,505
Elkins$3,463
Elm Springs$3,582
Emerson$3,770
Emmet$4,154
England$3,657
Enola$3,575
Ethel$3,674
Etowah$3,727
Eudora$4,119
Eureka Springs$3,589
Evansville$3,484
Evening Shade$3,692
Everton$3,667
Fairfield Bay$3,529
Farmington$3,524
Fayetteville$3,548
Fifty Six$4,027
Fisher$4,043
Flippin$3,383
Floral$3,421
Fordyce$3,891
Foreman$4,036
Forrest City$3,950
Fort Smith$3,839
Fouke$3,959
Fountain Hill$4,071
Fox$3,664
Franklin$4,292
Fredonia (Biscoe)$3,793
Frenchmans Bayou$3,668
Friendship$3,749
Fulton$4,168
Gamaliel$3,466
Garfield$3,503
Garland City$3,963
Garner$3,801
Gassville$3,421
Gateway$3,532
Genoa$3,925
Gentry$3,737
Gepp$3,556
Gibson$3,477
Gilbert$3,630
Gillett$3,686
Gillham$4,073
Gilmore$3,646
Glencoe$3,539
Glenwood$3,896
Goodwin$3,967
Goshen$3,662
Gosnell$3,836
Gould$3,694
Grady$3,745
Grannis$3,970
Grapevine$3,745
Gravelly$3,751
Gravette$3,587
Green Forest$3,945
Greenbrier$3,560
Greenland$3,521
Greenway$3,512
Greenwood$3,612
Greers Ferry$3,435
Gregory$3,831
Griffithville$3,853
Grubbs$3,952
Guion$4,376
Gurdon$3,889
Guy$3,580
Hackett$3,644
Hagarville$3,572
Hamburg$4,079
Hampton$3,970
Hardy$3,585
Harrell$3,946
Harriet$3,642
Harrisburg$3,921
Harrison$3,604
Hartford$3,664
Hartman$3,781
Harvey$3,792
Haskell$3,668
Hasty$3,715
Hatfield$4,111
Hattieville$3,604
Havana$3,802
Haynes$3,829
Hazen$3,801
Heber Springs$3,401
Hector$3,594
Helena-West Helena$3,817
Henderson$3,492
Hensley$3,727
Hermitage$3,970
Heth$3,857
Hickory Plains$3,704
Hickory Ridge$3,928
Higden$3,444
Higginson$3,818
Highfill$3,632
Highland$3,589
Hindsville$3,439
Hiwasse$3,524
Holiday Island$3,590
Holly Grove$4,000
Hope$4,188
Horatio$4,051
Horseshoe Bend$3,829
Hot Springs$3,613
Hot Springs National Park$3,626
Hot Springs Village$3,515
Houston$3,543
Hoxie$3,538
Hughes$3,677
Humnoke$3,687
Humphrey$3,670
Hunter$3,863
Huntington$3,712
Huntsville$3,514
Huttig$3,995
Ida$3,334
Imboden$3,500
Ivan$3,836
Jacksonport$3,989
Jacksonville$3,628
Jasper$3,732
Jefferson$3,845
Jersey$3,929
Jerusalem$3,580
Jessieville$3,633
Johnson$3,592
Joiner$3,681
Jones Mill$3,810
Jonesboro$3,593
Judsonia$3,815
Junction City$3,898
Keiser$3,709
Kensett$3,764
Keo$3,651
Kibler$3,986
Kingsland$3,917
Kingston$3,449
Kirby$3,943
Knobel$3,554
Knoxville$3,665
La Grange$3,855
Lafe$3,530
Lake City$3,594
Lake Hamilton$3,577
Lake Village$4,101
Lakeview$3,409
Lamar$3,670
Lambrook$3,831
Landmark$3,638
Langley$3,953
Lavaca$3,966
Lawson$3,845
Leachville$3,780
Lead Hill$3,591
Leola$3,740
Lepanto$3,982
Leslie$3,725
Letona$3,755
Lewisville$4,023
Lexa$3,846
Lincoln$3,545
Little Flock$3,451
Little Rock$3,650
Little Rock Air Force Base$3,774
Lockesburg$4,092
Locust Grove$3,478
London$3,616
Lonoke$3,699
Lonsdale$3,635
Louann$3,840
Lowell$3,439
Luxora$3,720
Lynn$3,581
Mabelvale$3,759
Madison$3,952
Magazine$3,778
