How to Compare Home Insurance Quotes
How Does LendingTree Get Paid?
LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

How Does LendingTree Get Paid?

LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

Best Homeowners Insurance in Ohio

Published on:
Content was accurate at the time of publication.

Erie is the best and cheapest homeowners insurance company in Ohio. Its rates average $104 a month and the company has higher customer service ratings than most other companies.

American Family, Cincinnati and State Farm are also good companies to contact for homeowners insurance quotes in Ohio.

Find the Cheapest Home Insurance Quotes in Ohio

Cheapest insurance companies in Ohio

$1,242/year
Best overall insurer in Ohio: Erie
Erie Insurance logo
$1,579/year
Best for discounts: American Family
American Family logo
$1,871/year
Biggest company in Ohio: State Farm
State Farm logo
+
More Options

Erie offers the cheapest homeowners insurance quotes in Ohio, averaging $1,242 a year ($104 a month) for a typical home. That’s 44% less than the state average of $1,553 a year.

The next-cheapest home insurance quotes are available from USAA ($1,553 a year) and American Family ($1,579 a year). Note that USAA is only available to current and former military members and their families.

CompanyAnnual rateLendingTree score
erie logoErie$1,242
4 stars
usaa logoUSAA*$1,553
4 stars
american family logoAmerican Family$1,579
4 stars
cincinnati financial logoCincinnati$1,633 Not rated
state farm logoState Farm$1,871
4 stars
westfield logoWestfield$2,047 Not rated
grange logoGrange$2,277 Not rated
allstate logoAllstate$2,285
4 stars
nationwide logoNationwide$2,310
3.5 stars
Farmers logoFarmers$5,276
3.5 stars

Find the Cheapest Home Insurance Quotes in Ohio

Erie, American Family and State Farm are the best large homeowners insurance companies in Ohio.

Meanwhile, Cincinnati is our pick for the best small company, and USAA is best for military families.

Ohio’s best homeowners insurance companies

CompanyAnnual rateSatisfaction scoreComplaint rating
Best overall: Erie$1,242 856 (Excellent)0.4 (Excellent)
Best discounts: American Family$1,579 813 (Average)0.4 (Excellent)
Most popular: State Farm$1,871 829 (Good)0.9 (Average)
Best small company: Cincinnati$1,633 Not rated0.1 (Excellent)
Best for military families: USAA*$1,553 881 (Excellent)0.4 (Excellent)

Satisfaction scores are based on J.D. Power’s 2023 U.S. Home Insurance Study. The segment average for home insurers is 819, and higher scores are better.

Complaint ratings track confirmed complaints (that lead to a finding of fault) reported to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. A 2.0 complaint rating means twice as many complaints as expected for the company’s size, while a 0.5 rating means half as many.

Best overall homeowners insurance company in Ohio: Erie

erie logo
Erie backs its low home insurance rates with strong customer service ratings and valuable policy features for Ohio homeowners.

Pros

 Cheapest average homeowners insurance rate in Ohio
 Higher customer satisfaction than most Ohio home insurers
 Guaranteed replacement cost coverage at no charge (even if the cost of rebuilding exceeds your policy’s limit)

Cons

 No instant quotes online — instead, Erie’s website refers you to local agents

Best home insurance discounts in Ohio: American Family

american family logo
American Family’s rate is 28% less than the state average for home insurance. It also has an excellent complaint rating and offers unique additional ways to save.

Pros

 Discount available for homes built less than 15 years ago
 Discount available for replacing old plumbing, electrical or heating systems
 Discount available if your parents are American Family customers and you’re under 30

Cons

 American Family’s satisfaction score is just average, although its complaint rating is excellent

Ohio’s most popular home insurance company: State Farm

state farm logo
State Farm is not the cheapest home insurance company in Ohio, but its 21% market share makes it the largest, or most popular. The next-largest company, Allstate, only has 11% market share.

Pros

 Home insurance rates are 15% below the state average
 Generous discounts available for bundling home and auto policies
 Quotes available online
 Agents available to provide personalized service

Cons

 State Farm’s complaint rating is just average, although it has a high satisfaction score

Ohio’s best small insurance company: Cincinnati

cincinnati financial logo
With just under 4% market share, Cincinnati is Ohio’s ninth-largest home insurer. However, its low rates and high customer service standards allow it to give larger companies a run for their money.

Pros

 Homeowners insurance rates are 26% lower than the state average
 Best complaint rating among the companies in our analysis
 Coverage for both standard and high-value homes

Cons

 Online insurance quotes not available.
 Website provides only minimal details about coverage choices.

Best for Ohio’s military families in Ohio: USAA

usaa logo
USAA’s rates are 30% lower than the state average, and also rewards its customers with valuable perks.

Pros

 Replacement cost coverage is standard for your belongings
 Discounts available for home security devices and services
 Coverage for service equipment and uniforms included for active-duty military

Cons

 You end up speaking with a different representative each time you call in for assistance
 Only available to military service members and their families

The average cost of homeowners insurance in Ohio is $2,207 a year, or $184 a month.

