How to Compare Home Insurance Companies
How Does LendingTree Get Paid?
LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

How Does LendingTree Get Paid?

LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

Best Homeowners Insurance in Michigan

Published on:
Content was accurate at the time of publication.

Michigan homeowners get the best overall rate for home insurance with Citizens Insurance Group of the Midwest, at an average of $1,004 a year.

Find the Cheapest Home Insurance Quotes in Michigan

Citizens Insurance Group of the Midwest (CIGM) has the cheapest homeowners insurance rate in Michigan, with an average of $1,004 a year. AAA is next at $1,904 a year.

To compare, the average home insurance rate in Michigan is $2,467 a year.

Michigan’s cheapest home insurance companies

Cheapest home insurance companies in Michigan

CompanyAverage annual rate
CIGM$1,004
AAA$1,904
USAA*$2,156
State Farm$2,259
Great Northern$2,464
Frankenmuth$2,676
Farmers$4,803

Find the Cheapest Home Insurance Quotes in Michigan

CIGM, State Farm, Frankenmuth and USAA are the best home insurance companies in Michigan based on cost, customer satisfaction and other factors.

CompanyAverage annual rateOverall satisfaction (higher is better)Complaint index (lower is better)
Best overall: CIGM$1,004NA0.83 (below average)
Most popular: State Farm$2,259873 (above average)1.69 (above average)
Lowest complaint rating: Frankenmuth$2,676NA0.18 (below average)
Best for military families: USAA$2,156899 (above average)2.26 (poor)

Sources: J.D. Power’s 2024 Property Claims Satisfaction Study and 2022 complaint data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).

Best overall: CIGM

CIGM provides the best combination of cost and customer satisfaction in Michigan. Its average home insurance rate of $1,004 a year is less than half the state average rate of $2,467.

CIGM’s NAIC Complaint Index of 0.83, which reflects its claim-based complaints compared to similar-sized insurers, is well under the national average rating of 1.0.

ProsCons

  Lowest average rate in Michigan

  Below-average complaint index

  Easy claim filing

  No local offices

Most popular: State Farm

State Farm has a 9.2% market share for property and casualty insurance in the U.S., according to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). This is the highest share of the insurers we surveyed in Michigan.

J.D. Power gave State Farm an above-average rating of 873 out of 1,000 for overall customer satisfaction in its 2024 Property Claims Satisfaction Study. The average satisfaction rating is 869.

ProsCons

  Average rate below state average

  High customer satisfaction rating

  Good discounts

  High complaint rating

Best complaint rate: Frankenmuth

Frankenmuth has the lowest complaint rate of the Michigan insurance companies we surveyed, at 0.18. This is well below the average NAIC Complaint Index of 1.0.

ProsCons

  Good complaint resolution

  Average home insurance rate higher than state average

  No online insurance quotes

Best for military members: USAA

USAA offers home insurance perks tailor-made for military members. This includes coverage of personal property damaged by an act of war and coverage of military uniforms with no deductible.

ProsCons

  Coverage especially for Armed Forces members

  Below-average home insurance rate

  Excellent customer satisfaction and complaint ratings

  Only available to active duty and retired military, as well as their families

  No assigned agents

The average cost of homeowners insurance in Michigan is $2,467 a year. This is 12% less than the national average of $2,801.

Home insurers use many different factors when calculating your quote, including:

  • Your ZIP code
  • Construction materials used to build your home
  • Age of home
  • Your claim history
  • Policy coverage limits and deductibles
  • Discounts

While home insurance policy offerings tend to be similar from company to company, they rarely cost the same. This is because home insurance companies weigh rate and risk factors differently. One company may see the age of your home as a higher risk than another company, for example.

To get the best home insurance coverage for your needs at the cheapest price, compare home insurance quotes from several companies.

The dwelling coverage limit you choose affects your home insurance quote. For example, there’s a $618 cost difference between a $350,000 and a $450,000 home insurance policy in Michigan.

Home insurance cost by dwelling coverage limit

Coverage amountAverage annual rate
$350,000$2,146
$400,000$2,467
$450,000$2,764

When choosing your dwelling coverage limit, make sure it equals the replacement value of your home in the event of a total loss. This is usually less than your home’s market value.

