How to Compare Home Insurance Companies
How Does LendingTree Get Paid?
LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

How Does LendingTree Get Paid?

LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

Best Homeowners Insurance in Massachusetts

Published on:
Content was accurate at the time of publication.

Dorchester Mutual is the best homeowners insurance company in Massachusetts, with the state’s cheapest rates as well as a wide range of coverages and discounts. Dorchester Mutual has an average rate of $685 a year.

Amica is Massachusetts’ best home insurance company if customer service and satisfaction are most important to you.

Find the Cheapest Home Insurance Quotes in Massachusetts

Dorchester Mutual is the cheapest home insurance company in Massachusetts, with an average rate of $685 a year.

Vermont Mutual also offers affordable home insurance to the state’s homeowners, with rates that average $1,000 a year. This is nearly half the state average rate of $1,906 a year.

Cheapest home insurance companies in Massachusetts

CompanyAverage Rate
Dorchester Mutual$685
Vermont Mutual$1,000
Travelers$1,536
USAA*$1,616
Arbella$1,841
Safety$1,850
Amica$2,578
Citizens$3,415

To get the cheapest rate for the coverage you need, compare home insurance quotes from multiple companies while you shop for a policy.

Find the Cheapest Home Insurance Quotes in Your Area

Dorchester Mutual is the best home insurance company overall in Massachusetts, mostly because it has the state’s lowest average rate of $685 a year, or $57 a month.

Amica, Arbella, Safety and Travelers are Massachusetts’ best home insurance companies for specific categories, like coverage options, discounts and customer satisfaction.

Best overall home insurance in Massachusetts: Dorchester Mutual

Dorchester Mutual is Massachusetts’ best home insurance company because of its winning combination of cheap rates, discounts and coverage options.

In particular, Dorchester Mutual offers:

  • The state’s cheapest home insurance rates by a wide margin
  • Many discounts that can save you money, such as lower rates for smart home and protective devices
  • Interesting add-on coverages, like home computer coverage and personal cyber protection

Among Massachusetts home insurance companies, Dorchester Mutual also has the advantage of being locally based and focused, serving state homeowners since 1855.

Best cheap home insurance rates in Massachusetts: Dorchester Mutual

If getting the cheapest homeowners insurance in Massachusetts is your goal, Dorchester Mutual is probably the best company for you.

Dorchester’s average home insurance rate is $685 a year. None of the other companies we surveyed in the state come close. Second-place Vermont Mutual’s average rate is over $300 more at $1,000 a year.

Best home insurance company for customer satisfaction: Amica

Amica is the best insurance company for Massachusetts homeowners who value customer service and satisfaction the most.

  • Amica’s J.D. Power customer satisfaction rating of 844 is one of the highest among insurance companies that serve everyone.
  • Its complaint rating of 0.33 from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) is among the best from the companies surveyed.

Amica’s rates are higher than the state average, but it offers several home insurance discounts that could lower your policy cost. With the company’s multiline discount, for example, you can save up to 30% when you bundle home insurance with auto, umbrella or life coverage.

Best home insurance discounts in Massachusetts: Arbella and Safety

Arbella and Safety are the best home insurance companies in Massachusetts for discounts that can lower the cost of your policy.

Arbella offers home insurance discounts for:

  • First-time customers (up to 7% discount)
  • Home energy assessment (5%)
  • New home (20%)
  • Policy renewal (3%)
  • Safety devices (3%)

Safety has home insurance discounts for:

  • Claim-free (16%)
  • Electronic policy issuance (up to 5% discount)
  • Fire and burglar alarms (16%)
  • New home (18%)

Both Arbella and Safety have multipolicy or bundle discounts that can save you money when you insure your home and auto together. Arbella’s bundling discount goes as high as 25%, while Safety’s is 20%.

Safety also provides multipolicy discounts if you have a personal umbrella and/or dwelling fire policy, as well as an auto policy with the company.

Best home insurance coverage options: Travelers

Travelers is the best homeowners insurance company in Massachusetts for add-on coverage options.

It offers additional coverage for:

  • Green homes
  • Jewelry and valuable items
  • Water backup and sump pump discharge or overflow
  • Identity fraud

Travelers also lets policyholders insure contents or personal property at replacement cost rather than actual cash value. Actual cash value pays you the depreciated value of damaged or destroyed belongings, while replacement cost covers buying new replacements for your valuables.