The actual price you pay depends on factors such as:

  • The amount of coverage you need
  • Your location
  • Your credit and insurance history
  • Any discounts you may be eligible to receive

Each insurance company weighs these factors differently, and one company may offer you a much lower rate than the others do, so you should compare quotes from multiple companies when you shop.

Home insurance rates by coverage amounts

In Ohio, a policy that insures your home, or dwelling, for $450,000 costs 23% more than a $350,000 policy.

Dwelling coverageAnnual cost
$350,000 $1,973
$400,000 $2,207
$450,000 $2,418

For a new mortgage, lenders typically require you to insure your home at its replacement value — basically, the cost of rebuilding your home to its current specifications and quality grade.

You can choose a lower amount of dwelling coverage if you have a low loan balance or if you own your home outright. But this may leave you without enough money to rebuild after a disaster.

Most insurance companies use a computer program to calculate your home’s replacement value. Make sure the information it has about your home is accurate.

In Ohio’s largest cities, home insurance rates range from $1,878 a year in Cuyahoga Falls to $2,609 a year in Dayton.

The average cost of home insurance in Columbus is $2,165 a year, which is 2% less than the state average.

CityAnnual rate
Aberdeen$2,699
Ada$2,383
Adamsville$2,199
Addyston$2,340
Adelphi$2,527
Adena$2,028
Akron$2,033
Albany$2,485
Alexandria$2,137
Alger$2,370
Alledonia$2,103
Alliance$2,034
Alpha$2,424
Alvada$2,375
Alvordton$2,138
Amanda$2,242
Amberley$2,217
Amelia$2,361
Amesville$2,389
Amherst$2,005
Amlin$2,039
Amsterdam$2,079
Andersonville$2,690
Andover$2,111
Anna$2,362
Ansonia$2,346
Antwerp$2,300
Apple Creek$1,938
Apple Valley$2,050
Aquilla$1,853
Arcadia$2,474
Arcanum$2,237
Archbold$2,349
Arlington$2,357
Arlington Heights$2,205
Ashland$2,086
Ashley$2,131
Ashtabula$1,989
Ashville$2,248
Athens$2,339
Attica$2,426
Atwater$2,001
Aurora$1,926
Austinburg$2,038
Austintown$2,038
Ava$2,148
Avon$1,837
Avon Lake$1,918
Bainbridge$2,141
Bakersville$2,156
Ballville$2,167
Baltic$2,009
Baltimore$2,156
Bannock$2,012
Barberton$2,019
Barnesville$2,136
Bartlett$2,254
Barton$2,057
Bascom$2,285
Batavia$2,220
Bay View$2,143
Bay Village$2,041
Beach City$1,953
Beachwood$2,004
Beallsville$2,075
Beaver$3,073
Beavercreek$2,374
Beaverdam$2,438
Beckett Ridge$2,262
Bedford$2,069
Bedford Heights$2,071
Beechwood Trails$2,117
Bellaire$1,985
Bellbrook$2,514
Belle Center$2,274
Belle Valley$2,175
Bellefontaine$2,294
Bellevue$2,092
Bellville$2,068
Belmont$1,962
Belmore$2,526
Beloit$2,071
Belpre$2,197
Bentleyville$1,946
Benton Ridge$2,445
Bentonville$2,719
Berea$1,959
Bergholz$2,027
Berkey$2,263
Berlin Center$2,052
Berlin Heights$2,097
Bethel$2,393
Bethesda$2,010
Bettsville$2,163
Beverly$2,248
Bexley$2,198
Bidwell$2,572
Big Prairie$2,067
Birmingham$2,099
Blacklick$2,097
Blacklick Estates$2,138
Bladensburg$2,151
Blaine$2,009
Blakeslee$2,201
Blanchester$2,326
Blissfield$2,163
Bloomdale$2,386
Bloomingburg$2,379
Bloomingdale$2,065
Bloomville$2,335
Blue Ash$2,233
Blue Creek$2,909
Blue Rock$2,188
Bluffton$2,364
Boardman$2,004
Bolindale$2,112
Bolivar$2,034
Boston Heights$1,950
Botkins$2,335
Bourneville$2,590
Bowerston$1,970
Bowersville$2,499
Bowling Green$2,241
Bradford$2,201
Bradner$2,376
Brady Lake$2,009
Bratenahl$2,332
Brecksville$1,997
Bremen$2,317
Brewster$1,961
Brice$2,060
Bridgeport$2,013
Bridgetown$2,276
Brilliant$2,080
Brimfield$1,935
Brinkhaven$2,103
Bristolville$2,083
Broadview Heights$1,947
Broadway$2,103
Brook Park$2,005
Brookfield$1,979
Brookfield Center$1,983
Brooklyn$2,032
Brooklyn Heights$1,974
Brookpark$2,012
Brookside$2,012