Ann Arbor has the lowest average home insurance rate of $1,747 in Michigan. Highland Park has the state’s highest average rate of $5,403 a year.

Home insurance rates by city

CityAverage annual rate
Acme$2,161
Addison$2,186
Adrian$1,993
Afton$2,051
Ahmeek$1,922
Alanson$1,900
Alba$2,006
Albion$2,296
Alden$1,931
Alger$2,063
Algonac$2,189
Allegan$2,090
Allen Park$2,765
Allendale$1,829
Allenton$2,245
Allouez$1,834
Alma$2,213
Almont$2,141
Alpena$1,933
Alpha$1,991
Alto$1,944
Amasa$1,960
Anchorville$2,207
Ann Arbor$1,747
Applegate$2,272
Argentine$2,237
Armada$2,309
Arnold$2,129
Ashley$2,106
Athens$2,207
Atlanta$1,954
Atlantic Mine$1,821
Attica$2,283
Au Gres$2,125
Au Sable$2,002
Au Train$1,934
Auburn$1,973
Auburn Hills$2,248
Augusta$2,036
Avoca$2,150
Azalia$2,105
Bad Axe$2,042
Bailey$2,075
Baldwin$1,992
Bancroft$2,157
Bangor$2,463
Bannister$2,119
Baraga$2,030
Barbeau$2,095
Barryton$2,140
Barton City$2,003
Bath$1,895
Battle Creek$2,146
Bay City$1,979
Bay Port$2,030
Bay Shore$2,104
Beaver Island$1,882
Beaverton$2,090
Bedford$2,464
Beecher$4,043
Beechwood$1,958
Belding$2,135
Bellaire$1,946
Belleville$2,915
Belmont$2,022
Bentley$2,096
Benton Harbor$2,415
Benton Heights$2,422
Bergland$1,986
Berkley$2,350
Berrien Center$2,498
Berrien Springs$2,353
Bessemer$1,959
Beulah$1,905
Beverly Hills$2,452
Big Bay$2,083
Big Rapids$2,019
Bingham Farms$2,483
Birch Run$2,471
Birmingham$2,290
Bitely$2,167
Black River$1,908
Blanchard$2,250
Blissfield$2,183
Bloomfield Hills$2,356
Boon$1,923
Boyne City$1,917
Boyne Falls$1,915
Bradley$2,541
Branch$2,021
Breckenridge$2,063
Breedsville$2,428
Brethren$1,936
Bridgeport$3,052
Bridgman$2,284
Brighton$2,027
Brimley$2,066
Britton$2,185
Brohman$2,114
Bronson$2,289
Brooklyn$2,146
Brown City$2,151
Brownlee Park$2,156
Bruce Crossing$2,067
Brutus$1,940
Buchanan$2,426
Buckley$1,853
Buena Vista$3,256
Burnips$2,460
Burr Oak$2,379
Burt$2,452
Burt Lake$2,140
Burton$2,875
Byron$2,252
Byron Center$1,799
Cadillac$1,964
Calumet$1,805
Canadian Lakes$1,990
Cannonsburg$2,393
Capac$2,356
Carleton$2,513
Carney$1,985
Caro$2,165
Carrollton$2,202
Carson City$1,904
Carsonville$2,203
Caseville$2,031
Caspian$1,983
Cass City$2,127
Cassopolis$2,596
Cedar$1,832
Cedar Lake$2,053
Cedar Springs$1,999
Cedarville$1,947
Cement City$2,243
Center Line$2,519
Central Lake$1,945
Centreville$2,255
Ceresco$2,248
Champion$2,015
Channing$1,927
Charlevoix$1,880
Charlotte$2,145
Chatham$1,998
Cheboygan$1,853
Chelsea$1,882
Chesaning$2,357
Chippewa Lake$2,033
Clare$2,282
Clarklake$2,118
Clarkston$2,222
Clarksville$2,025
Clawson$2,186
Clayton$2,327
Clifford$2,213
Climax$2,148
Clinton$2,033
Clio$2,520
Cloverdale$2,154
Coldwater$2,288
Coleman$2,227
Coloma$2,507
Colon$2,384
Columbiaville$2,312
Comins$2,126
Comstock Northwest$2,145
Comstock Park$1,944
