How to Compare Home Insurance Quotes
How Does LendingTree Get Paid?
LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

How Does LendingTree Get Paid?

LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

Best Homeowners Insurance in Illinois

Published on:
Content was accurate at the time of publication.

Best overall home insurance in Illinois: Erie Insurance

4 star

856

$2,075

Erie has the second-cheapest home insurance rates for most Illinois residents. Also, its overall satisfaction rating is the second highest of the companies we surveyed in Illinois.

Erie’s replacement coverage is noteworthy, too. After a total loss, its guaranteed replacement coverage takes care of the entire cost of rebuilding your home, even if the cost exceeds your dwelling coverage limit.

Pros

+

Low average rates
Excellent customer satisfaction scores
Discounts provide up to 25% savings

Cons

+

No online quotes

Erie is the best home insurance company in Illinois due to its low average annual rate of $2,075 a year and excellent customer satisfaction scores. Nationwide, however, has the cheapest rates for most homeowners at an average rate of $1,545 a year.

Find the Cheapest Home Insurance Quotes in Illinois

Best cheap insurance companies in Illinois

$1,545/year
Best rates: Nationwide
Nationwide logo
$2,075/year
Best overall insurer: Erie
Erie Insurance logo
$2,225/year
Best discounts: Allstate
Allstate logo
+
More Options

Most Illinois homeowners get the cheapest home insurance coverage from Nationwide, which offers an average rate of $1,545 a year. This is 44% less than the state average rate of $2,743.

Cheapest companies in Illinois

CompanyAverage annual rateLendingTree score
nationwide logoNationwide$1,545
3.5 stars
erie logoErie$2,0754 stars
allstate logoAllstate$2,225
4 stars
state farm logoState Farm$2,311
4 stars
country financial logoCountry Financial$2,378
4 stars
chubb logoChubb$2,444Not rated
american family logoAmerican Family$2,924
4 stars
Farmers logoFarmers$3,562
3.5 stars
aaa logoAuto Club$5,9482.0 stars
usaa logoUSAA*$2,013
4 stars

Although USAA is the second-cheapest home insurance company in Illinois, with an average rate of $2,013 a year, it only sells insurance policies to current and veteran military.

Find the Cheapest Home Insurance Quotes in Illinois

Erie is the best home insurance company in Illinois, based on policy price, satisfaction ratings and complaint trends. Nationwide, Allstate, Chubb and USAA are great choices, too.

Illinois home insurance companies by cost, customer satisfaction and complaint rating

CompanyAnnual rateOverall satisfactionComplaint index rating
Best overall: Erie$2,075856NA
Best rates: Nationwide$1,5458121.47%
Best for military: USAA$2,0138810.52%
Best complaint rating: Chubb$2,444NA0.03%
Best discounts: Allstate$2,2258092.90%

Ratings include satisfaction scores from J.D. Power’s 2023 U.S. Home Insurance Study and 2022 complaint data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).

The J.D. Power Property Claims Satisfaction Study measures policyholder satisfaction with their home insurer’s claims experience by tracking factors such as settlement, claim servicing and payout. The average rating is 819. The higher a company’s rating, the better.

NAIC’s Complaint Index rates policyholders’ claim-based complaints filed with state insurance departments compared to other insurers of similar size. The current average index is 1.0. The lower the index, the better.

Best rates in Illinois: Nationwide

Nationwide has the lowest rates for home insurance in Illinois, at an average of $1,545 a year. It also offers some good discounts, such as its bundling and new home purchase discounts, that can lower your annual premium even more.

ProsCons

  Low rates

  No online chat function

  Good discounts

Best for Illinois homeowners in the military: USAA

USAA has a great reputation for affordable rates and top-notch customer service. It only sells insurance products to currently serving and veteran military, though, as well as their families. If you fall into any of those categories, USAA is an excellent choice.

USAA has a low average rate of $2,013 a year for Illinois homeowners. Also, USAA received a score of 881 out of 1,000 in the 2023 J.D. Power U.S. Home Insurance Study, the best of any home insurer. USAA isn’t officially ranked in the study due its limited market; otherwise, it would be at the very top of the study.

ProsCons

  Low average rates

  You’re not assigned a specific USAA agent, and may get a different one every time you contact the company

  Excellent customer satisfaction

  Low complaint rating

  Military-specific home insurance coverage

Best complaint rating: Chubb

While Chubb’s average rates may be on the higher side in Illinois, its complaint rating is the lowest of the companies we surveyed, at 0.03%. When looking for a home insurance company, customer satisfaction is as important a factor to consider as cost and coverage.

Chubb also holds an A+ (Excellent) rating from A.M. Best for financial strength, showing strong confidence and capability to pay out on claims.