Brookville$2,462
Brownsville$2,001
Brunswick$1,890
Bryan$2,259
Buchtel$2,273
Buckeye Lake$2,089
Buckland$2,375
Bucyrus$2,144
Burbank$1,920
Burghill$2,039
Burgoon$2,328
Burkettsville$2,292
Burlington$2,669
Burton$1,839
Butler$2,032
Byesville$2,140
Cable$2,384
Cadiz$2,101
Cairo$2,444
Calcutta$2,025
Caldwell$2,165
Caledonia$2,196
Cambridge$2,108
Camden$2,704
Cameron$2,164
Camp Dennison$2,179
Campbell$1,993
Canal Fulton$1,887
Canal Winchester$2,132
Candlewood Lake$2,233
Canfield$1,990
Canton$2,018
Carbon Hill$2,351
Carbondale$2,272
Cardington$2,221
Carey$2,237
Carlisle$2,581
Carroll$2,198
Carrollton$2,056
Casstown$2,285
Castalia$2,186
Catawba$2,220
Cecil$2,367
Cedarville$2,439
Celina$2,300
Centerburg$2,170
Centerville$2,401
Chagrin Falls$1,882
Champion Heights$2,048
Chandlersville$2,193
Chardon$1,848
Charm$1,985
Chauncey$2,419
Cherry Fork$2,845
Cherry Grove$2,152
Chesapeake$2,626
Cheshire$2,464
Chesterhill$2,232
Chesterland$1,929
Chesterville$2,241
Cheviot$2,241
Chickasaw$2,390
Chillicothe$2,663
Chilo$2,370
Chippewa Lake$1,937
Chippewa Park$2,302
Choctaw Lake$2,271
Christiansburg$2,242
Churchill$2,032
Cincinnati$2,230
Cinnamon Lake$2,057
Circleville$2,374
Clarington$2,242
Clarksburg$2,739
Clarksville$2,486
Clay Center$2,345
Clayton$2,390
Cleveland$2,211
Cleveland Heights$2,172
Cleves$2,328
Clifton$2,381
Clinton$1,968
Cloverdale$2,413
Clyde$2,291
Coal Grove$2,592
Coal Run$2,147
Coalton$2,570
Coldstream$2,156
Coldwater$2,340
College Corner$2,547
Collins$2,204
Collinsville$2,545
Colton$2,451
Columbia Station$1,932
Columbiana$1,986
Columbus$2,165
Columbus Grove$2,431
Commercial Point$2,259
Conesville$2,143
Conneaut$1,978
Conover$2,163
Continental$2,458
Convoy$2,568
Coolville$2,427
Corning$2,424
Cortland$2,071
Coshocton$2,043
Covedale$2,212
Covington$2,160
Craig Beach$2,058
Creola$2,523
Crestline$2,169
Creston$1,938
Cridersville$2,316
Crooksville$2,410
Croton$2,163
Crown City$2,753
Crystal Lakes$2,196
Cuba$2,455
Cumberland$2,175
Curtice$2,475
Custar$2,274
Cutler$2,270
Cuyahoga Falls$1,878
Cuyahoga Heights$2,075
Cygnet$2,420
Cynthiana$2,600
Dalton$2,042
Danville$2,082
Darbydale$2,086
Day Heights$2,240
Dayton$2,609
De Graff$2,285
Deer Park$2,237
Deerfield$1,941
Deersville$2,115
Defiance$2,314
Delaware$2,039
Delhi Hills$2,206
Dellroy$2,195
Delphos$2,423
Delshire$2,210
Delta$2,446
Dennison$2,037
Dent$2,303
Derby$2,208
Derwent$2,163
Deshler$2,354
Devola$2,189
Dexter City$2,171
Diamond$1,981
Dillonvale$2,190
Dola$2,310
Donnelsville$2,254
Dorset$2,104
Dover$2,129
Doylestown$1,923
Dresden$2,221
Drexel$2,767
Dry Ridge$2,247
Dry Run$2,181
Dublin$1,955
Dunbridge$2,364
Duncan Falls$2,088
Dundee$2,052
Dunkirk$2,344
Dunlap$2,260
Dupont$2,523
East Canton$1,944
East Claridon$1,890
East Cleveland$2,313
East Fultonham$2,151
East Liberty$2,203
East Liverpool$2,019
East Palestine$2,002
East Rochester$1,975
East Sparta$2,035
East Springfield$2,081
Eastlake$1,893
Eaton$2,460
Eaton Estates$2,012
Edgerton$2,283
Edgewood$1,999
Edison$2,219
Edon$2,258
Eldorado$2,504
Elgin$2,565
Elida$2,377
Elkton$2,066
Elmore$2,337
Elmwood Place$2,228
Elyria$2,032
Empire$2,049
Englewood$2,431
Enon$2,244
Euclid$2,171
Evansport$2,260
Evendale$2,189
Fairborn$2,198
Fairfax$2,154
Fairfield$2,427
Fairfield Beach$2,182
Fairlawn$1,894
Fairpoint$2,008
Fairport Harbor$1,843
Fairview$2,183
Fairview Park$2,027
Farmdale$2,158
Farmersville$2,499
Fayette$2,358
Fayetteville$2,536
Feesburg$2,597
Felicity$2,457
Findlay$2,337
Finneytown$2,291
Five Points$2,371
Flat Rock$2,280
Fleming$2,308
Fletcher$2,149
Flushing$2,039
Forest$2,347
Forest Park$2,377
Forestville$2,150
Fort Jennings$2,365
Fort Loramie$2,291
Fort Recovery$2,427
Fort Shawnee$2,375
Fostoria$2,267
Four Bridges$2,419
Fowler$2,151
Frankfort$2,682
Franklin$2,575