Conklin$2,011
Constantine$2,353
Cooks$1,932
Coopersville$1,931
Copemish$2,128
Copper City$1,941
Copper Harbor$1,909
Coral$2,181
Cornell$1,947
Corunna$2,104
Covington$2,055
Cross Village$1,862
Croswell$2,270
Crystal Falls$1,948
Curran$1,957
Curtis$2,154
Custer$2,028
Cutlerville$1,780
Daggett$2,014
Dansville$2,050
Davisburg$2,210
Davison$2,241
De Tour Village$2,098
Dearborn$3,304
Dearborn Heights$3,190
Decatur$2,487
Decker$2,246
Deckerville$2,108
Deerfield$2,093
Deerton$1,955
Deford$2,148
Delton$2,064
Detroit$5,038
Detroit Beach$2,306
DeWitt$2,047
Dexter$1,982
Dimondale$1,939
Dodgeville$1,853
Dollar Bay$1,879
Douglas$1,982
Dowagiac$2,399
Dowling$2,084
Drayton Plains$2,546
Drummond Island$2,186
Dundee$2,349
Durand$2,419
East Grand Rapids$1,997
East Jordan$1,894
East Lansing$1,979
East Leroy$2,198
East Tawas$1,989
Eastlake$2,103
Eastpointe$2,721
Eastport$2,025
Eastwood$2,003
Eaton Rapids$2,092
Eau Claire$2,373
Eben Junction$2,017
Eckerman$2,138
Ecorse$4,804
Edgemont Park$1,911
Edmore$2,150
Edwardsburg$2,597
Elberta$2,057
Elk Rapids$1,927
Elkton$2,010
Ellsworth$1,954
Elm Hall$2,152
Elmira$2,134
Elsie$2,005
Elwell$2,110
Engadine$2,198
Escanaba$1,894
Essexville$2,029
Evart$2,141
Ewen$2,063
Fair Haven$2,179
Fair Plain$2,433
Fairgrove$1,993
Fairview$2,028
Falmouth$2,042
Farmington$2,358
Farmington Hills$2,436
Farwell$2,242
Felch$1,920
Fennville$1,993
Fenton$2,130
Fenwick$2,064
Ferndale$2,574
Ferrysburg$2,039
Fife Lake$2,003
Filer City$1,974
Filion$2,032
Flat Rock$2,581
Flint$3,826
Flushing$2,521
Forest Hills$1,927
Forestville$2,082
Foster City$1,911
Fostoria$2,324
Fountain$2,011
Fowler$1,915
Fowlerville$2,155
Frankenmuth$2,300
Frankfort$1,942
Franklin$2,498
Fraser$2,325
Freeland$2,111
Freeport$1,958
Fremont$2,137
Frontier$2,344
Fruitport$2,050
Fulton$2,166
Gaastra$1,959
Gagetown$2,116
Galesburg$2,101
Galien$2,314
Garden$1,964
Garden City$2,493
Gaylord$1,980
Genesee$2,593
Germfask$1,943
Gibraltar$2,725
Gladstone$1,916
Gladwin$2,110
Glenn$2,119
Glennie$2,026
Gobles$2,327
Goetzville$2,113
Good Hart$1,899
Goodells$2,128
Goodrich$2,246
Gould City$2,174
Gowen$2,079
Grand Beach$2,395
Grand Blanc$2,298
Grand Haven$1,868
Grand Junction$2,268
Grand Ledge$1,984
Grand Marais$2,070
Grand Rapids$1,972
Grandville$1,789
Grass Lake$2,029
Grawn$1,909
Grayling$1,975
Greenville$2,024
Gregory$2,046
Greilickville$1,762
Grosse Pointe$2,749
Grosse Pointe Farms$2,719
Grosse Pointe Park$2,799
Grosse Pointe Woods$2,683
Gulliver$2,132
Gwinn$2,143
Hagar Shores$3,327
Hale$2,074
Hamilton$2,033
Hamtramck$5,307
Hancock$1,782
Hanover$2,115
Harbert$2,327
Harbor Beach$1,974
Harbor Springs$1,953
Harper Woods$3,528
Harrietta$2,001
Harrison$2,218
Harsens Island$2,294
Hart$2,078
Hartford$2,424
Haslett$1,948
Hastings$2,074
Hawks$1,881
Hazel Park$2,962
Hemlock$2,108