ProsCons

  Low complaint rating

  Little website info regarding policy pricing and discounts

  No mobile app access

Best homeowners insurance discounts: Allstate

Allstate’s average rate for home insurance in Illinois is $2,225 a year. While not the cheapest policy available in the state, Allstate does have the best selection of discounts to possibly lower your premium to something competitive with less expensive insurers.

Allstate’s discounts include:

  • Early signing discount: Save up to 10% on your premium by signing up for a new home insurance policy at least seven days before the end of your current policy.
  • Claim-free discount: Having no recent claims on your homeowners insurance when you sign with Allstate can save you up to 20%.
  • Bundling discount: Bundling your home insurance policy with auto or life insurance through Allstate can save up to 25% on your premiums.
  • Welcome and loyalty discount: Save 10% on your home insurance when you switch to Allstate. This discount continues as long as you have your policy with Allstate.

The average cost of homeowners insurance in Illinois is $2,743. Your premium cost is based on many factors, including:

  • The age of the home
  • Construction materials used
  • Crime rates and extreme weather trends in your area
  • Your insurance claim history
  • Coverage limits
  • Discounts

Home insurance companies place different risk weights on these factors, resulting in different policy prices. The best way to get the most coverage at the cheapest price is to compare home insurance quotes from several insurers.

Home insurance rates by coverage amounts

Part of the cost of your home insurance policy depends on the amount of dwelling coverage you need. Dwelling coverage is the amount required to rebuild your home after a total loss.

Home insurance cost by dwelling coverage limit

Coverage amountAverage annual rate
$350,000$2,472
$400,000$2,743
$450,000$3,022

While no state law requires you to carry home insurance, your mortgage lender will usually require you to carry it at replacement value as part of your lending agreement.

Even if you don’t have a mortgage, home insurance is an excellent investment to protect yourself from a financial disaster.

Of Illinois’ biggest cities, Naperville has the lowest average rate of $2,337 a year for home insurance. Chicago has the most expensive rate of $3,322 a year.