Franklin Furnace$2,889
Frazeysburg$2,247
Fredericksburg$2,095
Fredericktown$2,126
Freeport$2,247
Fremont$2,160
Fresno$2,119
Friendship$2,830
Fruit Hill$2,119
Fulton$2,181
Fultonham$2,209
Gahanna$2,057
Galena$2,009
Galion$2,177
Gallipolis$2,635
Galloway$2,078
Gambier$2,161
Garfield Heights$2,071
Garrettsville$1,959
Gates Mills$1,987
Geneva$2,012
Geneva-on-the-Lake$2,013
Genoa$2,287
Georgetown$2,666
Germantown$2,492
Gettysburg$2,241
Gibsonburg$2,316
Girard$2,013
Glandorf$2,441
Glencoe$2,066
Glendale$2,210
Glenford$2,222
Glenmont$2,046
Glenmoor$2,029
Glenwillow$1,959
Gloria Glens Park$1,932
Glouster$2,376
Gnadenhutten$2,103
Golf Manor$2,194
Gomer$2,523
Goshen$2,414
Grafton$2,010
Grand Rapids$2,257
Grand River$1,914
Grandview$2,339
Grandview Heights$2,047
Granville$2,047
Granville South$2,047
Gratiot$2,122
Graysville$2,249
Graytown$2,307
Green$1,924
Green Meadows$2,240
Green Springs$2,274
Greenfield$2,747
Greenford$2,048
Greenhills$2,324
Greentown$1,865
Greenville$2,359
Greenwich$2,197
Grelton$2,398
Groesbeck$2,302
Grove City$2,077
Groveport$2,089
Grover Hill$2,432
Guysville$2,454
Gypsum$2,307
Hallsville$2,495
Hamden$2,577
Hamersville$2,667
Hamilton$2,465
Hamler$2,479
Hammondsville$2,034
Hannibal$2,219
Hanover$2,063
Hanoverton$2,153
Harbor Hills$2,187
Harbor View$2,271
Harpster$2,195
Harrisburg$2,066
Harrison$2,231
Harrod$2,373
Hartville$2,003
Harveysburg$2,212
Haskins$2,257
Haverhill$2,700
Haviland$2,371
Haydenville$2,339
Hayesville$2,086
Heath$2,034
Hebron$2,097
Helena$2,325
Hicksville$2,373
Higginsport$2,350
Highland Heights$2,110
Highland Hills$2,018
Highpoint$2,159
Hilliard$1,968
Hillsboro$2,599
Hinckley$1,940
Hiram$1,929
Hockingport$2,299
Holgate$2,462
Holiday Valley$2,188
Holland$2,267
Hollansburg$2,318
Holloway$2,037
Holmesville$2,078
Homerville$2,011
Homeworth$2,037
Hooven$2,408
Hopedale$2,105
Hopewell$2,282
Houston$2,358
Howard$2,063
Howland Center$2,107
Hoytville$2,353
Hubbard$2,091
Huber Heights$2,389
Huber Ridge$2,006
Hudson$1,951
Hunter$2,580
Hunting Valley$1,934
Huntsburg$1,864
Huntsville$2,312
Huron$2,065
Iberia$2,268
Independence$1,965
Irondale$2,083
Ironton$2,590
Irwin$2,109
Isle St. George$2,373
Jackson$2,885
Jackson Center$2,324
Jacksontown$2,106
Jacksonville$2,376
Jacobsburg$2,035
Jamestown$2,402
Jefferson$2,074
Jeffersonville$2,435
Jenera$2,378
Jeromesville$2,099
Jerry City$2,330
Jerusalem$2,148
Jewell$2,279
Jewett$2,160
Johnstown$2,153
Junction City$2,321
Kalida$2,468
Kansas$2,237
Keene$2,179
Kelleys Island$2,126
Kensington$2,074
Kent$1,935
Kenton$2,313
Kenwood$2,228
Kerr$2,607
Kettering$2,389
Kettlersville$2,343
Kidron$2,039
Kilbourne$2,080
Killbuck$2,015
Kimbolton$2,108
Kings Mills$2,372
Kingston$2,539
Kingsville$2,095
Kinsman$2,040
Kinsman Center$2,045
Kipling$2,120
Kipton$2,073
Kirby$2,251
Kirkersville$2,119
Kirtland$1,865
Kirtland Hills$1,819
Kitts Hill$2,578
Kunkle$2,218
La Croft$2,023
La Rue$2,270
Lacarne$2,301
Lafferty$2,033
LaGrange$2,059
Laings$2,186
Lake Darby$2,053
Lake Lakengren$2,469
Lake Lorelei$2,532
Lake Milton$2,049
Lake Mohawk$2,022
Lake Waynoka$2,693
Lakemore$1,960
Lakeside$2,461
Lakeside Marblehead$2,463
Lakeview$2,296
Lakeville$2,027
Lakewood$2,115
Lancaster$2,304
Landen$2,337
Langsville$2,627
Lansing$2,025
Latham$2,788
Laura$2,258
Laurelville$2,488
Leavittsburg$1,988
Lebanon$2,484
Leesburg$2,676
Leesville$2,083
Leetonia$1,977
Leipsic$2,424
Lemoyne$2,283
Lewis Center$1,993
Lewisburg$2,479
Lewistown$2,271
Lewisville$2,184
Lexington$2,111
Liberty Center$2,387
Lima$2,361
Limaville$2,069
Lincoln Heights$2,211
Lincoln Village$2,097
Lindsey$2,346
Lisbon$2,064
Litchfield$1,990
Lithopolis$2,216
Little Hocking$2,158
Lockbourne$2,108
Lockland$2,208
Lodi$2,043
Logan$2,330
London$2,267
Londonderry$2,722
Long Bottom$2,531
Lorain$2,068