Henderson$2,018
Hermansville$1,962
Herron$2,124
Hesperia$2,100
Hessel$2,363
Hickory Corners$2,087
Higgins Lake$2,090
Highland Park$5,403
Hillsdale$2,175
Holland$1,932
Holly$2,154
Holt$1,967
Homer$2,371
Honor$1,957
Horton$2,055
Houghton$1,811
Houghton Lake$2,078
Houghton Lake Heights$2,090
Howard City$2,134
Howell$2,138
Hubbard Lake$1,943
Hubbardston$2,048
Hubbell$1,922
Hudson$2,215
Hudsonville$1,891
Hulbert$2,127
Huntington Woods$2,432
Idlewild$2,001
Imlay City$2,332
Indian River$1,987
Ingalls$2,038
Inkster$3,238
Interlochen$1,962
Ionia$2,147
Iron Mountain$1,893
Iron River$1,886
Irons$1,993
Ironwood$2,049
Ishpeming$1,937
Ithaca$2,123
Jackson$2,150
Jasper$2,160
Jeddo$2,146
Jenison$1,809
Jerome$2,265
Johannesburg$1,960
Jones$2,461
Jonesville$2,257
K. I. Sawyer$2,131
Kalamazoo$2,057
Kaleva$2,104
Kalkaska$1,972
Kearsarge$2,543
Keego Harbor$2,449
Kendall$3,032
Kent City$2,054
Kentwood$2,002
Kewadin$1,839
Kincheloe$2,076
Kinde$2,021
Kingsford$1,882
Kingsley$1,931
L'Anse$1,905
Lachine$2,002
Lacota$2,501
Laingsburg$1,992
Lake$2,202
Lake Angelus$2,275
Lake Ann$1,912
Lake City$2,016
Lake Fenton$2,107
Lake George$2,093
Lake Isabella$2,211
Lake Leelanau$1,785
Lake Linden$1,800
Lake Michigan Beach$2,516
Lake Odessa$2,168
Lake Orion$2,348
Lakeland$2,125
Lakes of the North$1,960
Lakeside$2,349
Lakeview$2,177
Lakeville$2,188
Lakewood Club$2,202
Lambertville$2,119
Lamont$2,035
Lansing$1,944
Lapeer$2,113
Lathrup Village$2,894
Laurium$1,802
Lawrence$2,511
Lawton$2,365
Lennon$2,333
Leonard$2,283
Leroy$2,005
Leslie$1,974
Level Park-Oak Park$2,177
Levering$1,939
Lewiston$2,018
Lexington$2,163
Limestone$1,998
Lincoln$1,951
Lincoln Park$2,997
Linden$2,239
Linwood$1,978
Litchfield$2,326
Little Lake$2,052
Livonia$2,375
Long Lake$2,077
Loomis$2,255
Loretto$1,934
Lowell$1,905
Ludington$1,970
Luna Pier$2,209
Lupton$2,038
Luther$1,988
Luzerne$2,035
Macatawa$1,941
Mackinac Island$1,991
Mackinaw City$1,873
Madison Heights$2,464
Mancelona$1,941
Manchester$1,929
Manistee$1,970
Manistee Lake$2,047
Manistique$2,001
Manitou Beach-Devils Lake$2,240
Manton$1,875
Maple City$1,784
Maple Rapids$1,943
Marcellus$2,409
Marine City$2,120
Marlette$2,221
Marne$1,966
Marquette$1,832
Marshall$2,395
Marysville$2,263
Mason$1,998
Mass City$2,088
Mattawan$2,294
Maybee$2,285
Mayville$2,245
McBain$2,079
McBride$2,200
Mcbrides$2,200
McMillan$2,128
Mears$2,217
Mecosta$2,118
Melvin$2,117
Melvindale$3,103
Memphis$2,074
Mendon$2,404
Menominee$2,064
Merrill$2,098
Merritt$2,080
Mesick$1,857
Metamora$2,052
Michigamme$2,018
Michigan Center$2,195
Middleton$2,027
Middletown$2,110
Middleville$1,953
Midland$1,942
Mikado$1,979
Milan$2,056
Milford$2,208
Millersburg$1,863
Millington$2,330
Minden City$2,090
Mio$2,055
Mohawk$1,878
Moline$2,032
Monroe$2,304
Montague$2,208