Policyholders can get additional replacement cost coverage for their home’s structure, too.

The average cost of home insurance in Massachusetts is $1,906 a year, or $159 a month, if you have a dwelling coverage limit of $400,000.

If your dwelling limit is lower than that, you’ll usually pay less for home insurance, while a higher limit could cost you more.

Massachusetts home insurance rates by coverage amount

Dwelling LimitAnnual Rate
$350,000$1,727
$400,000$1,906
$450,000$2,094

Insurance for a home with a dwelling coverage limit of $350,000 costs 18% less than it does for a home with a $450,000 limit.

Dwelling coverage helps pay to repair or rebuild the structure of your home if a covered peril damages or destroys it.

One of the best ways to find out how much a policy will cost you is to compare home insurance quotes from several companies.

Where you live is one of many rate factors that determine what you pay for home insurance. This is why homeowners in Boston tend to pay higher home insurance rates than those in Springfield.

Williamstown homeowners pay the lowest average home insurance premiums, at $1,158 a year. Homeowners in Chilmark pay the state’s highest home insurance premiums, which average $5,044 a year.

CityAnnual Rate
Abington$1,859
Accord$2,127
Acton$1,401
Acushnet$2,547
Acushnet Center$2,487
Adams$1,168
Agawam$1,266
Allston$2,141
Amesbury Town$1,550
Amherst$1,242
Amherst Center$1,235
Andover$1,557
Arlington$1,406
Arlington Heights$1,411
Ashburnham$1,432
Ashby$1,437
Ashfield$1,241
Ashland$1,447
Ashley Falls$1,245
Assonet$2,381
Athol$1,403
Attleboro$1,966
Attleboro Falls$2,024
Auburn$1,428
Auburndale$1,479
Avon$1,625
Ayer$1,339
Babson Park$1,715
Baldwinville$1,409
Barnstable$3,695
Barre$1,417
Becket$1,306
Bedford$1,405
Belchertown$1,277
Bellingham$1,611
Belmont$1,446
Berkley$1,855
Berkshire$1,213
Berlin$1,413
Bernardston$1,210
Beverly$1,846
Billerica$1,397
Blackstone$1,436
Blandford$1,317
Bliss Corner$2,716
Bolton$1,442
Bondsville$1,296
Boston$2,007
Bourne$3,479
Boxborough$1,405
Boxford$1,583
Boylston$1,413
Braintree Town$1,629
Brant Rock$2,174
Brewster$3,647
Bridgewater$1,901
Brighton$2,140
Brimfield$1,387
Brockton$1,977
Brookfield$1,427
Brookline$1,883
Brookline Village$1,878
Bryantville$1,975
Buckland$1,292
Burlington$1,403
Buzzards Bay$3,263
Byfield$1,586
Cambridge$1,550
Canton$1,617
Carlisle$1,437
Carver$2,056
Cataumet$4,087
Centerville$3,682
Charlemont$1,308
Charlestown$2,160
Charlton$1,468
Charlton City$1,458
Charlton Depot$1,445
Chartley$2,138
Chatham$4,247
Chelmsford$1,339
Chelsea$2,217
Cherry Valley$1,408
Cheshire$1,220
Chester$1,303
Chesterfield$1,298
Chestnut Hill$1,773
Chicopee$1,392
Chilmark$5,044
Clinton$1,386
Cochituate$1,429
Cohasset$2,239
Colrain$1,302
Concord$1,400
Conway$1,292
Cordaville$1,369
Cotuit$3,893
Cummaquid$3,904
Cummington$1,284
Cuttyhunk$4,637
Dalton$1,221
Danvers$1,623
Dedham$1,616
Deerfield$1,207
Dennis$3,578
Dennis Port$3,873
Devens$1,328
Dighton$1,825
Dorchester$2,148
Dorchester Center$2,077
Douglas$1,430
Dover$1,560
Dracut$1,399
Drury$1,226
Dudley$1,451
Dunstable$1,361
Duxbury$2,381
East Boston$2,167
East Bridgewater$1,894
East Brookfield$1,417
East Dennis$3,697
East Douglas$1,414
East Falmouth$3,828
East Freetown$2,376
East Harwich$3,837
East Longmeadow$1,291
East Orleans$3,749
East Otis$1,310
East Pepperell$1,348
East Princeton$1,401
East Sandwich$3,476
East Taunton$2,114
East Templeton$1,406
East Walpole$1,596
East Wareham$2,513
East Weymouth$1,657
Eastham$3,874
Easthampton$1,303
Easthampton Town$1,266
Edgartown$4,498