Cost of home insurance by city

CityAverage annual rate
Abingdon$2,673
Adair$2,820
Addieville$3,082
Addison$2,328
Albany$2,433
Albers$2,944
Albion$3,222
Aledo$2,762
Alexander$2,825
Alexis$2,690
Algonquin$2,426
Allendale$3,158
Allerton$2,687
Alorton$3,531
Alpha$2,774
Alsey$2,830
Alsip$2,672
Altamont$2,698
Alto Pass$3,496
Alton$2,969
Altona$2,795
Alvin$2,740
Amboy$2,493
Anchor$2,474
Ancona$2,459
Andalusia$2,766
Andover$2,719
Anna$3,497
Annapolis$2,966
Annawan$2,722
Antioch$2,700
Apple River$2,577
Arcola$2,507
Argenta$2,617
Arlington$2,650
Arlington Heights$2,442
Armington$2,592
Armstrong$2,687
Aroma Park$2,715
Arrowsmith$2,490
Arthur$2,543
Ashland$2,791
Ashley$3,151
Ashmore$2,585
Ashton$2,513
Assumption$2,956
Athens$2,857
Atkinson$2,735
Atlanta$2,631
Atwood$2,636
Auburn$2,735
Augusta$2,818
Aurora$2,360
Ava$3,524
Aviston$2,888
Avon$2,801
Baileyville$2,472
Bannockburn$2,696
Bardolph$2,755
Barnhill$3,393
Barrington$2,449
Barrington Hills$2,439
Barry$2,867
Barstow$2,709
Bartelso$2,892
Bartlett$2,357
Bartonville$2,567
Basco$2,732
Batavia$2,289
Batchtown$2,946
Bay View Gardens$2,454
Baylis$2,784
Beach Park$2,597
Beardstown$2,715
Beason$2,616
Beckemeyer$2,868
Bedford Park$2,571
Beecher$2,588
Beecher City$2,845
Belknap$3,592
Belle Rive$3,361
Belleville$2,900
Bellevue$2,581
Bellmont$3,129
Bellwood$2,944
Belvidere$2,444
Bement$2,773
Benld$2,872
Bensenville$2,336
Benson$2,483
Benton$3,541
Berkeley$2,556
Berwick$2,648
Berwyn$2,576
Bethalto$2,950
Bethany$2,750
Bingham$2,856
Bishop Hill$2,750
Bismarck$2,722
Blackstone$2,507
Blandinsville$2,792
Bloomingdale$2,403
Bloomington$2,422
Blue Island$2,739
Blue Mound$2,624
Bluff Springs$2,742
Bluffs$2,932
Bluford$3,349
Boles$3,462
Bolingbrook$2,486
Bolivia$2,796
Bondville$2,391
Bone Gap$3,231
Bonfield$2,760
Bonnie$3,342
Boody$2,510
Boulder Hill$2,348
Bourbonnais$2,647
Bowen$2,789
Braceville$2,624
Bradford$2,679
Bradley$2,668
Braidwood$2,610
Breese$2,853
Bridgeport$3,172
Bridgeview$2,587
Brighton$2,865
Brimfield$2,539
Bristol$2,346
Broadlands$2,486
Broadview$2,875
Brocton$2,746
Brookfield$2,454
Brooklyn$3,221
Brookport$3,553
Broughton$3,477
Browns$3,257
Brownstown$2,889
Brussels$2,943
Bryant$2,807
Buckingham$2,736
Buckley$2,558
Buckner$3,567
Buda$2,705
Buffalo$2,803
Buffalo Grove$2,491
Buffalo Prairie$2,713
Bulpitt$2,853
Buncombe$3,610
Bunker Hill$2,883
Burbank$2,631
Bureau$2,650
Burlington$2,429
Burnham$3,420
Burnt Prairie$3,384
Burr Ridge$2,296
Bushnell$2,740
Butler$2,939
Byron$2,429
Cabery$2,398
Cahokia$3,512
Cairo$3,552
Calhoun$3,079
Calumet City$2,893
Calumet Park$2,758
Camargo$2,532
Cambria$3,517
Cambridge$2,772
Camden$2,789
Cameron$2,654
Camp Grove$2,530
Camp Point$2,904
Campbell Hill$3,478
Campton Hills$2,291
Campus$2,436
Canton$2,803
Cantrall$2,749
Capron$2,505
Carbon Cliff$2,692
Carbondale$3,443
Carlinville$2,888
Carlock$2,452
Carlyle$2,881
Carmi$3,406
Carol Stream$2,413
Carpentersville$2,388
Carrier Mills$3,496
Carterville$3,504
Carthage$2,742
Cary$2,444
Casey$3,017
Caseyville$3,298
Castleton$2,562
Catlin$2,657
Cedar Point$2,489
Cedarville$2,386
Central City$3,081
Centralia$2,955
Centreville$3,549
Cerro Gordo$2,761
Chadwick$2,537
Chambersburg$2,738
Champaign$2,355
Chana$2,470
Channahon$2,595
Channel Lake$2,707
Charleston$2,524
Chatham$2,702
Chenoa$2,495
Cherry$2,652
Cherry Valley$2,378
Chester$2,749
Chesterfield$2,884
Chestnut$2,695
Chicago$3,322
Chicago Heights$2,859
Chicago Ridge$2,624
Chillicothe$2,472
Chrisman$2,786
Christopher$3,542
Cicero$2,648
Cisco$2,781
Cisne$3,437
Cissna Park$2,508
Clare$2,374
Claremont$3,064