Montgomery$2,357
Montrose$2,594
Moran$1,960
Morenci$2,325
Morley$2,136
Morrice$2,119
Mosherville$2,245
Mount Clemens$2,187
Mount Morris$3,007
Mount Pleasant$2,111
Muir$2,159
Mullett Lake$1,897
Mulliken$2,053
Munger$2,014
Munising$2,017
Munith$2,084
Muskegon$2,280
Muskegon Heights$2,352
Nadeau$1,839
Napoleon$2,106
Nashville$2,134
National City$2,127
National Mine$2,261
Naubinway$2,152
Nazareth$2,490
Negaunee$1,922
New Baltimore$2,172
New Boston$2,697
New Buffalo$2,376
New Era$2,064
New Haven$2,177
New Hudson$2,229
New Lothrop$2,184
New Troy$2,334
Newaygo$2,119
Newberry$2,233
Newport$2,398
Niles$2,452
Nisula$1,973
North Adams$2,116
North Branch$2,328
North Muskegon$2,307
North Street$2,095
Northport$1,807
Northview$1,962
Northville$2,140
Norton Shores$2,264
Norvell$2,141
Norway$1,901
Novi$2,201
Nunica$2,074
Oak Hill$2,001
Oak Park$3,124
Oakley$2,201
Oden$1,966
Okemos$1,877
Old Mission$1,792
Olivet$2,058
Omena$1,848
Omer$2,191
Onaway$1,823
Onsted$2,111
Ontonagon$1,921
Orchard Lake Village$2,435
Ortonville$2,173
Oscoda$2,002
Osseo$2,360
Ossineke$2,077
Otisville$2,323
Otsego$2,155
Ottawa Lake$2,080
Otter Lake$2,292
Ovid$1,944
Owendale$2,017
Owosso$2,067
Oxford$2,238
Painesdale$1,929
Palmer$2,063
Palms$2,111
Palo$2,133
Paradise$1,981
Parchment$2,107
Paris$2,177
Paw Paw$2,348
Paw Paw Lake$2,517
Pearl Beach$2,217
Peck$2,216
Pelkie$1,940
Pellston$1,836
Pentwater$2,054
Perkins$2,031
Perrinton$2,035
Perronville$2,000
Perry$2,002
Petersburg$2,093
Petoskey$1,871
Pewamo$1,967
Pigeon$2,046
Pinckney$2,152
Plainwell$2,150
Pleasant Lake$2,063
Pleasant Ridge$2,410
Plymouth$2,014
Pointe Aux Pins$1,871
Pompeii$2,060
Pontiac$3,082
Port Hope$2,022
Port Huron$2,095
Port Sanilac$2,239
Portage$1,958
Portland$2,057
Potterville$2,165
Powers$1,883
Prescott$2,144
Presque Isle Harbor$1,886
Prudenville$2,061
Pullman$2,064
Quinnesec$1,924
Ralph$1,861
Ramsay$1,939
Rapid City$2,022
Rapid River$1,943
Ravenna$1,986
Reed City$2,088
Reese$2,083
Remus$2,162
Rhodes$2,059
Richmond$2,118
Richville$2,463
Riga$2,135
River Rouge$3,986
Riverdale$2,258
Riverview$3,176
Rives Junction$2,121
Robin Glen-Indiantown$3,262
Rochester$2,179
Rochester Hills$2,182
Rock$1,979
Rockford$1,912
Rockland$1,879
Rockwood$2,712
Rodney$2,055
Rogers City$1,795
Romeo$2,112
Romulus$3,068
Roosevelt Park$2,196
Roscommon$1,997
Rose City$2,042
Rosebush$2,019
Roseville$2,613
Rothbury$2,115
Royal Oak$2,245
Rumely$2,016
Ruth$1,994
Saginaw$2,813
Salem$2,032
Saline$1,837
Samaria$2,032
Sand Creek$2,117
Sand Lake$2,105
Sandusky$2,190
Sanford$2,286
Saranac$2,068
Sault Ste. Marie$2,030
Sawyer$2,311
Schoolcraft$2,142
Scotts$2,101
Scottville$1,898
Sears$2,075
Sebewaing$1,994
Seney$2,016
Shaftsburg$2,016
Shelby$2,045
Shelbyville$2,036
Shepherd$2,331
Sheridan$2,042
Shingleton$1,927
Shoreham$2,194
Sidnaw$2,014