Elmwood$2,029
Erving$1,173
Essex$1,783
Everett$1,501
Fairhaven$2,732
Fall River$2,318
Falmouth$3,976
Fayville$1,362
Feeding Hills$1,335
Fiskdale$1,457
Fitchburg$1,351
Florence$1,246
Forestdale$3,469
Foxboro$1,629
Foxborough$1,621
Framingham$1,430
Franklin$1,588
Franklin Town$1,591
Gardner$1,401
Georgetown$1,587
Gilbertville$1,439
Gill$1,199
Glendale$1,214
Gloucester$2,047
Goshen$1,293
Grafton$1,407
Granby$1,254
Granville$1,347
Great Barrington$1,206
Green Harbor$2,174
Green Harbor-Cedar Crest$2,348
Greenbush$2,179
Greenfield Town$1,211
Groton$1,370
Groveland$1,549
Hadley$1,252
Halifax$1,971
Hampden$1,297
Hanover$1,881
Hanscom AFB$1,434
Hanson$1,883
Harvard$1,383
Harwich Center$4,011
Harwich Port$4,167
Hatfield$1,235
Hathorne$1,679
Haverhill$1,545
Haydenville$1,263
Heath$1,290
Hingham$2,077
Hinsdale$1,242
Holbrook$1,634
Holden$1,408
Holland$1,367
Holliston$1,442
Holyoke$1,350
Hopedale$1,415
Hopkinton$1,479
Housatonic$1,195
Hubbardston$1,456
Hudson$1,438
Hull$2,383
Humarock$2,252
Huntington$1,289
Hyannis$3,845
Hyannis Port$3,796
Hyde Park$2,062
Indian Orchard$1,388
Ipswich$1,756
Jamaica Plain$2,068
Jefferson$1,397
Kingston$2,326
Lake Pleasant$1,215
Lakeville$2,053
Lancaster$1,464
Lanesboro$1,255
Lawrence$1,729
Lee$1,182
Leeds$1,221
Leicester$1,419
Lenox$1,184
Lenox Dale$1,185
Leominster$1,384
Leverett$1,295
Lexington$1,403
Lincoln$1,399
Linwood$1,401
Littleton$1,360
Littleton Common$1,360
Longmeadow$1,260
Lowell$1,530
Ludlow$1,308
Lunenburg$1,418
Lynn$2,074
Lynnfield$1,610
Malden$1,413
Manchaug$1,383
Manchester$1,915
Manchester By The Sea$1,857
Manomet$2,011
Mansfield$1,707
Mansfield Center$1,965
Marblehead$1,963
Marion$2,871
Marion Center$2,700
Marlborough$1,474
Marshfield$2,411
Marshfield Hills$2,350
Marstons Mills$3,844
Mashpee$3,869
Mashpee Neck$3,853
Mattapan$2,066
Mattapoisett$2,872
Mattapoisett Center$2,691
Maynard$1,401
Medfield$1,582
Medford$1,459
Medway$1,599
Melrose$1,405
Mendon$1,415
Menemsha$4,616
Merrimac$1,556
Methuen Town$1,526
Middleboro$2,011
Middleborough Center$1,928
Middlefield$1,298
Middleton$1,606
Milford$1,395
Mill River$1,275
Millbury$1,417
Millers Falls$1,212
Millis$1,599
Millis-Clicquot$1,599
Millville$1,413
Milton$1,589
Milton Village$1,625
Minot$2,249
Monponsett$2,015
Monroe Bridge$1,290
Monson$1,289
Monson Center$1,289
Montague$1,244
Monterey$1,287
Monument Beach$3,503
Nahant$2,005
Nantucket$4,868
Natick$1,434
Needham$1,542
Needham Heights$1,567
New Bedford$2,722
New Braintree$1,417
New Salem$1,307
New Seabury$3,869
New Town$1,417
Newbury$1,781
Newburyport$1,747
Newton$1,483
Newton Center$1,494
Newton Highlands$1,500
Newton Lower Falls$1,493
Newton Upper Falls$1,513
Newtonville$1,492
Nonantum$1,454
Norfolk$1,601
North Adams$1,206
North Amherst$1,227
North Andover$1,579
North Attleboro$1,990
North Billerica$1,374
North Brookfield$1,402
North Carver$1,955
North Chatham$4,262
North Chelmsford$1,374
North Dartmouth$2,561
North Dighton$2,075
North Eastham$3,858
North Easton$2,032
North Egremont$1,275
North Falmouth$3,679
North Grafton$1,398
North Hatfield$1,249
North Lakeville$1,964
North Marshfield$2,259
North Oxford$1,416
North Pembroke$1,882
North Plymouth$2,317
North Reading$1,390
North Scituate$2,286
North Seekonk$2,080
North Truro$3,879
North Uxbridge$1,419
North Waltham$1,415
North Westport$2,608
North Weymouth$1,663
Northampton$1,238
Northborough$1,393
Northbridge$1,405
Northfield$1,296
Northwest Harwich$3,827
Norton$1,699
Norton Center$1,959
Norwell$1,964
Norwood$1,611
Nutting Lake$1,413
Oak Bluffs$4,506
Oakham$1,473
Ocean Bluff$2,226