Clarendon Hills$2,240
Clayton$2,883
Claytonville$2,526
Clifton$2,539
Clinton$2,717
Coal City$2,644
Coal Valley$2,704
Coatsburg$2,907
Cobden$3,539
Coello$3,429
Coffeen$2,918
Colchester$2,853
Colfax$2,508
Collinsville$2,989
Collison$2,711
Colona$2,681
Colp$3,452
Columbia$2,650
Colusa$2,706
Compton$2,460
Congerville$2,438
Cooksville$2,473
Cornell$2,505
Cornland$2,667
Cortland$2,314
Cottage Hills$2,954
Coulterville$2,799
Country Club Hills$2,867
Countryside$2,435
Cowden$2,825
Crainville$3,508
Crescent City$2,559
Crest Hill$2,488
Creston$2,383
Crestwood$2,681
Crete$2,627
Creve Coeur$2,577
Cropsey$2,473
Crossville$3,425
Crystal Lake$2,453
Crystal Lawns$2,548
Cuba$2,883
Cullom$2,571
Cutler$3,100
Cypress$3,663
Dahinda$2,725
Dakota$2,432
Dalton City$2,732
Dalzell$2,636
Dana$2,493
Danvers$2,561
Danville$2,586
Darien$2,264
Davis$2,363
Davis Junction$2,475
Dawson$2,788
De Land$2,765
De Pue$2,666
De Soto$3,464
De Witt$2,702
Decatur$2,524
Deer Grove$2,430
Deer Park$2,428
Deerfield$2,644
DeKalb$2,283
Delavan$2,617
Dennison$3,149
Des Plaines$2,554
Dewey$2,409
Diamond$2,643
Dieterich$2,746
Dix$3,335
Dixmoor$2,899
Dixon$2,434
Dolton$2,867
Dongola$3,656
Donnellson$2,872
Donovan$2,550
Dorsey$2,934
Dover$2,643
Dow$2,938
Dowell$3,483
Downers Grove$2,268
Downs$2,506
Du Quoin$3,060
Dundas$2,997
Dunfermline$2,804
Dunlap$2,486
Dupo$3,018
Durand$2,471
Dwight$2,458
Eagarville$2,790
Earlville$2,506
East Alton$2,958
East Carondelet$2,985
East Dubuque$2,595
East Dundee$2,408
East Galesburg$2,700
East Hazel Crest$2,848
East Lynn$2,614
East Moline$2,691
East Peoria$2,545
East St. Louis$3,561
Easton$2,828
Eddyville$3,485
Edelstein$2,498
Edgewood$2,732
Edinburg$2,907
Edwards$2,591
Edwardsville$2,960
Effingham$2,649
Elburn$2,308
Eldena$2,433
Eldorado$3,501
Eldred$3,038
Eleroy$2,381
Elgin$2,410
Elizabeth$2,672
Elizabethtown$3,561
Elk Grove Village$2,447
Elkville$3,579
Ellery$3,232
Elliott$2,356
Ellisville$2,863
Ellsworth$2,493
Elmhurst$2,282
Elmwood$2,459
Elmwood Park$2,518
Elvaston$2,732
Elwin$2,531
Elwood$2,647
Emden$2,683
Emington$2,464
Emma$3,334
Energy$3,521
Eola$2,335
Esmond$2,341
Essex$2,736
Eureka$2,445
Evanston$2,491
Evansville$2,844
Evergreen Park$2,654
Ewing$3,642
Fairbury$2,415
Fairfield$3,459
Fairmont$2,548
Fairmont City$3,556
Fairmount$2,720
Fairview Heights$2,937
Farina$2,968
Farmer City$2,683
Farmersville$2,894
Farmington$2,787
Fenton$2,466
Ferris$2,749
Fiatt$2,787
Fidelity$2,893
Fieldon$2,953
Findlay$2,756
Fisher$2,433
Fithian$2,704
Flanagan$2,490
Flat Rock$2,997
Flora$3,183
Flossmoor$2,730
Foosland$2,417
Ford Heights$2,865
Forest City$2,858
Forest Lake$2,686
Forest Park$2,914
Forest View$2,575
Forrest$2,519
Forreston$2,490
Forsyth$2,531
Fort Sheridan$2,646
Fowler$2,888
Fox Lake$2,679
Fox Lake Hills$2,572
Fox River Grove$2,465
Fox Valley$2,483
Frankfort$2,580
Frankfort Heights$3,417
Frankfort Square$2,579
Franklin Grove$2,539
Franklin Park$2,540
Frederick$2,736
Freeburg$2,891
Freeman Spur$3,434
Freeport$2,361
Fulton$2,402
Fults$2,714
Gages Lake$2,545
Galatia$3,560
Galena$2,556
Galesburg$2,664
Galt$2,379
Galva$2,704
Garden Prairie$2,489
Gardner$2,654
Gays$2,681
Geff$3,511
Geneseo$2,647
Geneva$2,287
Genoa$2,324
Georgetown$2,670
Gerlaw$2,628
German Valley$2,417
Germantown$2,903
Germantown Hills$2,470
Gibson City$2,347
Gifford$2,371
Gilberts$2,382
Gillespie$2,872
Gilman$2,558
Gilson$2,712
Girard$2,856
Glasford$2,515
Glen Carbon$2,983
Glen Ellyn$2,301
Glenarm$2,724
Glencoe$2,485
Glendale Heights$2,372
Glenview$2,456
Glenwood$2,799
Godfrey$2,962
Golconda$3,545
Golden$2,934