Magnolia$3,753
Malvern$3,910
Mammoth Spring$3,554
Manila$3,797
Mansfield$3,796
Marble Falls$3,753
Marcella$3,594
Marianna$3,942
Marion$3,547
Marked Tree$3,973
Marmaduke$3,596
Marshall$3,672
Marvell$3,876
Maumelle$3,519
Mayflower$3,476
Maynard$3,406
Maysville$3,536
Mc Caskill$4,129
Mc Crory$3,879
Mc Dougal$3,550
Mc Gehee$3,891
Mc Neil$3,954
Mc Rae$3,721
McAlmont$3,651
McCrory$3,867
McGehee$3,894
Melbourne$3,892
Mellwood$3,821
Mena$3,963
Menifee$3,510
Midland$3,755
Midway$3,422
Mineral Springs$4,193
Minturn$3,555
Monette$3,646
Monticello$3,988
Montrose$4,079
Moro$3,882
Morrilton$3,668
Morrow$3,509
Moscow$4,042
Mount Holly$3,856
Mount Ida$3,909
Mount Judea$3,556
Mount Pleasant$4,039
Mount Vernon$3,514
Mountain Home$3,399
Mountain Pine$3,568
Mountain View$3,856
Mountainburg$3,755
Mulberry$3,743
Murfreesboro$3,969
Nashville$4,220
Natural Dam$3,677
New Blaine$3,627
New Edinburg$3,881
Newark$3,510
Newhope$4,089
Newport$4,026
Norfork$3,529
Norman$3,885
Norphlet$3,832
North Crossett$4,099
North Little Rock$3,596
O Kean$3,354
Oak Grove$3,597
Oak Grove Heights$3,602
Oakland$3,370
Oark$3,739
Oden$3,957
Ogden$4,033
Oil Trough$3,492
Okolona$3,868
Ola$3,799
Omaha$3,561
Oneida$3,804
Onia$3,727
Osceola$3,702
Oxford$3,963
Ozan$4,206
Ozark$3,818
Ozone$3,706
Palestine$3,984
Pangburn$3,759
Paragould$3,578
Paris$3,822
Parkdale$4,101
Parkin$3,906
Parks$3,809
Paron$3,627
Parthenon$3,702
Patterson$3,807
Pea Ridge$3,484
Peach Orchard$3,524
Pearcy$3,686
Peel$3,501
Pelsor$3,607
Pencil Bluff$3,832
Perry$3,637
Perryville$3,516
Pettigrew$3,450
Pickens$3,907
Piggott$3,520
Pindall$3,592
Pine Bluff$3,827
Pineville$3,885
Piney$3,595
Plainview$3,690
Pleasant Grove$3,739
Pleasant Plains$3,505
Plumerville$3,624
Pocahontas$3,422
Pollard$3,512
Ponca$3,749
Poplar Grove$3,811
Portia$3,509
Portland$4,102
Pottsville$3,559
Poughkeepsie$3,578
Powhatan$3,495
Poyen$3,719
Prairie Creek$3,493
Prairie Grove$3,516
Prattsville$3,719
Prescott$4,034
Prim$3,355
Proctor$3,597
Pyatt$3,568
Quitman$3,370
Ratcliff$3,713
Ravenden$3,552
Ravenden Springs$3,437
Rector$3,638
Redfield$3,802
Reydell$3,767
Reyno$3,487
Rison$3,672
Rivervale$3,895
Rockwell$3,573
Roe$4,002
Rogers$3,469
Rohwer$3,763
Roland$3,613
Romance$3,695
Rose Bud$3,786
Rosie$3,474
Rosston$4,029
Rover$3,701
Royal$3,640
Rudy$4,019
Russell$3,824
Russellville$3,564
Saffell$3,555
Sage$4,325
Salem$3,712
Saratoga$4,139
Scotland$3,459
Scott$3,760
Scranton$3,742
Searcy$3,794
Sedgwick$3,498
Shannon Hills$3,752
Sheridan$3,737
Sherrill$3,731
Sherwood$3,542
Shirley$3,431
Sidney$4,361
Siloam Springs$3,719
Sims$3,889
Smackover$3,846
Smithville$3,559
Snow Lake$3,607
Solgohachia$3,562
Sparkman$3,856
Springdale$3,492
Springfield$3,647
St. Charles$3,556
St. Francis$3,510
St. Joe$3,596
St. Paul$3,531
Stamps$4,044