Ocean Bluff-Brant Rock$2,347
Ocean Grove$2,445
Onset$2,515
Orange$1,234
Orleans$3,739
Osterville$3,624
Otis$1,308
Oxford$1,470
Palmer$1,324
Paxton$1,417
Peabody$1,620
Pembroke$1,882
Pepperell$1,344
Petersham$1,474
Pinehurst$1,405
Pittsfield$1,186
Plainfield$1,309
Plainville$1,634
Plymouth$2,302
Plympton$1,987
Pocasset$3,530
Prides Crossing$1,618
Princeton$1,387
Provincetown$4,048
Quincy$1,772
Randolph$1,606
Raynham$1,873
Raynham Center$2,110
Reading$1,399
Readville$2,113
Rehoboth$1,886
Revere$2,161
Richmond$1,205
Rochdale$1,457
Rochester$2,295
Rockland$1,863
Rockport$1,985
Roslindale$2,045
Rowe$1,275
Rowley$1,721
Roxbury$2,146
Roxbury Crossing$2,140
Royalston$1,473
Russell$1,318
Rutland$1,410
Sagamore$3,505
Sagamore Beach$3,639
Salem$1,838
Salisbury$1,787
Sandisfield$1,305
Sandwich$3,476
Saugus$1,736
Savoy$1,244
Scituate$2,350
Seekonk$1,878
Sharon$1,621
Sheffield$1,251
Shelburne Falls$1,243
Sheldonville$1,601
Sherborn$1,428
Shirley$1,365
Shrewsbury$1,409
Shutesbury$1,284
Siasconset$4,868
Silver Beach$3,483
Smith Mills$2,625
Somerset$2,302
Somerville$1,534
South Amherst$1,224
South Ashburnham$1,388
South Barre$1,433
South Boston$2,238
South Carver$2,183
South Chatham$4,213
South Dartmouth$2,785
South Deerfield$1,233
South Dennis$3,695
South Duxbury$2,317
South Easton$2,054
South Egremont$1,241
South Grafton$1,419
South Hadley$1,269
South Hamilton$1,618
South Harwich$3,821
South Lancaster$1,420
South Lee$1,302
South Orleans$3,796
South Walpole$1,597
South Wellfleet$3,852
South Weymouth$1,629
South Yarmouth$3,828
Southampton$1,249
Southborough$1,382
Southbridge$1,424
Southbridge Town$1,410
Southfield$1,324
Southwick$1,339
Spencer$1,453
Springfield$1,588
Sterling$1,400
Still River$1,399
Stockbridge$1,205
Stoneham$1,420
Stoughton$1,606
Stow$1,362
Sturbridge$1,461
Sudbury$1,421
Sunderland$1,209
Sutton$1,418
Swampscott$1,923
Swansea$2,294
Taunton$1,799
Teaticket$3,828
Templeton$1,407
Tewksbury$1,415
Thorndike$1,320
Three Rivers$1,324
Topsfield$1,616
Townsend$1,331
Truro$4,087
Turners Falls$1,211
Tyngsboro$1,341
Upton$1,387
Uxbridge$1,395
Village Of Nagog Woods$1,407
Vineyard Haven$4,475
Waban$1,498
Wakefield$1,389
Wales$1,349
Walpole$1,592
Waltham$1,439
Ware$1,274
Wareham$2,753
Wareham Center$2,588
Warren$1,452
Warwick$1,284
Watertown Town$1,449
Waverley$1,447
Wayland$1,445
Webster$1,446
Wellesley$1,550
Wellesley Hills$1,590
Wellfleet$4,081
Wendell$1,302
Wendell Depot$1,289
Wenham$1,633
West Barnstable$3,498
West Boxford$1,675
West Boylston$1,411
West Bridgewater$1,846
West Brookfield$1,432
West Chatham$4,247
West Chesterfield$1,288
West Chop$4,645
West Concord$1,399
West Dennis$3,875
West Falmouth$3,962
West Groton$1,363
West Harwich$4,201
West Hatfield$1,238
West Hyannisport$4,169
West Medford$1,431
West Millbury$1,435
West Newbury$1,542
West Newton$1,498
West Roxbury$2,056
West Springfield Town$1,270
West Stockbridge$1,235
West Tisbury$4,557
West Townsend$1,391
West Wareham$2,688
West Warren$1,446
West Yarmouth$3,820
Westborough$1,400
Westfield$1,260
Westford$1,319
Westminster$1,365
Weston$1,441
Westport$2,688
Westport Point$2,516
Westwood$1,592
Weweantic$2,596
Weymouth$1,668
Whately$1,213
Wheelwright$1,420
White Horse Beach$1,972
White Island Shores$2,596
Whitinsville$1,387
Whitman$1,841
Wilbraham$1,293
Williamsburg$1,284
Williamstown$1,158
Wilmington$1,477
Winchendon$1,381
Winchendon Springs$1,381
Winchester$1,436
Windsor$1,279
Winthrop Town$2,274
Woburn$1,416
Woods Hole$3,914
Woodville$1,439
Worcester$1,695
Woronoco$1,305
Worthington$1,279
Wrentham$1,620
Yarmouth Port$3,610