Golden Eagle$2,910
Golden Gate$3,411
Golf$2,532
Good Hope$2,836
Goodfield$2,441
Goodwine$2,481
Goreville$3,522
Gorham$3,498
Grafton$2,961
Grand Ridge$2,524
Grandview$2,702
Grandwood Park$2,581
Granite City$3,086
Grant Park$2,707
Grantsburg$3,517
Granville$2,485
Graymont$2,463
Grayslake$2,503
Grayville$3,327
Great Lakes$2,591
Green Oaks$2,541
Green Valley$2,624
Greenfield$3,110
Greenup$3,015
Greenview$2,803
Greenville$2,849
Greenwood$2,490
Griggsville$2,821
Gurnee$2,566
Hagaman$2,884
Hagarstown$2,799
Hainesville$2,501
Hamburg$2,914
Hamel$3,090
Hamilton$2,703
Hammond$2,744
Hampshire$2,389
Hampton$2,687
Hanna City$2,617
Hanover Park$2,383
Hardin$2,905
Harrisburg$3,451
Harrison$3,455
Harristown$2,538
Hartford$2,974
Hartsburg$2,633
Harvard$2,470
Harvey$3,043
Harwood Heights$2,499
Havana$2,787
Hawthorn Woods$2,656
Hazel Crest$2,855
Hebron$2,479
Hecker$2,668
Hennepin$2,571
Henning$2,590
Henry$2,502
Heritage Lake$2,535
Herod$3,504
Herrin$3,520
Herscher$2,721
Hettick$2,855
Heyworth$2,449
Hickory Hills$2,591
Hidalgo$3,010
Highland$2,995
Highland Park$2,709
Highwood$2,594
Hillsboro$2,860
Hillsdale$2,756
Hillside$2,507
Hillview$3,045
Hinckley$2,311
Hindsboro$2,579
Hines$2,943
Hinsdale$2,283
Hodgkins$2,445
Hoffman$2,872
Hoffman Estates$2,499
Holcomb$2,406
Holiday Shores$2,975
Homer$2,485
Homer Glen$2,448
Hometown$2,642
Homewood$2,833
Hoopeston$2,599
Hooppole$2,665
Hopkins Park$2,649
Hoyleton$3,125
Hudson$2,426
Huey$2,827
Hull$2,827
Humboldt$2,553
Hume$2,776
Huntley$2,432
Hurst$3,538
Hutsonville$2,963
Illinois City$2,783
Illiopolis$2,817
Ina$3,330
Indian Head Park$2,438
Indianola$2,721
Ingalls Park$2,612
Ingleside$2,722
Ingraham$3,181
Inverness$2,455
Ipava$2,838
Iroquois$2,505
Irvington$3,037
Island Lake$2,564
Itasca$2,357
Ivesdale$2,433
Jacksonville$2,804
Jacob$3,535
Janesville$2,985
Jerome$2,714
Jerseyville$2,911
Jewett$3,011
Johnsburg$2,463
Johnsonville$3,481
Johnston City$3,509
Joliet$2,544
Jonesboro$3,605
Joppa$3,471
Joy$2,723
Junction$3,486
Justice$2,512
Kampsville$3,004
Kane$3,000
Kaneville$2,375
Kankakee$2,709
Kansas$2,819
Karbers Ridge$3,434
Kasbeer$2,668
Keenes$3,503
Keensburg$3,163
Keithsburg$2,742
Kell$3,169
Kempton$2,416
Kenilworth$2,445
Kenney$2,746
Kent$2,399
Kewanee$2,683
Keyesport$2,925
Kildeer$2,664
Kincaid$2,882
Kinderhook$2,840
Kingston Mines$2,529
Kinmundy$3,216
Kinsman$2,685
Kirkland$2,337
Kirkwood$2,697
Knollwood$2,579
Knoxville$2,665
La Fayette$2,585
La Grange$2,429
La Grange Park$2,443
La Place$2,724
La Prairie$2,874
La Rose$2,475
Laclede$2,732
Lacon$2,567
Ladd$2,660
Lafox$2,369
Lake Barrington$2,438
Lake Bluff$2,588
Lake Forest$2,587
Lake Fork$2,623
Lake Holiday$2,420
Lake in the Hills$2,468
Lake of the Woods$2,317
Lake Petersburg$2,795
Lake Villa$2,568
Lake Zurich$2,678
Lakemoor$2,573
Lakewood$2,467
Lakewood Shores$2,620
Lanark$2,512
Lane$2,719
Lansing$2,753
LaSalle$2,459
Latham$2,692
Laura$2,535
Lawndale$2,534
Lawrenceville$3,212
Le Roy$2,474
Lebanon$2,892
Lee$2,433
Lee Center$2,491
Leland$2,482
Leland Grove$2,705
Lemont$2,448
Lena$2,394
Lenzburg$2,968
Leonore$2,482
Lerna$2,748
Lewistown$2,871
Lexington$2,494
Libertyville$2,538
Lima$2,869
Lincoln$2,576
Lincoln's New Salem$2,774
Lincolnshire$2,534
Lincolnwood$2,453
Lindenhurst$2,569
Lindenwood$2,487
Lisle$2,473
Litchfield$2,889
Literberry$2,805
Little York$2,647
Littleton$2,808
Liverpool$2,808
Livingston$3,042
Loami$2,817
Lockport$2,535
Loda$2,502
Logan$3,420
Lomax$2,802
Lombard$2,353
London Mills$2,828
Long Grove$2,603
Long Lake$2,524
Long Point$2,492
Longview$2,478
Loraine$2,882