Lordstown$2,085
Lore City$2,186
Loudonville$2,101
Louisville$2,019
Loveland$2,285
Loveland Park$2,355
Lowell$2,161
Lowellville$2,017
Lower Salem$2,134
Lucas$2,053
Lucasville$3,042
Luckey$2,216
Ludlow Falls$2,101
Lynchburg$2,648
Lyndhurst$2,035
Lynx$2,874
Lyons$2,531
Macedonia$1,911
Mack$2,281
Macksburg$2,191
Madeira$2,138
Madison$1,821
Magnetic Springs$2,098
Magnolia$2,053
Maineville$2,339
Malinta$2,469
Malta$2,227
Malvern$2,012
Manchester$2,834
Mansfield$2,090
Mantua$1,921
Maple Heights$2,073
Maple Ridge$2,084
Maplewood$2,283
Marble Cliff$2,042
Marblehead$2,464
Marengo$2,196
Maria Stein$2,293
Mariemont$2,148
Marietta$2,179
Marion$2,241
Mark Center$2,375
Marne$2,050
Marshallville$1,919
Martel$2,187
Martin$2,408
Martins Ferry$2,085
Martinsburg$2,194
Martinsville$2,299
Marysville$2,099
Mason$2,253
Massillon$1,909
Masury$2,093
Maumee$2,213
Maximo$2,037
Mayfield$2,110
Mayfield Heights$2,035
Maynard$2,012
Mc Comb$2,420
Mc Cutchenville$2,194
Mc Dermott$2,932
Mc Guffey$2,282
McArthur$2,605
McClure$2,451
Mcconnelsville$2,387
McDonald$1,988
Mechanicsburg$2,225
Mechanicstown$2,030
Medina$1,896
Medway$2,191
Melmore$2,354
Melrose$2,336
Mendon$2,411
Mentor$1,807
Mentor-on-the-Lake$1,802
Metamora$2,366
Meyers Lake$2,049
Miami Heights$2,327
Miamisburg$2,501
Miamitown$2,334
Miamiville$2,327
Middle Bass$2,551
Middle Point$2,600
Middlebranch$1,997
Middleburg$2,255
Middleburg Heights$2,029
Middlefield$1,903
Middleport$2,601
Middletown$2,435
Midland$2,434
Midvale$2,130
Milan$2,139
Milford$2,241
Milford Center$2,169
Millbury$2,361
Milledgeville$2,287
Miller City$2,562
Millersburg$1,937
Millersport$2,192
Millfield$2,407
Milton Center$2,363
Mineral City$2,149
Mineral Ridge$1,998
Minerva$2,024
Minerva Park$2,064
Minford$2,886
Mingo$2,675
Mingo Junction$2,255
Minster$2,290
Mogadore$2,014
Monclova$2,207
Monfort Heights$2,276
Monroe$2,424
Monroeville$2,133
Montezuma$2,327
Montgomery$2,223
Montpelier$2,219
Montrose-Ghent$1,891
Montville$1,919
Moraine$2,579
Moreland Hills$1,933
Morgandale$2,023
Morral$2,315
Morristown$2,037
Morrow$2,406
Moscow$2,497
Mount Blanchard$2,465
Mount Carmel$2,213
Mount Cory$2,458
Mount Eaton$1,966
Mount Gilead$2,234
Mount Healthy$2,264
Mount Healthy Heights$2,271
Mount Hope$1,971
Mount Liberty$2,232
Mount Orab$2,700
Mount Perry$2,251
Mount Repose$2,236
Mount St. Joseph$2,414
Mount Sterling$2,320
Mount Vernon$2,148
Mount Victory$2,374
Mowrystown$2,595
Moxahala$2,248
Mulberry$2,235
Munroe Falls$2,004
Murray City$2,384
Nankin$2,092
Napoleon$2,398
Nashport$2,234
Nashville$2,015
Navarre$1,938
Neapolis$2,362
Neffs$1,986
Negley$2,004
Nelsonville$2,435
Nevada$2,284
Neville$2,362
New Albany$1,953
New Athens$2,149
New Baltimore$2,229
New Bavaria$2,488
New Bloomington$2,308
New Boston$3,107
New Bremen$2,249
New Burlington$2,289
New Carlisle$2,158
New Concord$2,135
New Franklin$1,968
New Hampshire$2,229
New Haven$2,230
New Holland$2,314
New Knoxville$2,268
New Lebanon$2,611
New Lexington$2,273
New London$2,191
New Madison$2,315
New Marshfield$2,463
New Matamoras$2,312
New Miami$2,466
New Middletown$2,007
New Paris$2,418
New Philadelphia$1,993
New Plymouth$2,568
New Richmond$2,332
New Riegel$2,278
New Rumley$2,215
New Springfield$2,034
New Straitsville$2,361
New Vienna$2,361
New Washington$2,207
New Waterford$2,088
New Weston$2,396
Newark$2,038
Newburgh Heights$2,243
Newbury$1,939
Newcomerstown$2,085
Newport$2,222
Newton Falls$2,029
Newtonsville$2,365
Newtown$2,177
Ney$2,335
Niles$2,033
North Baltimore$2,248
North Bend$2,301
North Benton$1,991
North Bloomfield$2,113
North Canton$1,855
North College Hill$2,304
North Fairfield$2,271
North Georgetown$2,057
North Hampton$2,250
North Jackson$2,049
North Kingsville$1,986
North Lawrence$1,923
North Lewisburg$2,261