Additional home insurance coverages needed in Massachusetts

Standard home insurance doesn’t cover flood damage or destruction. For that, you need a separate flood insurance policy.

You can buy flood insurance through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) or from private flood insurance companies.

NFIP flood insurance policies offer up to $250,000 coverage for your home and $100,000 for your belongings. If you need or want more than those amounts, contact private flood insurance companies.

No, Massachusetts law does not require you to buy home insurance. If you have a mortgage for your home, though, your lender may require it. Your lender may also require you to get flood insurance for your home if it’s in a flood zone.

Home insurance covers damage to your home and property due to perils like fire, hail, wind, falling objects and burst pipes. It also usually covers vandalism and theft.

Home insurance usually doesn’t cover damage caused by floods, earthquakes, mine subsidence, sinkholes or other earth movements.

To find cheap home insurance in Massachusetts, compare quotes from several companies before buying or renewing a policy. See if you qualify for any discounts, too. And make sure you have the right kinds and amounts of coverage.

Methodology

The rates shown in this article are based on nonbinding quotes collected from Quadrant Information Services. Average rates were compiled from rates in Massachusetts. The following coverages and deductibles were used unless otherwise noted:

  • $400,000 dwelling coverage
  • $40,000 other structures
  • $200,000 personal property
  • $80,000 loss of use coverage
  • $100,000 liability
  • $5,000 medical payments
  • $1,000 deductible

Customer satisfaction and claims satisfaction ratings obtained from the J.D. Power 2023 U.S. Home Insurance Study.

Complaint ratings come from NAIC records for 2023. A confirmed complaint is one that leads to a finding of fault. A company with a 2.0 complaint rating has twice as many confirmed complaints as expected for its size. A company with a 0.5 rating has half as many.

*USAA is only available to current and former members of the military and their families.