Star City$3,731
State University$3,576
Stephens$4,001
Story$3,835
Strawberry$3,580
Strong$3,928
Sturkie$3,633
Stuttgart$3,638
Subiaco$3,815
Success$3,524
Sulphur Rock$3,507
Sulphur Springs$3,591
Summers$3,548
Summit$3,419
Sweet Home$3,588
Swifton$3,987
Taylor$3,916
Texarkana$3,968
Thida$3,446
Thornton$4,021
Tichnor$3,573
Tillar$3,889
Tilly$3,484
Timbo$3,761
Tollette$4,185
Tontitown$3,607
Traskwood$3,666
Trumann$3,942
Tucker$3,824
Tuckerman$4,046
Tumbling Shoals$3,327
Tupelo$3,897
Turner$3,751
Turrell$3,615
Twin Groves$3,632
Tyronza$3,957
Ulm$3,659
Umpire$4,001
Uniontown$4,011
Valley Springs$3,520
Van Buren$3,982
Vandervoort$3,973
Vanndale$3,895
Vendor$3,679
Vilonia$3,537
Viola$3,685
Violet Hill$3,937
Wabash$3,847
Wabbaseka$3,752
Walcott$3,560
Waldenburg$4,087
Waldo$3,990
Waldron$3,791
Walnut Ridge$3,509
Ward$3,545
Warm Springs$3,373
Warren$3,897
Washington$4,192
Watson$3,917
Weiner$4,065
Wesley$3,416
West Crossett$4,081
West Fork$3,483
West Helena$3,846
West Memphis$3,579
West Point$3,723
West Ridge$3,668
Western Grove$3,574
Wheatley$3,885
Whelen Springs$4,040
White Hall$3,813
Wickes$4,003
Wideman$3,860
Widener$3,878
Wilburn$3,354
Williford$3,573
Willisville$4,014
Wilmar$3,986
Wilmot$4,110
Wilson$3,770
Wilton$4,031
Winchester$3,821
Winslow$3,400
Winthrop$4,028
Wiseman$3,834
Witter$3,567
Witts Springs$3,581
Woodson$3,546
Wooster$3,476
Wright$3,749
Wrightsville$3,555
Wynne$3,980
Yellville$3,543
Yorktown$3,678

Methodology

The rates shown in this article are based on non-binding quotes collected from Quadrant Information Services. Your rates may vary. Average rates were compiled from rates in Arkansas.

The following coverages and deductible were used unless otherwise noted:

  • $400,000 dwelling coverage
  • $40,000 other structures
  • $200,000 personal property
  • $80,000 loss of use coverage
  • $100,000 liability
  • $5,000 medical payments
  • $1,000 deductible

Our team of insurance experts rated insurance companies based on several categories. These categories include average rates, discounts, coverage options, third party customer service ratings, and app / website experience. We weighted these categories based on what customers value in an insurance company.

For 3rd party customer service ratings, we included NAIC’s Complaint Index scores and financial strength ratings from A.M. Best. NAIC Complaint Index scores are used to determine how satisfied customers are with their claims, while financial strength ratings from A.M. Best reflect the ability to pay out claims.


*USAA is only available to active-duty and veteran military members and their families.

Overall customer satisfaction ratings are from the J.D. Power 2023 U.S. Home Insurance Study.

Complaint ratings are based on NAIC data from 2023.