North Lima$1,976
North Madison$1,814
North Olmsted$2,017
North Perry$1,850
North Randall$2,202
North Ridgeville$2,015
North Robinson$2,170
North Royalton$1,898
North Star$2,363
North Zanesville$2,183
Northbrook$2,287
Northfield$1,941
Northgate$2,303
Northridge$2,260
Northwood$2,285
Norton$2,023
Norwalk$2,052
Norwich$2,226
Norwood$2,193
Nova$2,118
Novelty$1,941
Oak Harbor$2,345
Oak Hill$2,847
Oakwood$2,326
Oberlin$1,999
Obetz$2,198
Oceola$2,228
Ohio City$2,563
Okeana$2,450
Okolona$2,448
Old Fort$2,292
Old Washington$2,173
Olde West Chester$2,262
Olmsted Falls$1,982
Ontario$2,105
Orange$1,981
Orangeville$2,040
Oregon$2,348
Oregonia$2,426
Orient$2,166
Orrville$1,945
Orwell$2,027
Osgood$2,301
Ostrander$2,169
Ottawa$2,440
Ottawa Hills$2,383
Ottoville$2,463
Otway$3,182
Overpeck$2,488
Owensville$2,325
Oxford$2,427
Painesville$1,853
Palestine$2,275
Pandora$2,437
Paris$1,931
Park Layne$2,157
Parma$1,991
Parma Heights$2,021
Pataskala$2,115
Patriot$2,659
Paulding$2,310
Payne$2,418
Pedro$2,723
Peebles$2,951
Pemberton$2,246
Pemberville$2,296
Peninsula$1,935
Pepper Pike$2,052
Perry$1,852
Perry Heights$1,940
Perrysburg$2,211
Perrysville$2,063
Petersburg$2,051
Pettisville$2,395
Phillipsburg$2,455
Philo$2,147
Pickerington$2,095
Piedmont$2,199
Pierpont$2,047
Pigeon Creek$1,938
Piketon$2,967
Piney Fork$2,073
Pioneer$2,205
Piqua$2,234
Pitsburg$2,264
Plain City$2,114
Plainfield$2,153
Pleasant City$2,309
Pleasant Grove$2,186
Pleasant Hill$2,170
Pleasant Hills$2,279
Pleasant Plain$2,404
Pleasant Run$2,284
Pleasant Run Farm$2,372
Pleasantville$2,117
Plymouth$2,071
Poland$1,992
Polk$2,006
Pomeroy$2,566
Port Clinton$2,476
Port Jefferson$2,231
Port Washington$2,160
Port William$2,468
Portage$2,285
Portage Lakes$1,944
Portland$2,558
Portsmouth$3,101
Potsdam$2,290
Powell$1,944
Powhatan Point$1,995
Proctorville$2,706
Prospect$2,171
Put In Bay$2,406
Quaker City$2,173
Quincy$2,219
Racine$2,556
Radnor$2,132
Rarden$3,046
Ravenna$1,999
Rawson$2,419
Ray$2,701
Rayland$2,049
Raymond$2,133
Reading$2,199
Reedsville$2,526
Reesville$2,569
Reminderville$1,954
Reno$2,200
Republic$2,352
Reynoldsburg$2,068
Richfield$1,877
Richmond$2,105
Richmond Dale$2,698
Richmond Heights$2,114
Richville$1,976
Richwood$2,284
Ridgeville Corners$2,421
Ridgeway$2,322
Rio Grande$2,610
Ripley$2,861
Risingsun$2,414
Rittman$1,930
Riverlea$2,006
Riverside$2,399
Roaming Shores$2,063
Robertsville$1,991
Rock Camp$2,586
Rock Creek$2,077
Rockbridge$2,464
Rockford$2,379
Rocky Ridge$2,273
Rocky River$1,980
Rogers$2,045
Rome$2,053
Rootstown$2,022
Rosemount$3,113
Roseville$2,252
Rosewood$2,325
Ross$2,476
Rossburg$2,350
Rossford$2,294
Rossmoyne$2,234
Rudolph$2,334
Rushsylvania$2,268
Rushville$2,214
Russells Point$2,286
Russellville$2,674
Russia$2,228
Rutland$2,524
Sabina$2,508
Salem$1,939
Salem Heights$2,121
Salesville$2,191
Salineville$2,020
Sandusky$2,138
Sandyville$2,196
Sarahsville$2,132
Sardinia$2,656
Sardis$2,262
Savannah$2,097
Sawyerwood$1,948
Scio$2,108
Scioto Furnace$2,866
Sciotodale$3,098
Scott$2,628
Scottown$2,776
Seaman$2,898
Sebring$2,070
Sedalia$2,239
Senecaville$2,142
Seven Hills$1,961
Seven Mile$2,323
Seville$1,914
Shade$2,366
Shadyside$2,102
Shaker Heights$2,078
Shandon$2,533
Sharon Center$1,963
Sharonville$2,204
Sharpsburg$2,354
Shauck$2,302
Shawnee$2,295
Shawnee Hills$2,396
Sheffield$2,037
Sheffield Lake$2,024
Shelby$2,038
Sherrodsville$2,072
Sherwood$2,187
Shiloh$2,101
Shreve$1,979
Sidney$2,188
Silver Lake$1,940
Silverton$2,240
Sinking Spring$2,502
Sixteen Mile Stand$2,162
Skyline Acres$2,261
Smithville$1,968
Solon$1,955
Somerdale$2,099
Somerset$2,251
Somerville$2,510
South Amherst$2,021
South Bloomfield$2,245
South Bloomingville$2,584
South Canal$2,033
South Charleston$2,231
South Euclid$2,163
South Lebanon$2,375