Silverwood$2,226
Six Lakes$2,196
Skanee$2,004
Smiths Creek$2,183
Smyrna$2,755
Snover$2,209
Somerset Center$2,234
South Boardman$1,998
South Branch$2,025
South Gull Lake$2,022
South Haven$2,455
South Lyon$2,177
South Monroe$2,307
South Range$1,893
South Rockwood$2,291
Southfield$3,015
Southgate$2,947
Spalding$2,031
Sparta$2,050
Spring Arbor$2,205
Spring Lake$2,041
Springfield$2,158
Springport$2,107
Spruce$1,949
St. Charles$2,277
St. Clair$2,104
St. Clair Shores$2,508
St. Helen$2,123
St. Ignace$1,943
St. Johns$1,910
St. Joseph$2,155
St. Louis$2,095
Standish$2,073
Stanton$2,147
Stanwood$2,010
Stephenson$2,023
Sterling$2,206
Sterling Heights$2,451
Stevensville$2,194
Stockbridge$2,165
Sturgis$2,311
Sumner$2,182
Swartz Creek$2,350
Sylvan Beach$2,593
Sylvan Lake$2,377
Tawas City$2,063
Taylor$2,875
Tecumseh$2,084
Tekonsha$2,332
Temperance$2,035
Thompsonville$1,951
Three Oaks$2,329
Three Rivers$2,243
Tipton$2,049
Toivola$1,858
Topinabee$1,976
Tower$1,893
Traverse City$1,775
Trenary$1,933
Trenton$2,423
Trout Creek$2,038
Trout Lake$2,089
Trowbridge Park$1,838
Troy$2,191
Trufant$2,118
Tustin$2,033
Twin Lake$2,213
Twining$2,181
Ubly$2,068
Union$2,529
Union City$2,445
Union Lake$2,612
Union Pier$2,358
Unionville$2,077
University Center$2,305
Utica$2,266
Vandalia$2,522
Vanderbilt$1,977
Vandercook Lake$2,200
Vassar$2,178
Vermontville$2,108
Vernon$2,252
Vestaburg$2,142
Vicksburg$2,166
Vulcan$1,927
Wacousta$2,032
Wakefield$2,000
Waldron$2,426
Walhalla$2,134
Walker$1,957
Walkerville$2,052
Wallace$1,984
Walled Lake$2,467
Walloon Lake$1,930
Warren$3,280
Waters$1,945
Watervliet$2,534
Watton$2,039
Waverly$1,994
Wayland$2,045
Wayne$2,997
Webberville$1,944
Weidman$2,224
Wells$1,916
Wellston$1,984
West Branch$2,143
West Ishpeming$1,957
West Monroe$2,305
West Olive$1,917
Westland$2,852
Weston$2,161
Westphalia$1,964
Westwood$2,060
Wetmore$1,997
White Cloud$2,157
White Pine$2,028
Whitehall$2,125
Whitmore Lake$2,041
Whittaker$2,130
Whittemore$2,005
Williamsburg$1,910
Williamston$1,936
Willis$2,097
Wilson$2,065
Winn$2,087
Wixom$2,250
Wolf Lake$2,326
Wolverine$2,066
Wolverine Lake$2,465
Woodhaven$2,412
Woodland Beach$2,306
Wyandotte$3,158
Wyoming$1,952
Yale$2,196
Ypsilanti$2,210
Zeeland$1,858

Methodology

The rates shown in this article are based on non-binding quotes collected from Quadrant Information Services. Your rates may vary. Average rates were compiled from rates in Michigan. The following coverages and deductible were used unless otherwise noted:

  • $400,000 dwelling coverage
  • $40,000 other structures
  • $200,000 personal property
  • $80,000 loss of use coverage
  • $100,000 liability
  • $5,000 medical payments
  • $1,000 deductible

*USAA is only available to active duty and veteran military members and their families.