Lostant$2,563
Louisville$3,217
Lovejoy$3,145
Loves Park$2,416
Lowder$2,759
Lowpoint$2,456
Lynn Center$2,749
Lynwood$2,859
Lyons$2,468
Macedonia$3,443
Machesney Park$2,452
Mackinaw$2,539
Macomb$2,747
Macon$2,613
Madison$3,255
Maeystown$2,655
Magnolia$2,510
Mahomet$2,320
Malden$2,744
Malta$2,344
Manchester$2,827
Manhattan$2,581
Manito$2,785
Manlius$2,682
Mansfield$2,681
Manteno$2,661
Maple Park$2,375
Mapleton$2,600
Marengo$2,473
Marietta$2,813
Marine$3,054
Marion$3,488
Marissa$3,004
Mark$2,482
Markham$2,970
Maroa$2,644
Marquette Heights$2,575
Marseilles$2,491
Marshall$3,103
Martinsville$3,071
Maryville$3,015
Mascoutah$2,918
Mason$2,757
Mason City$2,804
Matherville$2,672
Matteson$2,547
Mattoon$2,462
Maunie$3,364
Maywood$2,912
Mazon$2,683
Mc Connell$2,444
McHenry$2,439
McLean$2,538
McLeansboro$3,470
McNabb$2,519
Mechanicsburg$2,796
Medinah$2,348
Medora$2,893
Melrose Park$2,584
Melvin$2,444
Menard$2,711
Mendon$2,865
Mendota$2,483
Meredosia$2,852
Merna$2,499
Merrionette Park$2,644
Metamora$2,477
Metcalf$2,835
Metropolis$3,484
Mettawa$2,583
Michael$2,885
Middletown$2,707
Midlothian$2,674
Milan$2,716
Milford$2,553
Mill Shoals$3,346
Millbrook$2,392
Milledgeville$2,582
Miller City$3,555
Millington$2,387
Millstadt$2,954
Milmine$2,739
Mineral$2,726
Minier$2,581
Minonk$2,483
Minooka$2,573
Mitchell$3,081
Mode$2,813
Modesto$2,919
Modoc$2,814
Mokena$2,492
Moline$2,697
Momence$2,690
Monee$2,633
Monmouth$2,604
Monroe Center$2,435
Montgomery$2,330
Monticello$2,668
Montrose$2,982
Mooseheart$2,301
Morris$2,652
Morrison$2,414
Morrisonville$2,960
Morton$2,514
Morton Grove$2,442
Mossville$2,498
Mound City$3,596
Mounds$3,527
Mount Auburn$2,923
Mount Carmel$3,094
Mount Carroll$2,555
Mount Erie$3,463
Mount Morris$2,397
Mount Olive$2,844
Mount Prospect$2,433
Mount Pulaski$2,659
Mount Sterling$2,699
Mount Vernon$3,235
Mount Zion$2,538
Moweaqua$2,847
Mozier$2,912
Muddy$3,427
Mulberry Grove$2,918
Mulkeytown$3,603
Muncie$2,590
Mundelein$2,638
Murdock$2,589
Murphysboro$3,457
Nachusa$2,452
Naperville$2,337
Nashville$3,061
Nason$3,245
National Stock Yards$3,118
Nauvoo$2,776
Nebo$2,853
Neoga$2,937
Neponset$2,734
New Athens$2,927
New Baden$2,866
New Bedford$2,673
New Berlin$2,788
New Burnside$3,652
New Canton$2,872
New Douglas$3,035
New Haven$3,470
New Holland$2,686
New Lenox$2,466
New Memphis$2,831
New Milford$2,436
New Salem$2,758
New Windsor$2,750
Newark$2,444
Newman$2,566
Newton$2,941
Niantic$2,643
Niles$2,445
Nilwood$2,832
Niota$2,772
Noble$3,069
Nokomis$2,905
Nora$2,566
Normal$2,446
Norridge$2,499
Norris$2,796
Norris City$3,435
North Aurora$2,319
North Barrington$2,456
North Chicago$2,582
North City$3,545
North Pekin$2,575
North Riverside$2,481
North Utica$2,550
Northbrook$2,427
Northfield$2,436
Northlake$2,611
O'Fallon$2,917
Oak Brook$2,272
Oak Forest$2,668
Oak Lawn$2,609
Oak Park$2,573
Oakbrook Terrace$2,306
Oakdale$3,053
Oakford$2,819
Oakland$2,586
Oakwood$2,648
Oakwood Hills$2,443
Odell$2,533
Odin$3,150
Oglesby$2,461
Ohlman$2,834
Okawville$3,103
Olive Branch$3,582
Olivet$2,766
Olmsted$3,534
Olney$2,980
Olympia Fields$2,672
Onarga$2,562
Oneida$2,767
Opdyke$3,297
Ophiem$2,751
Oquawka$2,778
Orangeville$2,472
Oraville$3,421
Oreana$2,604
Oregon$2,398
Orient$3,454
Orion$2,691
Orland Hills$2,456
Orland Park$2,389
Oswego$2,304
Ottawa$2,463
Owaneco$2,936
Palatine$2,427
Palestine$3,004
Palmer$2,947
Palmyra$2,853
Paloma$2,860
Palos Heights$2,578
Palos Hills$2,579
Palos Park$2,485
Pana$2,871
Panama$2,855
Papineau$2,513
Paris$2,790
Park City$2,614
Park Forest$2,573
Park Ridge$2,492
Parkersburg$3,077