South Point$2,665
South Russell$1,866
South Salem$2,766
South Solon$2,406
South Vienna$2,220
South Webster$3,046
South Zanesville$2,179
Southington$2,152
Sparta$2,261
Spencer$1,950
Spencerville$2,395
Spring Valley$2,477
Springboro$2,379
Springdale$2,223
Springfield$2,240
St. Bernard$2,199
St. Clairsville$2,011
St. Henry$2,374
St. Johns$2,246
St. Louisville$2,025
St. Marys$2,216
St. Paris$2,197
Stafford$2,163
Sterling$2,057
Steubenville$2,103
Stewart$2,393
Stillwater$2,146
Stockdale$2,782
Stockport$2,177
Stone Creek$2,097
Stony Prairie$2,160
Stony Ridge$2,330
Stout$2,964
Stoutsville$2,245
Stow$1,940
Strasburg$2,147
Stratton$2,046
Streetsboro$1,865
Strongsville$2,011
Struthers$1,992
Stryker$2,298
Sugar Grove$2,375
Sugarcreek$2,024
Sullivan$2,039
Sulphur Springs$2,149
Summerfield$2,140
Summerside$2,226
Summit Station$2,041
Summitville$2,088
Sunbury$2,046
Swanton$2,278
Sycamore$2,310
Sylvania$2,204
Syracuse$2,430
Tallmadge$1,956
Tarlton$2,345
Taylor Creek$2,301
Terrace Park$2,238
The Plains$2,369
The Village of Indian Hill$2,193
Thompson$1,888
Thornport$2,278
Thornville$2,240
Thurman$2,653
Thurston$2,297
Tiffin$2,141
Tiltonsville$2,047
Timberlake$1,890
Tipp City$2,180
Tippecanoe$2,067
Tiro$2,282
Toledo$2,417
Tontogany$2,348
Toronto$2,096
Tremont City$2,326
Trenton$2,418
Trinway$2,187
Trotwood$2,704
Troy$2,172
Tuppers Plains$2,432
Turpin Hills$2,183
Tuscarawas$2,034
Twinsburg$1,945
Twinsburg Heights$1,943
Uhrichsville$2,115
Union$2,429
Union City$2,488
Union Furnace$2,462
Uniontown$1,873
Unionville$2,047
Unionville Center$2,118
Uniopolis$2,248
University Heights$2,107
Upper Arlington$1,990
Upper Sandusky$2,265
Urbana$2,245
Urbancrest$2,076
Utica$2,104
Valley City$1,952
Valley View$2,050
Valleyview$2,177
Van Buren$2,436
Van Wert$2,457
Vandalia$2,412
Vanlue$2,431
Vaughnsville$2,326
Venedocia$2,559
Vermilion$2,128
Verona$2,379
Versailles$2,212
Vickery$2,324
Vienna$2,142
Vincent$2,191
Vinton$2,920
Wadsworth$1,858
Waite Hill$1,866
Wakefield$2,803
Wakeman$2,127
Walbridge$2,263
Waldo$2,143
Walhonding$2,370
Walton Hills$2,067
Wapakoneta$2,249
Warnock$1,965
Warren$2,073
Warrensville Heights$2,132
Warsaw$2,112
Washington Court House$2,330
Washingtonville$1,969
Waterford$2,188
Waterloo$2,678
Waterville$2,218
Wauseon$2,391
Waverly$2,864
Waverly City$2,859
Wayland$1,992
Wayne$2,336
Waynesburg$2,049
Waynesfield$2,291
Waynesville$2,396
Wellington$2,030
Wellston$2,850
Wellsville$2,024
West Alexandria$2,490
West Carrollton$2,500
West Chester$2,259
West Elkton$2,571
West Farmington$2,087
West Hill$2,093
West Jefferson$2,205
West Lafayette$2,049
West Liberty$2,240
West Manchester$2,420
West Mansfield$2,250
West Millgrove$2,351
West Milton$2,242
West Point$2,048
West Portsmouth$3,022
West Salem$2,054
West Union$2,991
West Unity$2,151
Westerville$1,993
Westfield Center$2,018
Westlake$1,951
Weston$2,245
Westville$2,226
Wetherington$2,268
Wharton$2,313
Wheelersburg$2,947
Whipple$2,204
White Cottage$2,198
White Oak$2,301
Whitehall$2,173
Whitehouse$2,274
Wickliffe$1,867
Wilberforce$2,390
Wilkesville$2,696
Willard$2,240
Williamsburg$2,392
Williamsfield$2,164
Williamsport$2,265
Williamstown$2,253
Williston$2,270
Willoughby$1,849
Willoughby Hills$1,868
Willow Wood$2,663
Willowick$1,894
Willshire$2,626
Wilmington$2,375
Wilmot$2,061
Winchester$2,960
Windham$2,040
Windsor$2,098
Winesburg$2,391
Wingett Run$2,360
Winona$2,039
Wintersville$2,116
Withamsville$2,207
Wolf Run$2,086
Wolfhurst$2,012
Woodlawn$2,214
Woodmere$2,011
Woodsfield$2,249
Woodstock$2,302
Woodville$2,325
Wooster$2,011
Worthington$2,005
Wren$2,598
Wright-Patterson AFB$2,393
Wyoming$2,213
Xenia$2,499
Yellow Springs$2,352
Yorkshire$2,366
Yorkville$2,046
Youngstown$2,087
Zaleski$2,590
Zanesfield$2,280
Zanesville$2,179
Zoar$2,148

The average cost of flood insurance in Ohio is $962 a year (about $80 a month) for policies obtained through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP).

Homeowners insurance does not cover floods, so you have to purchase flood insurance separately.

Lenders usually require flood insurance for mortgages in high-risk flood zones. Flood insurance is also worth considering if you don’t have a mortgage and/or your home is in a low- or moderate-risk area.

Most flood insurance is purchased through the NFIP, which is managed by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). However, several private companies also offer it.

You can look up a home’s flood zone online by visiting the Flood Map Service Center on FEMA’s website.

Methodology

The rates shown in this article are based on an analysis of non-binding quotes obtained from Quadrant Information Services for sample homes in every ZIP code in Ohio. Unless otherwise noted, policies include:

  • Dwelling coverage: $400,000
  • Other structures: $40,000
  • Personal property: $200,000
  • Loss of use: $80,000
  • Personal liability: $100,000
  • Guest medical payments: $5,000
  • Deductible: $1,000

*USAA is only available to current and former members of the military and their families.

No, homeowners insurance is not mandatory under Ohio law, but most lenders require it for a mortgage. If you live in a high-risk flood zone, your lender will likely make you get flood insurance, too.

Ohio requires homeowners insurance companies to provide a 30-day notice before canceling or not renewing your policy. However, as the customer, you can cancel your policy at any time if you are switching companies, selling your home or for any other reason.

Homeowners insurance automatically includes mine subsidence coverage in Ohio’s 26 “mandatory coverage” counties. The coverage is offered on an optional basis in nine other counties. Mine subsidence occurs when a home sinks into a mine under its foundation.