Patoka$3,231
Patterson$2,969
Paw Paw$2,478
Pawnee$2,766
Paxton$2,305
Payson$2,917
Pearl$2,863
Pearl City$2,426
Pecatonica$2,437
Pekin$2,577
Pembroke Township$2,720
Penfield$2,440
Peoria$2,525
Peoria Heights$2,452
Peotone$2,607
Percy$2,847
Perks$3,435
Perry$2,773
Peru$2,432
Petersburg$2,806
Philo$2,408
Phoenix$3,056
Piasa$2,910
Pierron$2,833
Pinckneyville$3,089
Piper City$2,419
Pistakee Highlands$2,459
Pittsburg$3,614
Pittsfield$2,806
Plainfield$2,469
Plainville$2,901
Plano$2,380
Plato Center$2,397
Pleasant Hill$2,900
Pleasant Plains$2,752
Plymouth$2,795
Pocahontas$2,940
Polo$2,446
Pomona$3,517
Pontiac$2,395
Pontoon Beach$3,074
Poplar Grove$2,458
Port Barrington$2,566
Port Byron$2,709
Posen$2,892
Potomac$2,694
Prairie du Rocher$2,814
Prairie Grove$2,446
Preemption$2,624
Prestbury$2,294
Preston Heights$2,638
Princeton$2,635
Prophetstown$2,438
Prospect Heights$2,460
Putnam$2,522
Quincy$2,770
Radom$3,025
Raleigh$3,524
Rankin$2,663
Ransom$2,560
Rantoul$2,339
Rapids City$2,710
Raritan$2,719
Raymond$2,943
Red Bud$2,680
Reddick$2,674
Redmon$2,668
Renault$2,684
Reynolds$2,752
Richmond$2,462
Richton Park$2,564
Ridge Farm$2,769
Rinard$3,416
Ringwood$2,493
River Forest$2,605
River Grove$2,531
Riverdale$2,798
Riverside$2,465
Riverton$2,768
Riverwoods$2,693
Robbins$2,792
Roberts$2,426
Robinson$2,890
Roby$2,796
Rochelle$2,369
Rochester$2,682
Rock City$2,428
Rock Falls$2,354
Rock Island$2,693
Rockbridge$3,038
Rockdale$2,632
Rockford$2,479
Rockport$2,883
Rockton$2,366
Rockwood$2,849
Rolling Meadows$2,420
Rome$2,477
Romeoville$2,544
Roodhouse$3,079
Rosamond$2,901
Roscoe$2,373
Roselle$2,398
Rosemont$2,561
Roseville$2,664
Rosewood Heights$2,967
Rosiclare$3,590
Rossville$2,684
Round Lake$2,519
Round Lake Beach$2,525
Round Lake Heights$2,527
Round Lake Park$2,519
Roxana$2,945
Royal$2,406
Royalton$3,586
Rushville$2,751
Russell$2,678
Rutland$2,513
Sailor Springs$3,158
Salem$3,098
San Jose$2,819
Sandoval$3,096
Sandwich$2,323
Sauk Village$2,865
Savanna$2,488
Savoy$2,324
Sawyerville$2,878
Saybrook$2,494
Scales Mound$2,613
Schaumburg$2,466
Scheller$3,368
Schiller Park$2,555
Schram City$2,862
Sciota$2,761
Scott AFB$2,872
Seaton$2,765
Seatonville$2,669
Secor$2,452
Seneca$2,550
Sesser$3,549
Seward$2,405
Seymour$2,402
Shannon$2,518
Shawneetown$3,574
Sheffield$2,741
Shelbyville$2,780
Sheldon$2,512
Sheridan$2,451
Sherman$2,689
Sherrard$2,646
Shiloh$2,886
Shirland$2,404
Shirley$2,491
Shobonier$2,903
Shorewood$2,520
Shumway$2,731
Sibley$2,404
Sidell$2,733
Sidney$2,460
Silvis$2,677
Sims$3,471
Skokie$2,508
Sleepy Hollow$2,398
Smithboro$2,877
Smithfield$2,840
Smithshire$2,653
Smithton$2,907
Somonauk$2,331
Sorento$2,928
South Barrington$2,471
South Beloit$2,379
South Chicago Heights$2,858
South Elgin$2,380
South Holland$2,830
South Jacksonville$2,801
South Pekin$2,598
South Roxana$2,982
South Suburban$2,613
South Wilmington$2,667
Southern View$2,777
Sparland$2,575
Sparta$2,759
Speer$2,578
Spring Grove$2,436
Spring Valley$2,655
Springerton$3,438
Springfield$2,708
St. Anne$2,753
St. Augustine$2,692
St. Charles$2,272
St. David$2,851
St. Elmo$2,873
St. Francisville$3,225
St. Joseph$2,316
St. Libory$2,943
St. Peter$2,900
Standard$2,473
Stanford$2,542
Staunton$2,867
Ste. Marie$2,929
Steeleville$2,754
Steger$2,748
Sterling$2,379
Steward$2,464
Stewardson$2,818
Stickney$2,600
Stillman Valley$2,404
Stockland$2,476
Stockton$2,600
Stone Park$2,618
Stonington$2,962
Stoy$2,897
Strasburg$2,858
Strawn$2,474
Streamwood$2,476
Streator$2,475
Stronghurst$2,771
Sugar Grove$2,299
Sullivan$2,608
Summerfield$2,869
Summit$2,514
Summit Argo$2,530
Sumner$3,203
Sun River Terrace$2,754
Sutter$2,773
Swansea$2,895
Sycamore$2,307
Table Grove$2,864
Tallula$2,836
Tamaroa$3,098
Tampico$2,400
Taylor Ridge$2,793
Taylor Springs$2,910
Taylorville$2,861
Techny$2,510
Teutopolis$2,664
Texico$3,328
Thawville$2,489
Thayer$2,745
The Galena Territory$2,555
Thebes$3,716
Thomasboro$2,352
Thompsonville$3,618
Thomson$2,536
Thornton$2,792
Tilden$2,782
Tilton$2,625
Timewell$2,634
Tinley Park$2,463
Tiskilwa$2,731
Toledo$2,980
Tolono$2,376
Toluca$2,488
Tonica$2,543
Topeka$2,773
Toulon$2,581
Tovey$2,825
Tower Hill$2,786
Tower Lakes$2,427
Tremont$2,532
Trenton$2,870
Trilla$2,572
Triumph$2,496
Troy$2,967
Troy Grove$2,502
Tuscola$2,444
Twin Grove$2,425
Ullin$3,624
Union$2,451
Union Hill$2,632
Unity$3,503
University Park$2,652
Urbana$2,359
Valier$3,513
Valmeyer$2,773
Van Orin$2,648
Vandalia$2,813
Varna$2,528
Venetian Village$2,570
Venice$3,272
Vermilion$2,676
Vermont$2,903
Vernon$3,158
Vernon Hills$2,643
Verona$2,708
Vienna$3,590
Villa Grove$2,505
Villa Park$2,303
Viola$2,748
Virden$2,774
Virginia$2,835
Wadsworth$2,568
Waggoner$2,897
Walnut Hill$3,278
Walsh$2,768
Walshville$2,945
Waltonville$3,322
Wamac$2,958
Warren$2,631
Warrensburg$2,605
Warrenville$2,472
Warsaw$2,788
Wasco$2,359
Washburn$2,454
Washington$2,553
Washington Park$3,596
Wataga$2,711
Waterloo$2,709
Waterman$2,393
Watseka$2,471
Watson$2,747
Wauconda$2,674
Waukegan$2,596
Waverly$2,869
Wayne$2,335
Wayne City$3,498
Wedron$2,415
Weldon$2,775
Wellington$2,526
Wenona$2,481
West Brooklyn$2,479
West Chicago$2,382
West City$3,549
West Dundee$2,401
West Frankfort$3,523
West Liberty$2,956
West Peoria$2,573
West Point$2,762
West Salem$3,275
West Union$3,067
West York$2,947
Westchester$2,477
Western Springs$2,433
Westfield$3,019
Westmont$2,300
Westville$2,662
Wheaton$2,329
Wheeler$2,963
Wheeling$2,470
White Hall$3,071
White Heath$2,670
Whittington$3,496
Williamsfield$2,722
Williamsville$2,713
Willisville$3,129
Willow Springs$2,528
Willowbrook$2,383
Wilmette$2,456
Wilmington$2,621
Wilsonville$2,825
Winchester$2,909
Winfield$2,381
Winnebago$2,412
Winnetka$2,461
Winthrop Harbor$2,627
Witt$2,942
Wolf Lake$3,583
Wonder Lake$2,488
Wood Dale$2,351
Wood River$2,951
Woodhull$2,784
Woodland$2,467
Woodlawn$3,299
Woodridge$2,362
Woodson$2,789
Woodstock$2,458
Woosung$2,389
Worden$3,030
Worth$2,623
Wrights$2,931
Wyanet$2,730
Wyoming$2,587
Yale$3,042
Yates City$2,744
Yorkville$2,361
Zeigler$3,585
Zion$2,624

The rates shown in this article are based on non-binding quotes collected from Quadrant Information Services. Average rates were compiled from rates in every Illinois ZIP code.

Unless otherwise noted, quoted policies contain the following:

  • Dwelling coverage: $400,000
  • Other structures: $40,000
  • Personal property: $200,000
  • Loss of use: $80,000
  • Personal liability: $100,000
  • Guest medical payments: $5,000
  • Deductible: $1,000

Rates are provided for comparative purposes only.

Overall satisfaction ratings were obtained from J.D. Power’s 2023 U.S. Home Insurance Study. The agency’s scores are based on customer surveys that rate insurance companies on factors including price, policy offerings and claims.

Complaint ratings are based on NAIC Complaint Index data from 2022. A company with a 2.0 Complaint Index score has twice as many confirmed complaints as expected for its size. A company with a 0.5 rating has half as many.

*USAA only provides insurance to currently serving and retired military personnel, and their families.